drdrake

I think we all need to understand the financial position of the club, we can't afford to sack a coach and the AFL doesn't have the money to give us to do so. We are stuck with Goodwin, we need to surround him with high quality assistant coaches.

We can't compare our forward line to St Kilda or GWS, they have genuine talls forwards and high quality small forwards. The reason why we over handball is that is were our free players are, we push so many players to the contest with in 3-5m that when we get the ball the kick option is 3-4 opposition player sitting back waiting. This is our number 1 issue our game plan that was a carry on from Roos is to get players around the contest. We essentially don't play HFF's they push into the midfield, that leaves 2 defenders just sitting back waiting for the kick into our forward 50m arc. We need to maintain the ball until our players push from the contest forward, unfortunately we aren't good enough to maintain the ball we turn it over and our opponent has loose players everywhere as our guys are working hard forward to be an option, the opposition just holds a zone and waits for us to turn the ball over. Simple solution, have your forward 6 maintain position at least make it a contest when we go inside our forward 50m arc. Make teams beat you in your midfield and not beat you attacking of their Half Back Line. Every team knows the game we are going to play and are happy to let us do this as they know they can attack with speed of Half back. The last quarter the first 4 minutes, 3 intercept marks to Richmond in our forward 50m arc. When we are outnumbered like we are Richmond used the spare players to block and protect. The one's that frustrated me though was when we would win the centre clearance and our forwards were so far behind their opponent, the opposition should never take a uncontested mark inside you 50m arc after a centre clearance. Goodwin has a choice, keep playing the same way or make a change, I can't believe he didn't change our game style after 2019. It worked in 2018 because TMac was grabbing everything or at least bringing it to ground, add in Weidermans 4-5 game cameo we looked like a million dollars as our tall forwards were creating a contest. This hasn't happened in 18 months and the fact we don't play 2 tall forwards with the game style we play is a massive selection error. We play mid size forwards for run and defensive pressure, they offer little of both. At least Pickett has show he is willing to chase hard to put pressure on. If we don't maintain our 6 forwards nothing will change.

Really it is 20 years of drafting and trading on this topic though we drafted a midfield of contested ball players for Paul Roos game plan, it works if you hit targets but our mids just turn the ball over by hand and foot

We drafted the same players, again we went extremes, under Dean Bailey we went for runners, mobility his game plan was based around attack then Neeld and Roos wanted defensive mindset contested football and now we are left with an group that can't play the game as required today because we can't keep the football. If you turn the ball over like we do and enter the forward 50m arc like we do we just can't play the game style we want to play. It is simple push forwards onto the ball and out number at the contest, issue is we are all around the ball once it gets out we are out numbered, once it hits our forward 50m arc it is 2 v 4 ball goes in straight back out with overlap runners our back 6 have no chance the ball comes in that quick. Until we can keep the football we need to keep our forwards forward at least give us a chance to keep the footy forward

The only first year player I had was Jackson, Weiderman needs 4 to 5 games crack at, Bennell is 28 yo top line talent when fit and Bedford second year. My team Jetta May Smith Lockhart Lever Hibbard Langdon Petracca Tomlinson Hannah TMac Bennell Kossie Weiderman Fritsch Gawn Salem Oliver Jackson, Bedford, Jones, Harmes

If Brown is in our best team we are stuffed. Jones and Jetta yep for sure they will make us better. Jones comes in for Viney, jetta for Rivers. But i would like to see Jackson Weiderman, Bedford and Bennell as well. Some height speed and skill

No point playing Brown, our season is cooked so its about getting games into the future. In Jackson, Weiderman, Bennell, Bedford Out Melksham, Hunt, AVB, Brayshaw

Our club doesn't demand excellence, winning is not an expectation, in fact we expect to lose and accept losing. This isnt a Goodwin thing this is ingrained in our clubs culture.

Blame paul roos, these are the type of players he wanted contested players. We loaded up on them the issue we have is we will the footy but turn it over because we have poor disposl skills

That Oliver turnover just summed up the game. We lose games by turnovers, i say this every week all our opponents need to do is sit across our half forward and we will kick it to you. We dont have the foot skills to play a 4 or 5 man forward line

They should drive the buses make these blokes soul search on an overnight bus trip to Sydney

This could be 100points

Stop pushing forwards into the midfield go one on one in our forward line. We need to stop Richmond attacking of half back.

Hopefully some of our senior players stay home. Move May forward

Can someone remind me the reasoning behind our forward line. It isn't forward pressure ball goes in straight out score

We have played 2-3 quarters of decent football for the entire season to date, we have massive issues our mids are slow and have big issues kicking the football. The reason why we bomb it long is we don't have the confidence in hitting a target 20-30m away and we would rather bomb it to a 3 on 1, 50m away.

We are tanking for North Melbourne

And that is why we have drafted Jackson, a Grundy clone with a better leap. Would love for the club to back the kid and let him have a run around the MCG, let Max Ruck 60% and push deep forward 35%, Jackson 40% Ruck and deep forward. At least then we have tall targets deep.

Unless there is a dramatic turn around in Co-vid numbers I doubt this season will go ahead. A selfish few that couldn't follow rules are going to stuff it up for all return to sport and more importantly the Victorian economy.

I thought we were playing Freo in Melbourne anyway? The AFL know that the WA teams, Geelong and Collingwood need to go into 14 days quarantine once they arrive in WA. Good chance we will head to QLD as we haven't played the 2 sides up there as yet, plus we can play the SA sides up there as well.

That would have to be the most boring game of football I've seen. It was 2 teams that had such a great fear of losing that they didn't give themselves a chance to win the game. Defensive mindsets both sides, it was just ugly. Our issues, to many underdone players. Are we looking at 2020 to be a development year to see who is in our best 22. Bennell would have offered more in 65% game time that most our players. A lot of posters have already covered this, outside Pickett(developing) and Petracca we have a D grade players up forward. It is a massive concern for now and the future we don't have a player on our list that can play as an influential key forward, we have a fleet of midsize forwards that are irrelevant due the their ability and more important they way we play. We can't bomb into our forward line if we don't have the talls to bring it to ground and more importantly the smalls to keep it in there. I'm assuming that is our plan, use the small mid forwards to keep the ball inside our forward 50m arc any score through pressure, the issue is we don't lay many tackles inside 50, we don't keep the ball in there, why our forwards push so high up the ground when we get the ball inside 50, it is always a 3 V 1 and it comes straight back out. Every team knows this and lets us push forwards into our mid field as they know we will turn it over going forward and they can attacked from their defensive 50m arc. Our forwards/Mids don't work hard enough to protect the fat side of the ground and really they are stuffed because they work so hard winning the ball just to see it come straight back out. An idea, lets try winning a game by having our forwards play forward, I loved the Daniher years as this was his game style if you kick 14 goals we will kick 15 goals, simple win by high scoring, attacking football back your mids and defenders, to win the football and your forwards to score. I would rather lose playing attacking football than the way we have lost over the past 2 years.

The country and state are going into massive debt to get through Co-vid, I'm sure giving AFL clubs large sums of cash for training facilities is extreme low on their priority list. Unless of course your are Geelong/Hawthorn or Collingwood. Giving Melbourne money won't win anybody an election or even a seat at Federal or State level and that is all it is about.

So lets stop picking him for the player he was.

No Tom isn't a Gun, he is a bloke that had a good season and was almost out the door, he found life going forward but hasn't fired a shot for since 2018. The big concern is marking, he always has been a good contested mark, now he just can't grab them and is being pushed off the ball to easy. We put all our eggs in the 2018 finals combination of Weid and TMac, we have no developing tall forwards at our Club, Jackson will be a ruck not forward, even Petty is a defender that we are trying to do a Tmac with and make him a forward.

Can we have an intraclub at the mcg