Vineytime

It’s the depth of the list. To many vfl quality players that are unproven at AFL level over several seasons, there is about 6-7 in this weeks team and was the major problem last yr with our long injury list.

But do they run around the ball, run around the contest and dodge tackles?

There’s no one else...

Caro has had an agenda against Bartlett since he came out publicly and criticised her, she will trash him at any chance. Bartlett has been better than any recent President and needs to stay on to help drive standards.

Hogan not up to the level off field

Harmes, Brayshaw and Jones have had minimal impact the last 2 weeks, Harmes really hasn’t provided us with anything all yr. Brayshaw has had a few good games but overall has been underwhelming, Jones has shown glimpses. The most startling thing is though there is not much quality to replace them with...

What does the coaching group / selection committee consistently see in him to regularly pick him??? I’d love to know. never ever resembled an AFL player.

I thought Maxy smashed Sinclair, agree with other posters also Langdon good, he has been a great pick up.

He was our best tonight by a long way.

Waiting for the excuses from Mahoney at the end of the yr when we trade in another average player. “We thought last yr was a really tough yr but we have improved, we think we are in good shape and have addressed our needs through this trade period” Under achieving club

The list has no depth. A plethora of vfl plebs tonight: Oscar - worst player to ever play for MFC - Why? Wager Smith Brown ANB all proven not to perform at AFL level. Jones cooked

So who’s let the supporters down then? Elaborate.

Oscar - BOG.

Spot on. Does it every time.

Body of work across season / career tells the following can’t compete at the required level: Wagner Hannan Oscar Brown Drop them. Pickett / Jones / Vanders on thin ice. Bring in: Fritta Bennell Tmac Harmes.

Bottom 6 holding us back, gritty win but need depth in the list to take next step.

Beaten at the selection table, again....

It’s so hard to watch and happens so often.... and hasn’t changed for a few years now. It probably won’t until we address that midfield balance as it’s ingrained in our current crop of mids, especially under pressure.

Same old same old when it comes to a loss unfortunately: G.Lyon - excruciatingly barracking I mean commenting, rate him highly, very highly actually but feel his frustration while commentating MFC games, makes it harder to watch. overuse of handball around centre clearance work. Costly turnovers. lack of forward pressure. lack of team defense/ work rate / pressure. major convo around MFC, need more balance / different types in the midfield, glaringly obvious this afternoon when you see bulldogs mix, we won’t be a complete team till this happens Viney, May our best.

Bont & Hunter smashed us to pieces, not one thing done about it from the coaches box ??‍♂️ Harmes needs to be dropped, consistently poor all season.

Playing great footy at the moment Hibbo, keep up the great work legend ?

Horrid performance from NMFC, bottom 2 side. The test is next week.

Mick can have some outdated views, but a lot of the things he raises are the same as members on here have been asking over the last 18 months.

Lever will be skipper

Thought Harmes looked alright at half back against the Crows, one of his better games this yr, leave him there for the rest of the season and see if he can get some confidence back.