Billy

Is this the same player that has been roundly criticised by most supporters over the years for running around like a chook with its head cut off & the worst disposal in the team. Now he’s one of our best & we’re up in arms about him being traded Which one is it???

You’re kidding aren’t you, why would we want to pick up an average reject Its amazing how the draft period turns hacks into superstars

There’s no better way to show your desire for the footy than in a cut throat final He was unsighted from the first bounce 4 kicks 3 handballs at 42% No thanks

Was he playing on Saturday night!!!!!! Didn’t see him

He’s a pro, deserves a good run at it Good luck Jake

Yes he is

Have you heard of Clayton Oliver?

Stretch - a momentum killer What momentum!!!

Casey’s finest

Do people just automatically put Gawn as the best player? Not a huge influence in my opinion 6. Harmes 5. Petracca 4. Lever 3.Gawn 2. Salem 1. ???? 6 votes is way to many for this mob, it’s to hard most weeks to find 6 good players

The skill level of this mob is pathetic

Why do we seem to miss the scrutiny from the media? Is it because we are still an insignificant club & can’t be trusted & no one cares. We have been woeful, from a preliminary final to second bottom must be one of the biggest falls from grace in the history of the AFL yet it’s “Oh yeah that’s Melbourne move on” Nearly every expert tipped us top 4, so it’s totally unexpected yet unexplainable, but it’s just zero care factor from everyone Could you imagine the uproar if it was Collingwood or Richmond & why does Goodwin & the players seem to get away scot free?

6. Oliver 5. Fritsch 4. Salem 3. May 2. Harme 1. Brayshaw

May for captain 2020 Pruess a liability, can’t even handball Lockhart non existent Jetta is not fit & needs to be put on ice for next season Other than that a good effort

Pruess can’t even handball!!

Max has been ordinary

Why don’t you Farrk off ya [censored]

Fair enough l thought we had something in common supporting the same team, but l forgot l support you criticise Thanks for setting me straight

Get over it mate, he’s back up at best He will get a game next week if Max is out

Hibberd May Hore Fritsch Frost Salem Hunt. Brayshaw Baker Petracca Weideman Harmes Lockhart Tmac Smith Gawn Oliver Viney Int. Jones Lewis Lever Neal-Bullen

5. Oliver 4. Viney 3.Max 2. Lockhart 1. Trac

Forget Jeffry & Lockhart’s the one, really clean with ball in hand and great pressure

Some supporters don’t know how to enjoy it

Finally someone makes sense, he’s just signed a 4 year deal & was 3rd in the Brownlow last year. l could name a dozen Melbourne players who have also had a poor season along with Gus. We need to take a breath have a good 2nd half of the season and push for a fit & healthy 2020

My god that doesn’t fill me with confidence, Sidebottom didn’t seem to have anyone near him for a 100 minutes