What They are Saying at Princes Park - SF

[DubDee 24,703]

The blues comments seem respectful and well reasoned compared to the magpie tools. 

not a high bar. but still 

[Bitter but optimistic 22,123]

1 hour ago, No. 31 said:

At the risk of becoming a social outcast here, time to nail my navy blue colours to the mast.

Yes, I am a Bagger, was born in Carlton and have supported them since I was wee lad! 😁

I think Friday's game is very much a 50/50 prospect and will be a close one. Some outs for the Dees, some outs for the Blues.

As for the view from Parc des Princes, I think the Baggers are quietly confident. Reality is the Blues have only lost one match in the last 3 months and that was essentially the dead rubber against GWS in Round 24. So I don't think it is a case of misguided hubris. Carlton are a good side and in form.

I think for the Dees to win this they really need Fritsch and Pickett to have a significant scoreboard impact.

May the best team on the night win (with no ARC controversies) and then go all the way, via Brisbane, to beat GWS on the big day 😁

Social outcast !!!!  

We'll settle for a simple crucifixion.

[Lucifers Hero 39,045]

1 hour ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

I’m giving Luci a break (reportedly hungover) .

😮 What !!!!

Methinks you are projecting your state of being onto poor ol' innocent Luci !!

[Lucifers Hero 39,045]

1 hour ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

I’m giving Luci a break.

 

Thank you.

Your prediction?

Mine:  Dees by 2-3 goals.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,123]

14 minutes ago, Lucifers Hero said:

Thank you.

Your prediction?

Mine:  Dees by 2-3 goals.

I'm not certain exactly why Luci but ....... I'm extraordinarily, outlandishly confident. The baggers supporters will on their way home at 3/4 time.

[Master Deebater 484]

1 hour ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

I’m giving Luci a break (reportedly hungover) . So I waded through the paper baggers pre game “analysis”. [censored] boring [censored] really, mostly just droning on about team selection. What a dull mob.

The optimists

If we make the GF, you could put out the AFL Team of the 20th century against us and we wouldn’t lose.

We’ve won every close game this year, plus the draw in round 1.

Book your flights to Brisbane.

we beat the Dees without Harry, Silvagni, Cerra, Walsh and McGovern

This time around we have them all back except for Harry and Martin

They are missing JVR and Melksham

I am fairly confident

I think Cripps will have a huge game this week, heavily tag for 3qtrs against a quality opponent in mills and still had a decent match. Melbourne won’t tag him and will go head to head which should suit us heaps. 30 touches 8 clearences 6 plus tackles and 16 contested possessions coming up!!!

Very solid - think we will spank them in the middle this time.

Our Defence gets back so well after turnover - they don’t worry us in transition.

I don’t get this! We are playing like Melbourne for a chance in the pre-lim, both sides have everything to lose. Absolutely agree, but psychologically speaking, there is more pressure on Melbourne. Which in my opinion, can only be an advantage to us.

Prelim hear we come.  ( note the spelling FMD )

The crowd will go absolutely nuts. The noise from Blues supporters will certainly out weigh the Dees

Some views on the Dees

Last time we played Melbourne Charlie wasn't really double teamed that much, he was just played really close by May and probably beaten on the night.

You cannot underestimate the quality defender that May is, very strong very capable. Charlie just needs to try and get separation more often because body on body he's got not much hope.

Melbourne should have beaten Collingwood. We will need the 22 at its best and focused. This will be the biggest challenge this year.

 Would love for them to throw Petracca up forward, would be a massive win for us. Would be the easiest possible way for us to nullify his influence- starve the forward line by repeat centre clearance wins.We would absolutely smack them in the middle & be 6-7 goals up in the 1st quarter & would be game over by the time they tried to fix it.

But Cincotta beat Kozi last time we played them did he not? Kozi so dangerous.

Sounds like Gawn is hurt so odds shortening that Grundy will play if that's accurate. Still doesn't mean Goodwin will manage them in the team's best interests.

Lever intercepting and then lacing out the wingers and midfielders will cost us dearly. Charlie will have may under control.

Brayshaw will be their biggest out. He had 31 touches and 9 tackles and 6 clearances (2nd most for them after Oliver).Petracca is the one to try to nullify as best we can - had 24 touches and kick 2.2. Gawn only had 11 touches, but 47 hitouts and didn't bother the goal umpire.

 

Some boring waffle  about their own players

Crippa is nowhere near fit, his out put shows that. Bloke is a monster & plays thru the pain but we need to be smart & manage it. Playing forward will stretch Melbourne & hopefully reduce further damage. Viney & Petracca are hard AF, even Oliver is tough.

We need to be smart, we need Crippa at 100% (or as close to as possible) for Brisbane.

Cripps doesnt have the forward craft of a player like Dusty/Petracca and we need him at the coalface, if we are sacrificing a mid to send them forward I would go with Docherty.

Midfield matchups will be interesting and a number of options are viable throughout the game Hewett will try and shutdown the most active clearance player at any point in time, but at the start of the game.  Hewett v Viney, Oliver v Cripps, Cerra v Petracca

And finally ……

I blame the climate. Poor snow season has meant Dees supporters are staying home for the school holidays…

Goodwin will milk the absolute s**t out of the tribunal decision. They’ll be looking for any motivation.

??????????

It is an alien chimpanzee who had crossed 3 alternate dimensions to watch the very beginning of what would become the ultimate scandal and greatest attempt to cheat in the history of the AFL!!!!!  It sat knowingly in the background at what would become known throughout the multiverse as the “whatever it takes” game!!!

Heh Uncle,

Clearly the penicillium has kicked in and you're back to near normal.

Hope the maids are OK

You know the lurgy is infectious

[No. 31 1,109]

21 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

Social outcast !!!!  

We'll settle for a simple crucifixion.

 

[Lucifers Hero 39,045]

1 hour ago, No. 31 said:

At the risk of becoming a social outcast here, time to nail my navy blue colours to the mast.

Yes, I am a Bagger, was born in Carlton and have supported them since I was wee lad!

Well done for staying undetected for a whole year!!  Had me fooled with the No.31!  But the jumper should have given it away...

You seem a good sport so you can hang around....

...But in the unlikely event the Dees lose on Friday night I suggest you stay well away from DL for a while...

Edited September 13, 2023 by Lucifers Hero

[Bitter but optimistic 22,123]

15 minutes ago, Hardley Benial said:

Heh Uncle,

Clearly the penicillium has kicked in and you're back to near normal.

Hope the maids are OK

You know the lurgy is infectious

I'll keep that in mind Hardley ! 

[beelzebub 23,242]

1 hour ago, No. 31 said:

At the risk of becoming a social outcast here, time to nail my navy blue colours to the mast.

Yes, I am a Bagger, was born in Carlton and have supported them since I was wee lad! 😁

I think Friday's game is very much a 50/50 prospect and will be a close one. Some outs for the Dees, some outs for the Blues.

As for the view from Parc des Princes, I think the Baggers are quietly confident. Reality is the Blues have only lost one match in the last 3 months and that was essentially the dead rubber against GWS in Round 24. So I don't think it is a case of misguided hubris. Carlton are a good side and in form.

I think for the Dees to win this they really need Fritsch and Pickett to have a significant scoreboard impact.

May the best team on the night win (with no ARC controversies) and then go all the way, via Brisbane, to beat GWS on the big day 😁

Well done...

I think you should feel deservedly confident..   i sure as hell don't. 

 

[No. 31 1,109]

42 minutes ago, Lucifers Hero said:

Well done for staying undetected for a whole year!!  Had me fooled with the No.31!  But the jumper should have given it away...

You seem a good sport so you can hang around....

...But in the unlikely event the Dees lose on Friday night I suggest you stay well away from DL for a while...

Actually, I outed myself earlier this year and even had some other Demonlanders confess assorted connections or sympathies with the Navy Blues after my post [I now call them my Blues Brothers 😁]

BTW, Ron B was Carlton's most famous No. 31. Tom Alvin ('87 Premiership side) coming in as the second most famous Blue to don the No. 31 guernsey I would say.

In the event the Blues get up on Friday (I will be there with the hordes of other Navy Blue Zombies* at the 'G) I won't come here to gloat as that would be disrespectful. I would probably even feel a tinge of sadness mixed with the elation of the Baggers being back in the big time. The Dees are my 'second team', I watch all their matches and even occasionally go to watch them live as I have a membership this season.

* reference to Robbo on AFL 360 last night describing the Carlton fans after defeating Sydney last Friday ... he needn't fear us, Zombies lust after brains for food, he will be safe! 😁

 

[nedleg 169]

43 minutes ago, No. 31 said:

Actually, I outed myself earlier this year and even had some other Demonlanders confess assorted connections or sympathies with the Navy Blues after my post [I now call them my Blues Brothers 😁]

BTW, Ron B was Carlton's most famous No. 31. Tom Alvin ('87 Premiership side) coming in as the second most famous Blue to don the No. 31 guernsey I would say.

In the event the Blues get up on Friday (I will be there with the hordes of other Navy Blue Zombies* at the 'G) I won't come here to gloat as that would be disrespectful. I would probably even feel a tinge of sadness mixed with the elation of the Baggers being back in the big time. The Dees are my 'second team', I watch all their matches and even occasionally go to watch them live as I have a membership this season.

* reference to Robbo on AFL 360 last night describing the Carlton fans after defeating Sydney last Friday ... he needn't fear us, Zombies lust after brains for food, he will be safe! 😁

 

I grew up in the Carlton of old, ten minutes walk from Princes Park in the Demon wilderness years (which ones!), so would often take advantage of the free last quarter to see the Blues play some decent footy – a trick I learned from my old man who'd been doing the same since.... well... there was a lot of wilderness....

Always had a soft spot for 'em, great song, used to drink at Percy's once I came of (under)age, and my sister rues that I could have joined her side of the family in blue if she'd only seen the opportunity and put a bit more pressure on. That's unlikely, but they're way down my list of teams I like to see lose. Except on Friday.

Edited September 13, 2023 by nedleg
typo

[Superunknown 4,158]

17 minutes ago, No. 31 said:

Actually, I outed myself earlier this year and even had some other Demonlanders confess assorted connections or sympathies with the Navy Blues after my post [I now call them my Blues Brothers 😁]

BTW, Ron B was Carlton's most famous No. 31. Tom Alvin ('87 Premiership side) coming in as the second most famous Blue to don the No. 31 guernsey I would say.

In the event the Blues get up on Friday (I will be there with the hordes of other Navy Blue Zombies* at the 'G) I won't come here to gloat as that would be disrespectful. I would probably even feel a tinge of sadness mixed with the elation of the Baggers being back in the big time. The Dees are my 'second team', I watch all their matches and even occasionally go to watch them live as I have a membership this season.

* reference to Robbo on AFL 360 last night describing the Carlton fans after defeating Sydney last Friday ... he needn't fear us, Zombies lust after brains for food, he will be safe! 😁

 

Well played, and do stick around. See, why can’t we just be nice. If oppo fans could be (even partly) like this, we’d all have a better time of it. Bit of good natured ribbing, a few froffies, and a jolly good time of it, what! 

Of course, it goes without saying - but is worth saying anyway- that doesn’t apply to 90% of Collingwood fans because they’re amoeba. And that’s doing amoeba a disservice. 
 

Good luck, hope you lose: If you do, I shan’t be gloating, and if you don’t I’ll be wishing you the best.

Remember the refrain we all share: anyone but Collingwood. I live to see McGuire’s beetroot-headed apoplectic face when they lose. God I despise them. 

[No. 31 1,109]

3 hours ago, nedleg said:

I grew up in the Carlton of old, ten minutes walk from Princes Park in the Demon wilderness years (which ones!), so would often take advantage of the free last quarter to see the Blues play some decent footy – a trick I learned from my old man who'd been doing the same since.... well... there was a lot of wilderness....

Always had a soft spot for 'em, great song, used to drink at Percy's once I came of (under)age, and my sister rues that I could have joined her side of the family in blue if she'd only seen the opportunity and put a bit more pressure on. That's unlikely, but they're way down my list of teams I like to see lose. Except on Friday.

I grew up in the Demons old Melbourne recruiting zone in S.E. Melbourne. MFC players used to come to teach us footy skills at primary school so I always had a fondness and affinity for them. Robbie Flower came to one of our footy clinics, I remember being pretty excited and made sure I traded footy cards to get his one.

My extended family were largely either St Kilda or Richmond supporters (depending upon which suburb they first lived in when they arrived in Melbourne from overseas).

I baulked at supporting either of them for some reason despite the attempted bribery to join their ranks and once I found out that I was born in Carlton (at the Royal Womens Hospital) I declared them as my club. The Blues were flying high in the early 80s and my ethnic compatriot, Val Perovic, who featured in the 1981-82 Blues Premiership sides sealed supporting CFC for me. 

[Lucifers Hero 39,045]

11 hours ago, No. 31 said:

Actually, I outed myself earlier this year and even had some other Demonlanders confess assorted connections or sympathies with the Navy Blues after my post [I now call them my Blues Brothers 😁]

BTW, Ron B was Carlton's most famous No. 31. Tom Alvin ('87 Premiership side) coming in as the second most famous Blue to don the No. 31 guernsey I would say.

In the event the Blues get up on Friday (I will be there with the hordes of other Navy Blue Zombies* at the 'G) I won't come here to gloat as that would be disrespectful. I would probably even feel a tinge of sadness mixed with the elation of the Baggers being back in the big time. The Dees are my 'second team', I watch all their matches and even occasionally go to watch them live as I have a membership this season.

* reference to Robbo on AFL 360 last night describing the Carlton fans after defeating Sydney last Friday ... he needn't fear us, Zombies lust after brains for food, he will be safe! 😁

Yes, Ron carried the No 31 to Carlton but for me it will always be a an infamous Demons number.

Your a good sport and I look forward to reading your posts, albeit from a slightly different angle.

[leave it to deever 17,498]

17 hours ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

Brayshaw will be their biggest out. He had 31 touches and 9 tackles and 6 clearances (2nd most for them after Oliver).Petracca is the one to try to nullify as best we can - had 24 touches and kick 2.2. Gawn only had 11 touches, but 47 hitouts and didn't bother the goal umpire.

I'm still so angry with Maynard and now the Afl. I reckon the team would be ropeable.

[inanunda 342]

Love how they said it was a Dead rubber after the loss.  Tipping it wouldn't have been if they had won.  

[No. 31 1,109]

Interesting old footage of RDB's last game as a player in 1969 has now surfaced. Carlton played Melbourne in Ron's last game!

https://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/1430971?fbclid=IwAR1Gyp59vqAa4Mc6K2935x984zNUusurpXRobEVp9nFtkjPwDvDFPfDTfpk

[Lucifers Hero 39,045]

On 9/13/2023 at 7:31 PM, No. 31 said:

Actually, I outed myself earlier this year and even had some other Demon landers confess assorted connections or sympathies with the Navy Blues after my post [I now call them my Blues Brothers 😁]

Reckon it would be churlish to not feel pleased for you that the Blues won.  It was one of those nights that things went right for the blues and didn't go right for the dees.  Nonetheless, it is the score on the final siren that counts and the blues were in front.

Enjoy the rest of the finals.  If you come up against Coll...smash 'em!!!

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,480]

I don’t think they’ll do much next week against Brisbane, and if they are to win they’re going to have step up their scoring. 18 scoring shots isn’t going to pay the bills next week.

I found them to be a step down in class compared to Collingwood, although Walsh was something else.

[BW511 2,591]

After last week and now, last night, I think Brisbane actually win it this year.

I want GWS to do it but think Brisbane have the best mix.

Walsh played like a man that really, really wanted to win. Big games demand it and he was brilliant