SFebes

Weideman - 6 disposals, 4 clangers. He is out for me

Still a rookie? Wouldn't we need a player to go down on LT injury list for him to debut anyway?

20,000 free ticket giveaway's help

Tom McDonald back in defence gives me more confidence and straightens us up, Oscar, I had been critical but his year has been a great story of persistence. Hogan up forward, Salem and Watts back would be handy. Wagner goes out as does Weed and possibly Petracca for a rest? Garlett has had a tough few weeks personally, but he's allowed to, his year has been great. We need to thump Lions next week.

What a late season recruit BRAYSHAW is!!! Good football story and well done to him and his family

OK thanks WB. Didnt someone say Salem would be ok and wasnt even reported? Unsure about Hogan, but would be nice to have all 3 of those back. Pedo stays in, put him on a wing if need be, team plays better with him in it for whatever reason but as Clint said, Gawn forward and Pedo in ruck looks much more dangerous

Much better, actually much much better.

Salem back for Wagner please. Unsure if Watts was good enough to replace Weideman but he's like a rabbit in headlights

Whos still nervous??? Haha

Gawn better as a forward today IMO

Ease up on Jeffy, he's obviously having a rough trot personally since NT game with two trips to Perth, including this week. Probably shouldn't be playing

Thats the Melbourne brand, always has been

19 scoring shots each.....after our 1Q domination. Unacceptable

This is [censored] pathetic

What is with these umpires again?

Oliver only 3 kicks in his 20 disposals

[censored] this, cheating umpire [censored]

And Vince

Been happening all year to every game, corrupt.

They can have one after round 23

Brayshaw - wow....what a new recruit!! HBF is his for good!

What's his kicking like? Decision making? I might go to next weeks game just to watch him

Speaking of which, was that Carey rumour BS? I'd actually rate Murphy ahead of Jones as he can win games for the Blues off his own boat. Hurn is the worst. Anyway, not trying to offend anyone and hard to explain in text but I'm sure people understand where I'm coming from.

.

Well sorry, I'm going to question continually. The St Kilda game earlier in the season and from memory the Crows game in Adelaide were standouts. I'm not knocking his endeavour, but he isn't a leader, chips down I'd back Viney, but not Jones to get us over the line. He's a B grader IMO