old55

When my nerves have flared over the past few weeks I've pictured Jack Viney standing in front of the Cup. Anyone else who wants it has to get past him - he won't let it happen.

If we go with Jones this week, barring something unforeseen, we pretty much have to go with him next week given the twins on the way. I'm not feeling it.

Good to see you here! They're in number order, and so is the Interchange, I'm not reading in.

Fort on the Geelong emergency list is interesting, I wonder if there's a question over Stanley, Blicavs or Ratugolea?

I'd guess that since the entire squad is in WA that they are all training together - and that's why you see Majak there. There has been no match in our week off and we will have been running match simulation, you need a full squad to do that as effectively as possible. He's ruck depth and he's most likely to be rucking for the B team in match simulations against Gawn and Jackson in the A team. The club isn't going to be sending non-best 26 players somewhere else to train.

Do you speak like this in person?

Chris Scott's Geelong beat Collingwood 3 times in 2011 to win the flag. They were the only 3 games Collingwood lost for the season going 22-3, pretty amazing!

I think Cerra would be a great get and I agree that Oliver and Petracca are critical members of our midfield. But I don't think we're as thin as you believe. Sure we would suffer if one of them went down but we have Brayshaw on the wing to come back into the midfield and Viney, Harmes, JJ and Sparrow who have all proven themselves capable and the latter two will only be better next year. For example: Petracca, Brayshaw, Viney, Harmes, Sparrow in the middle and JJ to the wing is still competitive I don't think we need to sell the farm to get Cerra which is what it may take.

He's not Clayton Oliver so he's no good. OK. Yes, you're totally entitled to your opinion. Simon Goodwin has the completely the opposite opinion.

No, we need to win the Premiership this year.

David Zaharakis may have been delisted just in time.

Stakes are very high but we wanted it that way. I'm grateful we have the opportunity to put the final stamp on those smug campaigners' era. Max, Clarrie, Jack and Steven are between them and the GF, Geelong aren't going there.

Do it Clint!

.

The "fact" that there is only a 5% chance in the last 20 years that the Premier will have kicked more behinds than goals in the final series is NOT the same as - if you kick more behinds than goals you have a only 5% chance of being Premier. The comparative data you are looking for is how many time finals teams have kicked more behinds than goals. Think about it this way - how many times has the Runner-up kicked more behinds than goals?

I 've been on the bandwagon that poor scoring conversion is a big risk for us this year and has cost us games. But your "5% chance" reasoning is flawed. If it's correct does that mean if we kick more goals than behinds there's a 95% chance we'll win the flag? No team in the last 20 years has won the flag with a 208cm bald ruckman - we're clearly no chance ...

Accurate analysis. We're in flag mode and Smith wasn't good enough at that level on Cameron who is probably the best going. Different opposition may be a different proposition. Port have some class small forwards.

There's 45 on the list: 26 in Adelaide including JJ, Jones, Melky, Hibbo and there's 16 in the photo. That means 3 missing? I guess someone took the photo - who's not in it - Vanders, Thommo and Declase?

11 goals 23 behinds - 12 behinds kicked, 11 rushed by the Hawthorn defence to regain possession of the ball. It was a tactic by Clarkson.

McGowan was just re-elected with a Massive Majority reflecting WA's approval of his approach. Once vaccination gets to 70% and then 80% McGowan will be faced with some challenging choices.

Essendon just bombing into the forward 50. Dogs with so many left footed play-makers want to play the right hand wing going forward.

I agree - I've had the GFG for as long as I can remember, probably 15 years, including the Neeld years. I hope if we do win the flag this year there is some sort of exclusive event for those us in that position.

If Green pushed Stevic over or hit him he'd be looking at YEARS not weeks. Get some perspective.

So built his reputation on "Oliver is a good player", OK?

I see Kane Cornes is saying "ask Matt Stevic what he thought because Stevic is a 400 game, 8 GF umpire". That's exactly why this should not be a factor - a 15 year old rising umpire is not Matt Stevic and players need to understand that respect must be shown. Greene cannot under any circumstances play again this year, it will be a total joke if he does, three weeks minimum penalty.