Everything posted by Redleg
-
The No T$ No B$ Thread
It was and only MFC type luck, they used the last review on a certain failure. Captain admitted Cummings told him not to review, as it was a certain not out. And Lyon misses a stumping he wouldn't have missed since he was in kinder, with Leach half way down the pitch, trying to get back.
-
The Writing Was/Is on the Wall
Macca says Hi. Jade Rawlings also says a little hello.
- The No T$ No B$ Thread
-
We'll Have To Keep Garlett
It is unfair that the dole has not kept pace with inflation.
-
Petracca on the Move?
That's the attitude.
-
We'll Have To Keep Garlett
It is difficult to analyse footballers, when you are sloshed on those cheap casks of wine you guzzle each night, before retiring to the dungeon.
-
We'll Have To Keep Garlett
IMO he is finished as an AFL player.
-
Review One player at a time
Might not have, but would you have predicted it?
-
Official Delistings?
Not disagreeing with that.
-
Review One player at a time
Not at all. If May stays fit next year, no question mark at all.
-
Review One player at a time
Agree. Suppose we should have guessed he would be injured all year.
-
Official Delistings?
With Lewis gone, we have how many players over 30? Oh that's right, only one. He of course won 3 B & F's in a row and stayed loyal while we were sh-t. He is not in our worst 8 players and therefore on a number of grounds deserves another year. Would hurt the club massively through the AFL if we dumped him this year.Would speak volumes of our culture. Hardly soft I would have thought. PS. Don't bring up Hodge, Lewis and Roughhead, as the Hawks have half their list over 30.
-
Official Delistings?
Might not be, but he deserves another year and will get it. Where he plays will be up to his form. We have plenty to move on, while keeping him and he will likely retire next year. Can't get rid of 15 players, even though we on DL might want to.
-
Review One player at a time
I guess we should have used the old hindsight and traded him.
- The No T$ No B$ Thread
-
Round 23 Non MFC Games
Salem always has hit his targets, up until the last quarter of this season.
-
Round 23 Non MFC Games
Disgusting soft free to Reiwoldt. Like the non existent arm chop to Larkey yesterday. Pathetic.
-
Review One player at a time
4-6 and 2 year contract left. Wonderful.
-
Review One player at a time
AVB. ?
- The No T$ No B$ Thread
-
Round 23 Non MFC Games
Funny then, that a sh-t club like ours, as the media and footy world see us, with a crap coach, selfish players, who are poorly skilled, should have beaten the Eagles twice this year, but for massive injuries, poor umpiring and shocking kicking for goal. No credit given to us for those and many other close losses this year. It's time to adopt the John Northey mantra of "it's us against the rest of them" and come out fighting next year. We need a hard edge on the ground from our team and in the public forum from our FD. Get fit, learn how to tackle, work on our skills, make the game plan simpler, bring in some new talent and pace, get rid of those that aren't good enough and reward those that play hard team footy. Do that and we are back as a competitor and a relevant team.
-
Official Delistings?
We probably need to make about 8-10 changes, so besides the obvious few, some more players will be moved on. Maynard and Lewis are gone, Keilty, JKH and Garlett are likely too. Tim Smith and Josh Wagner could also be added and Walker the rookie is probably gone. That is 8 and maybe another 1-2 could and should be traded, like ANB who IMO has no future with us. His mate Billy might get another year, with Josh's brother Corey.
-
My 3 word player analysis V North
Not sure how you did that because that wasn’t my post, I posted an answer, but no biggy.
- The No T$ No B$ Thread
- The No T$ No B$ Thread