6. Watts: Not a massive game, but continues to stand up when needed. Fantastic mark and goal in the last to kickstart the comeback.

5. Garlett: Celebrated his 150th in style. Three goals and eight tackles

4. Petracca: Took some incredibly strong one on one marks and was clean throughout. So close to a breakout game.

3. Spencer: Competed incredibly well against one of the best of the business. Glad to see he's capable of going forward like Max.

2. Oliver: Typical Oliver game. Not much else to say. Would be leading the B&F by a street at the moment.

1. Salem: Setting a pretty good standard with his class. Need to see more of it during four quarters.

6. Jeffy (1st / 4.53)

5. Clarry (2nd / 4.43)

4. Salem (3rd / 4.03)

3. Spencil (12th / 2.98*)

2. ANB (5th / 3.83)

1. Harmes (6th / 3.75)

*No hit out stats included. Big Maxy's results around the ground (also excluding hit outs) were, Rnd 1 ... 1.45 and Rnd 2 ... 3.28. Big Maxy's average score in 2016 was 2.72

Worst 3 (weighted statistics only)

Weids (22nd / 0.38)

Melksham (21st / 1.18)

Hannan (20th / 2.20)

6. Watts

5. Hunt

4. Garlett

3. Petracca

2. Spencer

1. Oliver

Just now, DeeZone said:

6. Watts

5. Hunt

4. Garlett

3. Petracca

2. Spencer

1. Oliver

Played two really good quarters of footy and one really crap qtr, hard to sit and watch the 3rd quarter. Took me back to the bad old days, then we nearly run over them two minutes to go we hit the front and we didn't get the numbers back to snuff them out. When are we going to learn.???

6.  Watts

5.  Garlett

4.  Hunt

3.   Oliver

2.   Petracca

1.  Spencer

 

 

 

 

Edited April 16, 20178 yr by Deeoldfart

Clayton Oliver is back in the lead -

42. Clayton Oliver
40. Nathan Jones
31. Jack Watts
19. Jeff Garlett
17. Jayden Hunt
16. Christian Salem
11. Max Gawn Dom Tyson
9. Christian Petracca
7. Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Jordan Lewis  Bernie Vince          
5. Dean Kent Billy Stretch 
4. Jesse Hogan Neville Jetta Tom McDonald 
2. Jake Melksham 

6: Jack watts

5: Jayden Hunt

4: Jeff Garlett

3: Claytons Oliver

2: Jake Spencer

1: Chris Salem

Apologies to Petracca.

6. Watts 

5. Petracca

4. Garlett

3. Spencer 

2. Oliver 

1. Salem 

6. Harmes

5. Watts

4. Spencer

3. Garlett

2. Frost

1. Oliver

6. Watts

5. Hunt

4. Garlett

3. Petracca

2. Oliver

1. Spencil

I don't know what game Matt Burgan was watching. http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2017-04-18/the-team-review-round-four

His 3, 2, 1 were Garlett, Oliver and Spencer which seem reasonable.  But his apologies were Salem, Harmes and Frost.  Can't believe he couldn't find a spot for Watts and maybe Petracca and Hunt instead of Harmes and Frost. 

On a different note @Demonlandcould you explain how the cumulative votes ala post #31 are calculated - 'simple' arithmetic over 4 rounds doesn't seem to work so I'm missing something...  Cheers.

Edited April 18, 20178 yr by Lucifer's Hero

On 16/04/2017 at 4:42 PM, Demonland said:

Clayton Oliver is back in the lead -

42. Clayton Oliver
40. Nathan Jones
31. Jack Watts
19. Jeff Garlett
17. Jayden Hunt
16. Christian Salem
11. Max Gawn Dom Tyson
9. Christian Petracca
7. Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Jordan Lewis  Bernie Vince          
5. Dean Kent Billy Stretch 
4. Jesse Hogan Neville Jetta Tom McDonald 
2. Jake Melksham 

 

Where is Spencer? He was in everyone's votes this week