Sorry if this is posted elsewhere....

Thought the numbers were pretty interesting....in particular Viney and Gawn,,

Geelong vs Melbourne
8 Vince (Melb)
8 Viney (Melb)
6 Dunn (Melb)
3 Gawn (Melb)
3 N. Jones (Melb)
2 Motlop (Geel)

hmmmm

5 viney
4 vince
3 jones
2 gawn
1 dunn

5 dunn
4 vince
3 viney
2 motlop
1 gawn

???

hmmmm

5 viney

4 vince

3 jones

2 gawn

1 dunn

5 dunn

4 vince

3 viney

2 motlop

1 gawn

???

Which coach is which? Roos doesn't rate ruckmen generally so maybe the second one is him?

Which coach is which? Roos doesn't rate ruckmen generally so maybe the second one is him?

Scott is the one that gave 2 to Motlop

The 5 best players on the ground were clearly Demons... Ling gave his 5-4-3-2-1 votes all to Demons

Scott is a biased [censored].

Motlop ???????

Motlop was bloody good, especially in the first half. I don't have a problem with him getting some points.

Scott is the one that gave 2 to Motlop

The 5 best players on the ground were clearly Demons... Ling gave his 5-4-3-2-1 votes all to Demons

Scott is a biased [censored].

But Roos strikes me as the type to have the class to award a token vote (and note the 1 vote) to the opposition just out of respect and determination not to be biased. Scott was probably filthy and made sure none of his got any 'reward'. In particular I reckon he knew that Viney blanketing his skipper was their major undoing and voted accordingly. Motlop was pretty good, but Brayshaw probably still deserved his votes.

T Mac has fallen out of the top 10.. but another Demon has replaced him

AFLCA Player of the Year leaderboard

90 - Nat Fyfe (Fremantle)
61 - Dan Hannebery (Sydney Swans)
48 - Matt Priddis (West Coast)
45 - Todd Goldstein (North Melbourne)
45 - Scott Pendlebury (Collingwood)
43 - Dylan Shiel (GWS)
42 - David Armitage (St Kilda)
39 - Andrew Gaff (West Coast)
36 - Bernie Vince (Melbourne)
35 - Luke Parker (Sydney Swans)

Motlop ???????

Motlop was bloody good, especially in the first half. I don't have a problem with him getting some points.

Agree, thought Motlop kept them in the game.

His contracts up, is he worth a go at....'Machsy' what's the word on him?

We could certainly do with a bit more outside run and he does get his own ball.

Having just watched a replay of the game, I'd say Motlop certainly deserved recognition.

He kept them in the game.

But big Max was IMHO the standout.

Having just watched a replay of the game, I'd say Motlop certainly deserved recognition.

He kept them in the game.

But big Max was IMHO the standout.

One of their only players who provided run. 27 touches and 2 goals. He'd slot in nicely at Melbourne.

One of their only players who provided run. 27 touches and 2 goals. He'd slot in nicely at Melbourne.

Next year he would be a depth player for us, might struggle to get a game at the dees.

Next year he would be a depth player for us, might struggle to get a game at the dees.

I live for the day that a player like Motlop is a depth player for us who would stuggle to be in our best.