Redleg

Correct.

Played well too.

Sylvia at 185cms in the ruck is a joke. With Bate back, Miller or Dunn (if he is in) can have a few minutes there, as they are far bigger than Sylvia. Sylvia can then slot into their forward position while they are rucking. IMO it is ridiculous to ruck Sylvia and probably get him hurt as well. If Spencer, Gawn or Fitzpatrick kick on we won't have this discussion.

I understand that Beamer feels upset and wants to contest the charge, but a week's rest after a hard game last week and the chance to play your 100th in front of 50000 at the G against the scum, instead of at Skilled with few demon fans present, is not a bad alternative.

Disagree on Warnock. He was injured. He is in our best 22.

Doubt it after playing in 80% humidity.

He is only on the Rookie List.

He is 25. Mature age rookie for Dons.

Amazing. His best game for the Dees and a major part of the win and you have him gone.

He made no head contact luckily as shown in the replays. He hit him in the side as Tony Shaw said and added that the Port player was acting a fair bit for a free.

Well done Dees. Scultz and Davenport should have holidays for the punches to Garland behind play. Beamer should be safe as no head contact, he hit him in the side as the replays showed. I would also use Foxtel audio where Tony Shaw says the Port player acted for the free a fair bit. Then again Beamer got three weeks for missing a player. Chad Cornes could be in trouble for the forearm to Watts' head.

Considering Melksham got one for 14 possessions he should bolt one in.

And what makes me want to puke is that Carlscum got 260 of them at $5.5k each. They paid $1.4m for 260 and we paid $2m for 92. They will not struggle financially anymore and that really upsets me.

Only difference is that in the Age it said we paid $2m instead of $400K, a significant difference.

I thought the other one was Jackson Trengrove.

Not the game for two ruckmen. With 80% humidity and possible rain, in the words of the Coach, "the ball will be a cake of soap".

What was that, I couldn't hear you, what did you say?

Agree, other than thugs and snipers, who deserve some bagging.

Now that's my kind of forward.

So would Swans and Pies.

Umpires wore "lime green not yellow".

Hit the nail on the head. If you watch the kick outs saturday, the kicker was searching desperately for someone to make position and no one did. We were static. That is attitude and it appeared poor early on and was borne out by our lowest number of tackles. WC did the 1 per centers and we didn't. That said the coaching was also poor as was the disposal which was atrocious. Handballs falling short or missing by metres is poor and kicking to ankle height or over the head is also poor. Le Cras received great disposal and marked accordingly.

I would want him to be in the best Casey players 3 times before i would play him.

Didn't play two weeks ago and wasn't in best players this week. Maybe that is why.

Maybe not. He was coming off the ground with two trainers when Brown who had put him downshortly before followed him and had a go. Jackson was probably dazed and reacted. He was leaving the field and was entitled to be allowed to do so.