Demons1858

No doubt the coaching staff have had a poor end to the season along with players. You can include our sports science team in that also

They are just not at the point where their focus and desperation to make their mark on the big stage overshadows the fear of expectation to the point where you don't even stop to consider the alternatives. Hugely disappointing just the same.

Upto my 3rd can of burboun this going to get fugly

Just cracked open my 1st can of jim beam. Hoping when l wake up it will all have been just a bad dream

Trying to think of something to write but in the end l really just need a man hug

Will probably help run the family business in NZ post his AFL career. Can be quite lucrative l hear

It was the last round of the year and a must win game to make the finals at Whitten Oval for the 1st time in many years. Its my favourite MFC memory. Robbie finally getting the chance to play finals. For the 1st and only time l went onto the oval and followed a number of supporters up the race expecting to get knocked back leading into the rooms. The supporters that got in early enough were able mingle and chat with the players. Massive buzz insude. Robbie signed my footy record that day. Its probably worth nothing but its priceless to me

Resting players would be too clever by half. I think people are reading into this a little too much. Both players are listed as injured. The impact on those players (if just rested) would be that they won't have played a game for 20 odd days by the time the line up in their 1st final. Not going to happen me thinks Out: D.Hannebery (hip), T.Papley (knee)

Hold your fire. It will be worth more as a premiership captain in a few weeks time

Should be a great Shame its unlikely to be in Melbourne - would love to have gone and seen our supporters come out of the woodwork. Who would we play the following week ... I think it would be the loser of Geel vs Rich a the G? We had both teams on toast earlier in the yr. As an aside, its been so long since we made finals I couldn't recall the ticketing arrangements until the club sent me a timely email.

Don't want to lose Sam Frost either

Deecisive, I'm pretty sure we don't hold any new IP here. Clubs aren't eagerly awaiting our next post to make their next trade move

Given he hadn't played much until this season (mostly injured) he probably backed himself to play again before commencing contract talks and his manage would be out there testing the market with the likes of the Bulldogs & Carlton with limited competition for spots. Was good for a patch early on but has leaked plenty of goals against opp bigs and lost his dash in recent games.

Hope so. That would mean we are elite in another position on the ground

That's a big 'If'

What l find both ironic and pleasing is that melbourne until the last 12 months or so were critised by the the likes of Wallace and Barrett on trade radio each year whilst Derek Hine, Bucks and the CFC were lauded. Think Jesse White, Clinton Young, Russell Jordan, Quinton Lynch, Patrick Karnezis, Daniel Wells, Aish, Sharenberg, Freeman. Just shows that opinions are like ar-seholes everybodies got one and not all experts are equal

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/jake-spencer-set-to-test-free-agency-as-he-chases-more-opportunities-outside-melbourne/news-story/8d58bcbd8489895520b45da1c9add900 Jake is a work horse and team first type of player but his body has repeatedly failed him throughout his career. With Pedo signing on again for next season and succeeding as a back up ruckman l'm happy for the MFC to move on. Best of luck Jake

Poor Jimmy was part of lose-lose-lose trade involving 3 clubs

Robbie Flower. No one said it had to be a current day player. If only he (l think it was Tony Campbell) had handballed to Robbie while running towards goal in the last quarter of the 1987 prelim against the Hawks ...

Won't happen. Pretty much impossible for the 'for and against' scores to be identical for any of thr teams battling for a finals berth (Melb, Esse, West C.) given their spread at the moment. Will just keep going to more decimal points until one team leads

Predicting Hogan to rag doll a couple of their undersized defenders and have a good day

The whole family has decided to go this weekend. Feels like final for those that can recall the Daniher and Northey eras when we won more than we lost

I have read many of the posts on this thread and they are pretty harsh. He's a complicated human being but a human being just the same. Granted he has issues but has also had had a tough unbringing by all reports

Collingwood has a string of injured players already out so with Wells and Adams added to the list we should get the chocolates

Lets not forget that he playing in teams with limited competition for votes.