mo64

How can you say that it's hard to build a tank during the season when Ben Brown did exactly that? The coaching dept showed enough faith in Weid to give him a block of 5 games last year. Weid didn't repay the faith. That's on him. Even if Brown or T Mac got injured, I could easily see Weid still missing out, because both Max and Jackson are developing as forwards. And Fritsch essentially is a key forward.

It was difficult to find wide options on that ground. The dimensions of Norwood Oval width wise was 110m compared to Casey Fields 145m. This week they trained with cones on the ground to mimic the size of Norwood Oval, but they basically had to unlearn everything they'd practiced all preseason. But that was no excuse. They had to win the contested possession to beat the Crows on that ground, and they were soundly thrashed.

Getting smashed in contested ball. We're miles behind the Crows, and we're almost at full strength.

Spot on. You could tell in his Grand Final comments as an analyst on SEN that he wanted the Dogs to win. When every other commentator thought the Kozzie got taken high in the 3rd qtr, Healy yelled out "that's a throw", and a free kick should have been paid against Kozzie.

One of the best posts on Demonland. The detail on each player is fantastic. I was initially surprised that Brian Wilson was rated so highly, but I didn't realise he played 154 games for us, so that was fair enough. I share your feelings about being rapt for Greg Wells when he won a flag at Carlton. As I was for Stan Alves at North.

If you can't remember Paul Prymke, then I suggest you didn't follow the Dees from 1994-1996. Played 24 games in his debut season, came 3rd in the BnF in 1995, and retired in 1996 due to back issues. Was a gun CHB, who's career was ruined by injury.

I agree with everything you've said other than the last paragraph. The club isn't going to factor in homesickness when recruiting, even if they had an inkling that Jackson may want to go home. I'd be more concerned with Dogga being tempted by a crazy contract offer elsewhere than the homesickness factor.

You left out Paul Prymke from the 1994 side. Barring injury, he would have made a huge difference. Todd Viney raves about him. Also Jako was gone by the time Wiz arrived.

Not often do I say this, but I have to agree with DeeSpencer in regards to Paxman. She was slow to move the ball on, and when she did, she invariably took the wrong option. Hanks is elite. Along with Monique Conti and Erin Phillips, she is the best kick in the comp.

From the rare times we got to see him for Casey, Turner looked really assured down back. The club must see potential in him as he was re-signed, whilst our other midseason draftee Declasse was delisted. We are well stocked down back, but I fear Covid ball will hit most teams at some stage, so he may get a gig in the seniors at some stage.

Jackson, Rivers and Pickett all played in their 1st season. As did Bowey. If he's good enough, JVR will play. Age is irrelevant.

Great post CHF. I think the term "depth" is often misconstrued. My definition of a depth player is someone who has shown that they can perform a role at AFL level. Just because a player at Casey is playing in a particular position, he may not be adequate AFL depth. An example would be Baker, who from what we've seen at AFL level, isn't currently adequate AFL standard depth. Outside of the premiership 23, this would be my depth chart: Proven depth: Dunstan, Tomlinson, Hunt, J.Smith Adequate depth: M.Brown, Daw, Melksham Questionable depth: Weidemann, Chandler, Bedford, Baker Unproven depth: Laurie, Turner, D.Smith, JVR, Woey, Howes, Rosman, McVee, AMW Jason Taylor said prior to the draft that we would be drafting for needs in areas where we need backup. He's gone with a KPF in JVR, a wingman in Howes, and picked up FA Dunstan as a mature aged inside mid. Dunstan provides cover for the loss of Jones and Vandenburg. JVR is backup for the aging Brown, T Mac and questionable Weid. Howes is backup with question marks over Baker and Rosman. I haven't included Woey, McVee and AMW, who as late picks, I'd consider best available development players.

With the way Covid has impacted the AFLW, our draftees may be needed to play rd 1. I think that DD36 summed it up well. If you're doing all the right things at training or at Casey, birth certificates, body size or experience will not be a factor in team selection.

Travis Johnstone was definitely a wingman.

If not for Scott Pendlebury, Patty may have been an AFL player. Pendlebury quit the AIS basketball program, and Patty was offered that scholarship. I agree durango. The path for Australian basketballers is through the American college system. Many get offered scholarships, but only the select few make it to the NBA. Josh Giddey is one the exception. He made it via the NBL. Those that don't make it to the NBA, very few get offered European contracts, and the rest are fighting for NBL contracts. The NBL has slashed player contracts due to Covid disruptions. A rookie listed player in the AFL would be in the top 5% paid players in the NBL. A development player in the NBL (rookie equivalent) earns only $17,000 pa. So it's not surprising that many switch codes.

I would definitely prefer to stand at the footy, though it's not really an option now, aside from AFLW. We didn't think about it at the time, but it was fantastic to be able to go to a game, pay your money at the gate, and stand pretty much wherever you like. I went to the races at Flemington on Saturday, and whilst standing in a queue with $20 in hand, I was told by a lady that tickets had to be bought online through Ticketek. The process was a knightmare, and If I wasn't meeting a large group of friends, I would have returned home. Everyone had the same knightmare experience. The Hillsborough disaster had a fair bit to do with stadiums around the world becoming all-seating.

Good gets Big Carl. Alan Johnson would be the 2nd wingman aside from Robbie in his top 20, but I tend to think of AJ as a back pocket. I'm surprised that Big Carl made the top 20. Whilst he certainly scared the living daylights out of the opposition, it didn't necessarily translate to wins.

All politics aside, the interviewer must either live under a rock, or doesn't believe in researching his guest. Why would he have Tmac as a guest in the first place, if Tmac hadn't been part of a premiership team? So I fast forwarded, and he didn't realise that NBA players like Bogut earn 20 times that of an AFL player. That was enough for me.

Nice work Deespic. This list is the most controversial IMO. To say that Travis Johnstone "put his first good season together" in 2005, and yet he is rated so highly. And whilst Steven Stretch had a fine career, I'd rate Stinga and Stan Alves ahead of him. I'm curious to find out who the 2nd wingman in your top 20 is aside from Robbie. Surely not Langdon, based on 2 seasons at the club. Maybe Tom Flower gets a nod to complete the Flower, Wells, Flower centreline. Your ranking of Allen Jakovich at 26 is fair. He was an absolute freak.

I remember that game with Steven Clark well. Pretty sure he had that kick for goal to tie the scores. I was up the other end and knew his kick was on line. However I had a flight to Perth that night, so immediately left the ground without knowing whether he kicked it. I grew up within walking distance of Windy Hill, so aside from the MCG, that was my 2nd most attended ground. I'd go with school mates and we'd meet under the windsock at the scoreboard end. I never felt intimidated cause I knew most of the people around me, but I could understand why opposition supporters hated going there. The crowd was 95% Bombers supporters. As a young tacker, I would go to either Footscray (Wester Oval) or Hawthorn (Princes Park) games with my 2 oldest brothers. I never found their supporters to be feral. My 1st experience with feral supporters was on the train home from a Dees game at the G. I was on the Broadie line, and when the train stopped at North Melbourne, feral Richmond supporters and a few North supporters got on. The Richmond supporters directed every expletive under the sun at the North supporters. That was the only time as a youngster that I felt scared that a fight was going to start.

Richie Benaud - Bitchie Renault

The only swashbuckling openers I can think of are Keith Stackpole, Michael Slater and Matt Hayden. No Spoonerisms for Stacky, so it must be either Slick Mater or Hat Maiden. But I'm clueless as to the answer.

Not according to Darren Burgess. When asked on the Gus and Gawny podcast "who surprised you with their fitness when you started", Burgess mentioned that Pickett's endurance in addition to his speed was high level. So I'm not sure where you got that from.

8. Brett Lee. Brie (Cheese) Lett (Off market)

🤷‍♀️ Maybe a case of premature celebration on our part.