Deestar9

JVR had eyes for the ball..not the player & the player proceeded to play the game out. Maynard had eyes for Brayshaw..the ball had left his hands and he chose to turn his shoulder & he collected him ..shoulder to head. He also left the ground. He also publicly stated he was going to go in hard. He took out one of our best midfielders and completely changed the way we had to play our game especially with the use of Trac. Laurie is also a half forward not a midfielder. I have no problem having a lifetime grudge against him & very easy to extend the same courtesy to the entire club. Don’t even get me started on Mason Cox & the rockstar applause when Ginnivan came on. Noble would be justifiably aggrieved with his omission …

Who are their 4 tall forwards ? McStay …yes ..Cox as a resting ruckman ..Miochec same height as Hibberd & Rivers & if Howe plays forward on Lever well good luck to him …his form has been very average . Who else am I missing ?

That was an awesome game . Listened to Libby birch before the game she said (paraphrasing) that it would be close but we’d run over them in the last qrt. (Sound familiar) However she didn’t predict the overwhelming effort in the second half. Great enjoyable footy to watch !!

It’s just logging on to a TV station so you can watch what you have missed. I don’t get any emails etc from them

You’ll get it on 7 plus …

Singularly one of the most painful things I’ve ever done but incredibly successful…

There was also a furore when Max got scans a few weeks ago but we were informed it was a scheduled scan & no more came if it. If it’s purely scheduled to see how the foot pulled up after the first big work out …not sure why supporters need to be informed about that ?

He played in the back half 2018 I think

He will probably have another Casey game if it is needed but you saw how seamlessly Oliver & Friita fitted in so gave to trust the High Performance team on this

We play such a system based game & I feel that Good’s ethos is “if everyone plays their role” then we’re a very hard team to beat. 42 possessions but a lot of those were uncontested..

So that’s finally confirmed it for me ..you are a secret Pies supporter. No supporter who watched that game today could fail to be impressed with our win. And NO I am not wearing my rose coloured glasses ..,

Well he’s named in the team, Laurie super sub

We’ ll trade picks with WC …

I don’t feel it was a criticism of the player as they follow coaches instructions. It was more aimed at the coach & good on Simon for having his say. We criticise them for being bland & then when they give an honest answer we criticise them for that …

Bowey went out of the team in round 18..2022 because his form had dropped off & he didn’t feature again that year. He seems to be following a similar pattern but hopefully he can pick it up against Syd because he is a good kick in a team who isn’t overly endowed in this area

Not in favour of resting players. We have rarely had a settled line up all season so need every opportunity to build synergy in the team.

Maybe rain on Sunday in Sydney 😱

Has to have a run …game fitness is crucial

Pity we don’t extend the same level of understanding when our players make errors under same type of pressure …

If we had been awarded that goal and won I don’t feel that we were by far the better team just as I don’t feel Carlton were by far the better team by winning. They’re riding a wave at the moment and I felt it was very even. If we meet them again I’d still be confident regardless of who they bring in ..

Obviously your comments reflect your moniker ?

Agree with both. Think the game is more about the decline (finally) of Geelong rather than the resurgence of Collingwood. Of course the media won’t have that opinion

4 players …fantastic !! Thought McVee a little unlucky …

I intend to get there at 5pm to watch this match. There’s been a few times a momentous sporting match of different codes has been on in the bars etc & the atmosphere is fantastic..

Nowhere in my reply did I disrespect Carlton & I’m not making myself feel better by “building a narrative against them”. They have done well …it’s a competition where you only have to be a couple of % off & you’ll lose to anyone but they can emulate our DNA all they like but they’re not us & I honestly believe we are the better team. So I’m not in the business of building up Carlton & lauding their team …I save that for my team. Petty is a huge loss & so is McKay. I think Curnow found that out last week with 10 possessions & 1 goal. I’m hoping that we’ll realise just how much we have missed Clarry after Sat night !