WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - TOMAS BUGG

[monoccular 17,413]

seagulls don't hunt much, they gather anything they can, including easy pickings from tips. They are in good health & not underweight. They reuse discarded material for their purposes well.

we need to take all we think can help us. No team is a SoOrigin side.

one mans scrap, is another creators treasure. we must stop thinking like women at a supermarket. only looking to the shelves.

That is very d&m. Not quite sure that I entirely agree, but, like Voltaire, I defend your right to say it, and enjoy the mental challenge of trying to decipher it all :-))

Just on Bugg, he definitely competes but his footskills are a bit questionable. He's deceptively quick as well. As someone alluded to, he might be a nice run with player which will free up Viney.

Can't say I have really followed him or would recognise him, but I hope you are not suggesting that he would be a good fit for #13 !

[dee-luded 2,959]

The point I'm trying to make is Jetta does a great job playing his role locking down small forwards but what if we had someone who could do that and have elite disposal and push up into the midfield if needed.

We struggled this year again in the midfield but maybe next year depending on injuries but definitely in 2017 there should no such thing as a small lock defender or a mid sized defender and that's all they can do. It will be we have midfielders with elite disposal playing the role of a lock down defender or a mid size defender.

Hawthorn and Geelong worked this out years ago and the results speak for themselves.

I haven't seen a lot of Melksham, could be coming off the other back flank from Salem. Multiple options.

we lost mcKenzie & riley, & bail & cross so far...

so i wondering if Bugg could be a possible replacement of McKenzie/Riley ? that hard nut runwith? Vince hasn't got too many years left.

[SaberFang 7,151]

Yep, based on Roosy's comments the other night the club have been looking for a new tagger.

Bugg seems to fit the bill if he's as irritatingly niggly as suggested.

[P-man 13,366]

Can't say I have really followed him or would recognise him, but I hope you are not suggesting that he would be a good fit for #13 !

This "lack of footskills" is getting a bit over the top and I'm wondering what sample size it's based upon. I've watched him live on numerous occasions over his career and his footskills are fine. Stagnated a little the last couple of years but his tagging role hasn't really allowed him to show his wares.

Ignition summed it up well. He's not top end but for late 2nd or 3rd round he'll be a good pick up. Definitely ticks the competitor box.

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Jetta and Bugg are both neat kicks, not lethal kicks. Not an issue at all. Judd is a neat kick. Fyfe is a below-average kick.

[stuie 7,374]

Jetta and Bugg are both neat kicks, not lethal kicks. Not an issue at all. Judd is a neat kick. Fyfe is a below-average kick.

Jetta and Bugg must have been robbed in Brownlow votes the last few years by that logic...

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Jetta and Bugg must have been robbed in Brownlow votes the last few years by that logic...

I don't know whether you're making a joke or having a go at me. Horrible post. Go away.

[spirit of norm smith 16,267]

Yes Bugg fits in as the hard nut. Either as back pocket or tagger in the midfield when required. He has the potential to play the unsociable footy required to take Melbourne upwards.

[stuie 7,374]

I don't know whether you're making a joke or having a go at me. Horrible post. Go away.

Now come on don't be like that, I think your point about Bugg being as good as Fyfe because he has one similar deficiency is intriguing...

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Now come on don't be like that, I think your point about Bugg being as good as Fyfe because he has one similar deficiency is intriguing...

That call is about as funny as a call to Kids Helpline. Go away.

[stuie 7,374]

That call is about as funny as a call to Kids Helpline. Go away.

Says the guy who has had every bad MFC pun under the sun as his nickname here....

So I'm guessing you're not going to elaborate then? Jetta and Bugg are potential Brownlow winners based on the fact they are average kicks?

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Says the guy who has had every bad MFC pun under the sun as his nickname here....

So I'm guessing you're not going to elaborate then? Jetta and Bugg are potential Brownlow winners based on the fact they are average kicks?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

So I'm guessing you're not going to elaborate then? Jetta and Bugg are potential Brownlow winners based on the fact they are average kicks?

Correct, that's exactly what he said.

[dee-luded 2,959]

This "lack of footskills" is getting a bit over the top and I'm wondering what sample size it's based upon. I've watched him live on numerous occasions over his career and his footskills are fine. Stagnated a little the last couple of years but his tagging role hasn't really allowed him to show his wares.

Ignition summed it up well. He's not top end but for late 2nd or 3rd round he'll be a good pick up. Definitely ticks the competitor box.

yep, & this is the box we've fallen on our faces from, over the last 10 years. If you were to take out Whelan, Neitz, Ox, Rigoni, powell, JnrMac, from our list since 2000, we would have had very little substance & physical presence.

.... we had a bit of flash & sparklers, that wouldn't work hard enough, tackle, chase, keep feet, & all the other bits that go into being a real team & AFL side... we looked great when allowed to, but fall on face when pressure applied.

Jetta and Bugg are both neat kicks, not lethal kicks. Not an issue at all. Judd is a neat kick. Fyfe is a below-average kick.

TJ was a lethal kick... but can't remember them kicks now. & how would he go in this congestion, would he get picked off threading the needle?

Edited October 7, 2015 by dee-luded

[rpfc 28,252]

The point I'm trying to make is Jetta does a great job playing his role locking down small forwards but what if we had someone who could do that and have elite disposal and push up into the midfield if needed.

We struggled this year again in the midfield but maybe next year depending on injuries but definitely in 2017 there should no such thing as a small lock defender or a mid sized defender and that's all they can do. It will be we have midfielders with elite disposal playing the role of a lock down defender or a mid size defender.

Hawthorn and Geelong worked this out years ago and the results speak for themselves.

I haven't seen a lot of Melksham, could be coming off the other back flank from Salem. Multiple options.

If we had such a player, he wouldn't be playing the same role as Jetta.

We would want that player to beat a bloke in a spot on the ground where he can quickly become involved in an attack.

We wouldn't want this person playing on Betts, Wingard, Walters, and co.

They WILL hurt you if they are playing on someone interested in being heavily involved in rebounding the footy.

Hawthorn and Geelong still have role players down back who 'beat their bloke.'

There is a place for that mentality in good teams.

[Radar Detector 1,347]

Jetta and Bugg are both neat kicks, not lethal kicks. Not an issue at all. Judd is a neat kick. Fyfe is a below-average kick.

I think your point about Bugg being as good as Fyfe because he has one similar deficiency is intriguing...

What post were you reading Stuie?

I think the suggestion was that being an average kick doesn't necessarily make you redundant as a player, in fact you can be an elite player with average skills if your other attributes are sufficiently strong. Nowhere was it stated, or even implied, that Bugg or Jetta were approaching the calibre of Fyfe let alone his equal.

[stuie 7,374]

What post were you reading Stuie?

I think the suggestion was that being an average kick doesn't necessarily make you redundant as a player, in fact you can be an elite player with average skills if your other attributes are sufficiently strong. Nowhere was it stated, or even implied, that Bugg or Jetta were approaching the calibre of Fyfe let alone his equal.

Yes, i did get that and was clearly being a bit facetious.

What I was pointing out, is that players like Judd and Fyfe are that good at everything else that their average kicking skills don't really matter, whereas for players like Jetta and Bugg it's a more important factor given their other skills and talent levels are nowhere near the same.

I figured people would be able to work that out for themselves and not have me point it out.

[stuie 7,374]

Correct, that's exactly what he said.

I've explained it for you in my post above.

Should have realized how much of a struggle it would be for some 'Landers to think for themselves.

[monoccular 17,413]

Jetta and Bugg must have been robbed in Brownlow votes the last few years by that logic...

I don't know whether you're making a joke or having a go at me. Horrible post. Go away.

Brownlow votes require more than being a good kick otherwise Strauss, Morton Watts and Maric would have lots of votes.

Yes Bugg fits in as the hard nut. Either as back pocket or tagger in the midfield when required. He has the potential to play the unsociable footy required to take Melbourne upwards.

I have said I don't know a lot about him - how is his endurance? Eveready type?

[Little Richard 6,261]

I've explained it for you in my post above.

Should have realized how much of a struggle it would be for some 'Landers to think for themselves.

Are you trying to set a record for the amount of threads you can derail Stuie? It's pretty annoying reading through a thread and finding that the last page is filled with nothing arguments that you've started.

FWIW, I hope we land Bugg. He'd be a very good pick up and I'd expect we wouldn't have to pay an exorbitant price for him.

Edited October 8, 2015 by Django

[DemonLad5 1,642]

Are you trying to set a record for the amount of threads you can derail Stuie? It's pretty annoying reading through a thread and finding that the last page is filled with nothing arguments that you've started.

FWIW, I hope we land Bugg. He'd be a very good pick up and I'd expect we would have to pay an exorbitant price for him.

really? I thought a 3rd rounder may get it done.

[MadAsHell 4,212]

really? I thought a 3rd rounder may get it done.

Swap of our 2nd & 3rd round picks for their 2nd & 3rd round picks & throw in Grimes. Could seal the deal.

Leaves our 2nd round pick for Melksham.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

What I was pointing out, is that players like Judd and Fyfe are that good at everything else that their average kicking skills don't really matter, whereas for players like Jetta and Bugg it's a more important factor given their other skills and talent levels are nowhere near the same.

Your point was very poorly made.

[stuie 7,374]

Your point was very poorly made.

Or very poorly understood... Potato, potato

[stuie 7,374]

Are you trying to set a record for the amount of threads you can derail Stuie? It's pretty annoying reading through a thread and finding that the last page is filled with nothing arguments that you've started.

Sooooooo you're way of dealing with that is having a personal crack at me when my posts have actually been on the topic?......