Beetle

All eggs in one basket for short term “success” that won’t amount to anything. Meanwhile they sacrifice any decent young players coming into the club for the next two years.

Sorry guys, all the nuffies on the Melbourne Facebook pages are up in arms, so I’m afraid this trade period is officially a failure. May as well close the thread please Admins. Ive given us a B, however our trade period shouldn’t be officially graded until a minute before our first selection on draft night. If we manage to walk into the draft with picks 6, 8, a second rounder and get a 2020 first round pick back then it’s an A grade from me.

Not if they make another pick swap prior to us it isn’t.

Which of the idiots are we talking about exactly @Pennant St Dee?

I don’t believe that will happen. I truly believe we made this deal with North today off the back of what GWS has promised us by the end of tomorrow. I guess we shall see...either way I am happy with where we are at.

If this happens and we manage to go into the draft with 6, 8 (possibly a fourth rounder included) and get back into the the first round next year for pick 3, it will be a massive win for Mahoney and his team.

I like the bloke but he had an appalling season. Almost embarrassing to watch at times. Unfortunately has become a real plodder that throws his head around to demonstrate desperation. I hope for his and the clubs sake he can turn it around but I highly doubt it.

If GWS manage to pry pick 4 from Adelaide somehow and offer it to us with sweeteners (Additional pick/player) then it’s a no brainer. ”Here is pick 3, take it but leave player x alone”.

Could not kick a drop punt that spins correctly to save his life.

I’d put good money on us not going into the draft with pick 3.

Couldn’t be happier with the way the club is going about this trade period so far. Absolutely ecstatic to have Langdon on board. Damn this club!!! They are sucking me back in again as usual!

Jason McCartney v Josh Mahoney

Would we consider pick 6 and GWS’ 2020 first round pick for pick 3?

Also said on channel 7 Geelong are likely to chat to us for pick 3.

Channel 7 news reporting GWS will offer us pick 6 with a big offer for pick 3.

If only we could sign him and find him the perfect life coach..

I dunno...

*His hopeless, glad we didn’t get him.

Preferred him to have completed the ninja warrior course for the interview?

Jack Crisp just asked whether he thinks Elliott will stay l, on channel 10 news. Paused for a moment, then answered “yeah I think he will stay” then added that’s obviously the only answer he can give, before ending with “I hope he stays”.

Haha isn’t she also the one who got scalded on here for posting a photo wearing cats scarf during a game?

For the sake of the state of Victoria, I am on the Giants bandwagon.

The club in its wisdom are seizing the opportunity to have him walk through the mounting yard one last time in order to push his price up. They’ll be oiling him up to the hilt to have him glistening. ”We convinced him he had to run in the grand final sprint to get the contract over the line haha” said Mahoney.

Thank god for that. I can barely contain myself.

I don’t know “many”...Central Coast Mariners went down that path too...