Billy

Which is?

So true but let’s not compare Clarry with McClean?

Can someone please tell me if there’s a rift between Oliver & Viney, or just our flakey supporters jumping at shadows

That’s what we should all think of him instead of criticism

This post is so far from the truth it’s not funny, haven’t seen much evidence of him sooking it up on field. He hasn’t regressed, he had a few bad turnovers by foot during the year & the media & some very short sighted supporters have jumped all over him. l honestly thought he was easily top 3 in the b&f, probably 2 And as for saying he’s got a can’t be [censored] attitude, he in my opinion was busting a gut more than any other player. He and a precious few have had plenty of players weighing them down He’s 23yo and has carried the midfield for nearly 4 years Totally disagree with everything you’ve said

Trade the McDonald brothers for Connor Blakley & Jesse Hogan

Was going to argue, but then noticed your pic profile Dopethrone, one of the geats?

Nope

Agree, can’t understand why the Pies would want him, they have an excellent backline Wish him well if it happens he’s put his body on the line for 12 years buts can’t see him playing much next season

He should’ve finished 3rd, was better than Langdon

That’s absolute rubbish, how in Gods name do you know what he’s thinking?? Its not always about making finals, there’s friendships, loyalty & integrity as well Not all all players jump ship just for the sake of making finals Clarry to me is a loyal bloke not a money hungry grub that would walk away for the sake of a premiership

He’s our best player period and would be the last player on our list to trade. So if he’s not happy the club needs to make him happy

GWS, Sydney & Hawthorn all have pics in the 20s I’d be pushing for that If Smith was 29-30 I’d jump at it but 32 & injuries in the 2nd half of 2020, huge question mark

If they all want him, get one of them to give up 28,22, or 21

Why?? Swapping an in demand 25yo ruckman for a 32yo, surely we’ve gone past recycled old premiership players Sydney, GWS & Hawthorn are after him & he’s got 2 years left on his contract, play hardball with him & we should get overs

Totally agree with Oliver, don’t blame him for being [censored] off with 5th, he was top 3 every day of the week Viney has the runs on the board for a 3 year contract & had a better 2020 than you give him credit for Stats aren’t the be all & end all of a players performance, you know better than that Pickett

I think Hibberd has earned his, has been a warrior for us

Cripps is a poor mans Clayton Oliver

Don’t be ridiculous, l agree 5 years is to much, but you don’t offer a 1 year deal to a player that just finished 3rd in the b&f

He really should’ve been top 2 or3

If we replaced Collingwood in the 8 West Coast would’ve beaten us by 10 goals

Don’t want him, 4th club & he’s not that good

Agree Maxy cost us a bit this season, his disposal by foot was abysmal May was fantastic a lot better than Darcy Moore but hey May doesn’t play for Collingwood

I hope he gets a 1 year contract but don’t think he will

Correct, mentally weak as soon as they get into a positions to have an impact they fall apart Classic example is Hunt & Tracc carrying on and laughing at 3/4 time, what happens Essendon kick the next 4 goals and we fall in Totally unprofessional Fail