ManDee

It was ok until EFC & now Collingwood are in the sights of an independent governing body. Something has his the fan, what do you do? Buy a new fan or stop shytting on the rules?

We will win this! I have a feeling. (Door open)

How does that effect Collingwood?

Unless the deal is done and he has been told to look after himself.

What about schweler[sic} Wayne? Where should he play?

Too easy - Anjelica Huston

What has Hird got to do with the selection process?

When they make the mini-series about this I have some suggestions for the cast. James Hird - Christopher Pyne (That annoying voice suits Hirds personality) or Lance Armstrong Little - Danny Devito Dean Robinson - Arnie Schwatzenegger Mark Thompson - Johnny Depp Stephen Dank - Meryl Streep - why not she has played nutters before Shane Charters - Joaquin "El Chapo" Guzman Andrew Demetriou - Al Pacino Edit: I forget Gil - Big Bird

Nice work thanks Luke the Lurker

Is that the same Lucas Cook? (Pick 12 2010)

If you are referring to the list of 30 best players there a plenty of Brownlow winners. Hird Judd Skilton Bunton Ablettjnr

Edit:- This is biggestred's link

1. Leigh Matthews 2. Wayne Carey 3. Gary Ablett Snr 4. Ted Whitten Snr 5. Barrie Robran 6. Peter Hudson 7. Russell Ebert 8. Barry Cable 9. Gordon Coventry 10. Graham ‘Polly’ Farmer 11. John Nicholls 12. Ron D. Barassi 13. James Hird 14. Chris Judd 15. Michael Tuck 16. Garry McIntosh 17. Michael Aish 18. Darrell Baldock 19. Stephen Michael 20. Bob Skilton 21. Haydn Bunton snr 22. Dick Reynolds 23. Malcolm Blight 24. Lindsay Head 25. Neil Kerley 26. Ian Stewart 27. Len Thompson 28. Gary Ablett jnr 29. Terry Daniher 30. Wayne Johnston Only four of the top 30 players of all time (http://www.theroar.com.au/2011/10/28/the-30-greatest-afl-players-of-all-time/Big Footy List) are over 190cm I think a side made up from that list would beat any side today. F L Mathews P Hudson M Aish HF J Hird W Carey D Baldock C B Cable B Skilton I Stewart HB T Whitten T Daniher G Ablett snr B G Farmer J Nichols B Cable Foll L Thompson R Barrassi G Ablett jnr Int C Judd N Kirley M Blight

Sorry DP if I offended you. The lie I was referring to was Hirds. Hird continues to say that they have been found innocent.

So moonie how do you think Leigh Mathews 178cm 86kg would go playing forward today? or Alex Jesaulenko 182cm 86kg or Kevin Bartlett 175cm 71kg or Michael Voss 183cm 88kg My point or slogan if you like is a good player is good enough regardless of size. But back on topic I see Petracca as a forward midfielder.

1966 StKilda - Ruckman Brian Mynott 193cm 92kg vs Collingwood - Ruckman Len Thompson 200cm 96kg 2015 Mark Jamar 198 101kg 5cm difference 2inches to Mynott Last time I looked 193 was 6" 4" If you are good enough you are big enough. Edit: And it was almost 50 years ago! PS: Jason Dunstall was 188, Petracca is 186. NOTE:- Gary Ablett snr 185cm Malcolm Blight 182cm Peter Hudson 188cm

So if you're good enough then you are big enough.

OD yours looks quite ghostly to me.

Ever heard of Darrel Baldock? 179cm 84kg CHF in a premiership side. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darrel_Baldock Edit: Suggestion that Petracca plays CHF

Yes. Too much?

Ground Hog Day anyone?

Try saying. You are right, I am wrong, sorry. It annoys the crap out of them, they end up not starting arguments.

This could lead to no one drafting ruckmen. Why would you bother, many take 5 or 6 years to get to 30 games,

expect Scully will do or except Scully? OK must be typo.