Smokey

Remove hogan from that equation I think as he has seriously struggled to have any impact whatsoever against good teams this year

Love a good armchair expert comment like this. Get your hand off it mate - playing top level sport is never easy for anyone.

It's really hard to reconcile your username with that last sentence

Can't argue with that mate. I guess there's a fine line between having faith in your system and game plan and being dynamic when required. I'm just hopefully Goody finds that balance sooner than later.

I liked Goody's presser today. Although his game day coaching hasn't been great, I feel he is getting better at being more dynamic and identifying issues as they happen. It's only his second year with with the reigns after all. When we lose as many games as we have this year by a couple of kicks, it's really just up to the players at that point. We're closer than ever before, and I'm backing Goody in as he seems to have the respect and buy-in from the playing group. That's one of the most important aspects of being the head coach in my opinion, the rest can and will improve in time.

Thank you sir

Dunn would be nice to have right now!

Second this. I can't figure out how a statement like that could be inferred from this interview.

Come to the realization that we are perhaps better off without Hogan ...

Not taking anything personally, just calling out the rubbish comment about how people should feel ashamed for being critical of Hogan simply because he has now become injured

Yes. Yes you are.

Its the same commentators that are pumping us up in the first place. I really can't understand it - the media pumps us up and then has a go at us for getting pumped up when we don't perform. It's mind boggling really. The media loves using terms like "drinking their own bathwater" when it was the media themselves that run the bath and made us get in. sick of the commentary these days - there is way too much of it. Its hard for the average punter to form an opinion on anything footy related when we have the opinions of an army of ex players rammed down our throat every 10 mins, 7 days a week. I miss the 90's. Footy was simpler and far more enjoyable.

What does this even mean? Because some of us entertained the idea of trading him that we someone willed this injury upon him? Or that we are somehow relishing on a fine young man struck down by injury? That's enough internet for you today, champ.

I was just mucking around mate, no offence intended at all

Settle down old boy, you don't know me

Ok everyone - the baby boomers have spoken. We are not to discuss anything other than whether we won or not.

I appreciate that, but our goal kicking - on averages - has been pretty good this year. Sunday hurt big time, but there no reason to start rewriting history. Everyone should probably take a deep breath, remember we are missing 4 of our top 10 players right now (two of whom we should get back next week). We are also missing Billy Stretch right when he came into some form, same goes for Joel Smith who I thought was becoming really good. We'll beat West Coast.

Aren't we ranked top 3 for set shot accuracy this year?

Because we are a very ordinary football team

Calm down, the coach cant do anything on game day about horrible goal inaccuracy. We were good enough other than that.

Media - "Melbourne are playing really well at the moment and are winning games" *Melbourne lose a game* Media - "Melbourne got ahead of themselves. Melbourne drank there own bathwater." Yawn ... According to the media its not possible for us to lose a game simply by being outplayed on the day. It happens you know.

Home game mate

Why wouldn't you like that? We've only dropped 1 game all year that was a gimme, yet dropped plenty of games such as whats ahead in our last 3 weeks.

Agreed. Rather the boys be under pressure for the weeks leading in rather than walking through easy games and then trying to get ready for real games in September.

We will finish top 4 this year. The boys are ready.