joeboy 3,193 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 (edited) Jones - captain our captain Hogan - continued outstanding season T.McDonald - important as Gawn Neal-Bullen - consistent and versatile Hannan - a quiet achiever Brayshaw - now a weapon Fritsch - impressive and reliable Petracca - missing too often Melksham - played his part Gawn - toyed with opponents Oliver - engine room master Harmes - played different role Hibberd - not always convincing Jetta - never been better Lever - the curse continues Lewis - experience was evident O.McDonald - dependable and safe Salem - disposal from heaven Smith - didn’t take chances Spargo - quiet but valuable Vince - much like Lewis Viney - still finding feet Edited June 2, 2018 by joeboy 2 Quote
M_9 2,216 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 Wrong on Trac, Hib and Viney IMO. McClure (ABC radio) big rapts on Hib. I agreed. Quote
Adzman 2,154 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 Lever - will be missed Didn't see myself saying this after rounds 1-4, but here we are pondering the rest of 2018 without Jake the Snake. There is now a big hole back there, and Tmac is worth more forward. Quote
Wiseblood 24,637 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 Slightly harsh on Trac, who I thought played his best game since he hurt his finger. He had over 20 touches and kicked a goal as well which is a positive return to form. Agree with the rest. 3 Quote
Queanbeyan Demon 7,023 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 Jones - captain our captain Jones – [QD says: Thankyou thankyou thankyou] Hogan - continued outstanding season [QD says: multi-dimensional star] T.McDonald - important as Gawn [QD says: value keeps rising] Neal-Bullen - consistent and versatile [QD says: quiet by comparison] Hannan - a quiet achiever [QD says: off boil today] Brayshaw - now a weapon [QD says: threads the needle] Fritsch - impressive and reliable [QD says: needs more involvement] Petracca - missing too often [QD says: not superstar Eddie] Melksham - played his part [QD stays: says involved well] Gawn - toyed with opponents [QD says: kicking costs granny?] Oliver - engine room master [QD says: pretty good day] Harmes - played different role [QD says: quiet – did enough] Hibberd - not always convincing [QD says: virtually impassable again] Jetta - never been better [QD says: league's most underrated] Lever - the curse continues [QD says: oh no Jake!] Lewis - experience was evident [QD says: mistakes again today] O.McDonald - dependable and safe [QD says: confidence is everything] Salem - disposal from heaven [QD says: stylish and polished] Smith - didn’t take chances [QD says: still learning role] Spargo - quiet but valuable [QD says: gut runner potential] Vince - much like Lewis [QD says: wonderful clubman Bernie] Viney - still finding feet [QD says: solid as concrete] 1 Quote
rufus 1,162 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 Salem is outstanding at picking when to expose himself to the possibility of his direct opponent getting a cheap one over the back by getting to a contest to provide help. Has excellent timing and contests well. Jetta played as well as I've seen from him today. I thought Gawn got clear hands to a ton of balls but we don't quite maximise that with enough clean clearances. Not sure how the stats bear out but that's how it felt today. If we could maximise this area we may become consistently very hard to beat. 1 Quote
binman 44,824 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 1 hour ago, joeboy said: Jones - captain our captain Hogan - continued outstanding season T.McDonald - important as Gawn Neal-Bullen - consistent and versatile Hannan - a quiet achiever Brayshaw - now a weapon Fritsch - impressive and reliable Petracca - missing too often Melksham - played his part Gawn - toyed with opponents Oliver - engine room master Harmes - played different role Hibberd - not always convincing Jetta - never been better Lever - the curse continues Lewis - experience was evident O.McDonald - dependable and safe Salem - disposal from heaven Smith - didn’t take chances Spargo - quiet but valuable Vince - much like Lewis Viney - still finding feet Best joeboy analysis 1 Quote
binman 44,824 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 Best showreel ever: http://www.afl.com.au/video/2018-06-02/aerial-assault-from-dees-key-talls Quote
Demon17 5,262 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 2 hours ago, joeboy said: Jones - captain our captain Hogan - continued outstanding season T.McDonald - important as Gawn Neal-Bullen - consistent and versatile Hannan - a quiet achiever Brayshaw - now a weapon Fritsch - impressive and reliable Petracca - missing too often Melksham - played his part Gawn - toyed with opponents Oliver - engine room master Harmes - played different role Hibberd - not always convincing Jetta - never been better Lever - the curse continues Lewis - experience was evident O.McDonald - dependable and safe Salem - disposal from heaven Smith - didn’t take chances Spargo - quiet but valuable Vince - much like Lewis Viney - still finding feet In the spirit of trying to rationalize levers loss i have gone over joeboys above list which i thinl is a great summary of all snd counted 15 names i would be equally devastated to lose. Once upon a time that numbet might have been 5 ish. If goodwin can fill tjis loss adequately recognising levers value may not be replicated i think the fundamentals are still sound. Q B will tell us. 1 Quote
chook fowler 19,772 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 Hibberd - safe and sound Gawn - good except kicking Quote
Wolfturdo 123 Posted June 2, 2018 Posted June 2, 2018 2 hours ago, Queanbeyan Demon said: Jones - captain our captain Jones – [QD says: Thankyou thankyou thankyou] Hogan - continued outstanding season [QD says: multi-dimensional star] T.McDonald - important as Gawn [QD says: value keeps rising] Neal-Bullen - consistent and versatile [QD says: quiet by comparison] Hannan - a quiet achiever [QD says: off boil today] Brayshaw - now a weapon [QD says: threads the needle] Fritsch - impressive and reliable [QD says: needs more involvement] Petracca - missing too often [QD says: not superstar Eddie] Melksham - played his part [QD stays: says involved well] Gawn - toyed with opponents [QD says: kicking costs granny?] Oliver - engine room master [QD says: pretty good day] Harmes - played different role [QD says: quiet – did enough] Hibberd - not always convincing [QD says: virtually impassable again] Jetta - never been better [QD says: league's most underrated] Lever - the curse continues [QD says: oh no Jake!] Lewis - experience was evident [QD says: mistakes again today] O.McDonald - dependable and safe [QD says: confidence is everything] Salem - disposal from heaven [QD says: stylish and polished] Smith - didn’t take chances [QD says: still learning role] Spargo - quiet but valuable [QD says: gut runner potential] Vince - much like Lewis [QD says: wonderful clubman Bernie] Viney - still finding feet [QD says: solid as concrete] 10 minutes of wrong on Lewis. He was great today. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.