BDA

I didn’t pay enough attention when we recruited him tbh but if this is his level of output then it’s a black mark against our recruitment team for sure.

Looks like a win win trade to me.

Daisy Pearce shows these three up every week. They should put her on the selection panel!

Well done Trac. B&F and AA. Fantastic season.

Melksham Fritch AVB have had their performances rightly panned this season but Tomlinson has slipped under the radar. He’s been a major disappointment. 5 years at $500k is a big investment. I want to see a lot more from him next year. I suggest he’s paired with Steven May this pre-season so he can learn how to turn a bad first season into a successful second.

Tomlinson, weid and Jackson can pinch hit. Not sure where Bradtke is at. I think this is the year to trade him to maximise the return. Giants and Swans are pretty desperate for a ruckman and Pruess is by far the best back-up in the comp. they don’t grow on trees so I’d drive a hard bargain. Swans have pick 22. I’d aim for that.

Beautiful kick and much loved character. Didn’t have the temperament of professionalism to optimise his undoubted talent but 174 games is still an outstanding effort. Will always be welcome at the footy club. Thanks for the memories and best of luck in retirement Jack.

Why should any capable, sought after, ambition footballer hang around Melbourne in the hope that the club will become successful. In a short career we’ve just wasted 2 years of their time. We’re a middling, mid ranked club. Our coach is second rate. We’ve completely and utterly failed to build on our great run to the prelim in 2018 (it was a fluke, a mirage). All the momentum from that run was killed stone dead by the abomination that was 2019. Some improvement this year but nothing to suggest we’re building something lasting. Nothing to suggest we’re building towards a flag or top 4. Seriously, who here is confident we’ll even play finals next year. If I’m Jack Viney, I’m seriously considering Geelong’s offer. He’s done his bit for this club. Go play for a team that offers finals footy, a great lifestyle for his young family in a footy mad town. I wouldn’t blame him if he decides to go. Oliver. He could play in midfield for Richmond or another top club. I think he’d be mad to sign a new contract with us this off season. If the club are serious about success they would bring in a new coach to bring instil some hope and optimism into this group of players. Player retention – another reason to get rid of Goodwin.

I think he’s a very good option. Strong mark and an accurate kick. And he’s still only 27. I think he’s worth a second rounder. Not sure how much coin he’d demand but if we can move Tmac on then he would be a definite upgrade.

I love Maxy but I reckon Steven May is our captain

The vibe seems pretty downbeat. May and Viney speeches short and muted.

No qualms with the decision. Best of luck to all 3. I hope they’ve put some thought into and prepared for their post footy careers as a I can’t see them getting picked up by other clubs. It’s a tough time to be looking for work.

Hard to know what to make of this story. Only Harley can answer why he chose to leave the HUB in clear breach of the rules. I was in favor of giving him another year but if he is going to miss 4 games of a potentially 17 game season then that changes the equation somewhat. Plus its obvious his decision making and judgment are highly suspect (Seriously, how do you run out of petrol and get picked up by the police). He’s an accident waiting to happen. Its unfortunate for Harley but this club has enough problems. Delist and move on.

Thanks for pointing these out Bobby. Not easy to acknowledge when the red mist has descended. To those positives I would add Burgess. The team have looked fit and primed. I think we won a number of games in the 4th quarter off the back of his fitness program. Ultimately I think this season is a failure. We are not getting the best from this group of players and I lay the blame at Goodwin’s feet. My wish list for the summer: 1. A new coach preferably Clarkson 2. A KPF (Hogan, Brown or Cameron) 3. Another Langdon type for the opposite wing

done and dusted.

poor kick hoges.

Freo not going away. Go Freo

needs to slot this.. and he does. good lad

we should trade for Fyfe.

rotten turnover

what a goal from fyfe.

Freo to give the doggies a game but ultimately one team playing for finals and the other thinking of the beach. Doggies by 25 points.

I didn’t know what to expect when I saw the title of this thread! I don’t get the groping or the finger up the [censored] thing amongst teammates. If a bloke tried that in my time he would have been decked. 2 consenting adults in the privacy of their homes well that’s their business. Having said that its obvious the boys were in on the joke so what does it matter other than just don’t get caught on camera. The blood suckers in the press are always looking for a beat-up so don’t give them the opportunity.

too injury prone

Couldn't agree more. Bring back Jesse I say.