whatwhat say what

If it wasn't for BBBJB and dodgy knees Tredrea would've been the best key forward in the competition during his peak years

his notes are detailed tho...

terrifically exciting for the young fella fingers crossed for a gun of a son

it would definitely be limited you'd think the likes of jones, neitz, schwarz, yze, and white, would be likely candidates based upon their current body of work from 2000 to now current players under consideration would be gawn, oliver, and possibly petracca depending on what sort of impact they have as players over the next half a decade or more you'd also hope that young players such as jackson, pickett, rivers, and who knows who else would be seriously considered depending on their next decade of performance for the most part, we haven't had many 'star' performers this century; we've been fairly woeful on field

Reckon he’ll be back on fox footy within first couple of rounds

goodwin love child

forward you'd think if we need him but coming off an injury- and illness-interrupted preseason, hard to see him being 'match fit' for round 1

he doesn't have mfcss, which is remarkable really given everything he has witnessed when injured and / or on field must be the kiwi in him

so far definitely ruled out: weideman - hore - b brown likely ruled out: viney - brayshaw - hibberd - vandenberg - smith possible squad: B: Lockhart - May - Lever HB: Hunt - Tomlinson - Salem C : Langdon - Petracca - Melksham HF: Fritsch - McDonald - Spargo F: Jackson - M Brown - Pickett Foll: Gawn - Oliver - Harmes I/c: Rivers - Neal-Bullen - Sparrow - Baker Emerg: Jones - Rosman - Jordon - Jetta

mitch brown, come on down

love the projecting that is going on in this thread goodwin? unhappy! richardson? clueless! taylor? loves midgets! lamb? overrules everyone! i still maintain that drafting is an extremely inexact science; you're picking children who're 17 and hoping that by the time they're 24 they will be regular senior afl players it's very much pot luck imo

just one...and then another one...and another...and another...and another...

reckon he'll lead with 'it's a proud day...'?

sounds like we were pretty set on bowey and laurie, and the decision behind carroll or rosman was line ball

gulp...

it's not a trick, @58er, it's an illusion; a trick is something whores do for money... they have both been on our list for three years and have obvious deficiencies that look likely to hold them back from being regular best 22 players they've clearly got heaps of talent - you have to in order to be on an afl list - but both have been in / out of the side on a regular basis due to the missing elements in their ability

i don't overly rate smith or lockhart tbh @58er - both are classic 'good, ordinary' players, no different to the likes of o mac or godfrey or other battlers that we've had along the journey

joel smith finished the year playing pretty well on the mid-to-tall forwards - his game against gw$ when he pantsed jeremy cameron being a case in point i think we were generally speaking going wih the geelong model of mid-tall defence - no 'small' per se

wish these match day threads - at the least - would stay on the main page that was a really impressive win and the kids are REALLY exciting

he's a bit of a nong https://www.sen.com.au/news/2021/02/05/why-kane-cornes-is-worried-about-melbourne-in-2021 Kane Cornes is concerned Melbourne will let themselves off the hook this season, after key recruit Ben Brown was sidelined by injury.

the notion of spargo turning into our robbie gray type sounds very promising bit of a myth re distance of his kicking tho; i seem to remember he had no issues dobbing one from just inside the 50 arc in a final

bruce francis seems like a complete and utter nutbar

i think there's an obvious distinction between 'best 22 / next 22' and 'likely 22 for rd 1' hore and b brown are definitely out, and the likes of viney, brayshaw, hibberd, and vandenberg will be up against it for rd 1 given their lack of / interrupted pre-season preparation

listened to the footyology podcast this week; neither rohan connolly nor mark fine thought we were a chance of finals, let alone premiership contenders mark fine is a saints nuffy tho, and his views are almost universally terrible - but he's right that we've been consistency mediocre for a long time

i would have thought arthroscopy indicates they don't know what's wrong with his knee - explorative rather than determinative won't play til round 6 at the earliest i suspect