MFC Injury lies.. over it.

[Demon_Chef 20]

has anybody else noticed the bullsh1t lies that the MFC continuously feeds us?

whether its injuries or excuses, it simply portrays a very weak club and im bloody over it.

but its the crap they sell us about injuries tgat drives me nuts.. im sure im not the only one who noticed Watts didnt play the majority of the last quarter.. so why wait til Thursday to tell us he hurt his hammy in Brisbane? it sounds exactly the same as Bryce Gibbs' hammy strain which they confirmed on Monday.

and Clarks "sprained foot"? clearly it wasnt a sptain and Clark would have known the club were lying too..

and then you have Vineys injury.. its his 2nd game and he cops a knock.. yet they selfishly play him for a few more games underdone and unfit clearly..

its all just a bit selfish and immature.. but maybe its just me..

[Longsufferingnomore 1,489]

has anybody else noticed the bullsh1t lies that the MFC continuously feeds us?

whether its injuries or excuses, it simply portrays a very weak club and im bloody over it.

but its the crap they sell us about injuries tgat drives me nuts.. im sure im not the only one who noticed Watts didnt play the majority of the last quarter.. so why wait til Thursday to tell us he hurt his hammy in Brisbane? it sounds exactly the same as Bryce Gibbs' hammy strain which they confirmed on Monday.

and Clarks "sprained foot"? clearly it wasnt a sptain and Clark would have known the club were lying too..

and then you have Vineys injury.. its his 2nd game and he cops a knock.. yet they selfishly play him for a few more games underdone and unfit clearly..

its all just a bit selfish and immature.. but maybe its just me..

You are right. It is just you.

[DeeSpencer 23,569]

Um maybe they don't want to always give the opposition a free ride.

Ok Viney cops a knock and is saw but can still play the next week, do you go and tell the other team?

As for Clark's foot there was obviously some soreness in there that they weren't completely sure what was going on, whats wrong with calling it a sprain? They told us he'd have further scans and see the specialist.

Now this Watts one is slightly disappointing. But maybe they were hoping it was only a very very minor strain and therefore wouldn't report it unless he was likely to miss time. But I'm not overly concerned about the club not giving us straight away details about a guy who is a fringe player lucky to get a game.

The club has every right to be selfish and give us an injury update each week with really good details about the players they do feel ready to comment on. Remember this is the players livelyhood and the AFL don't have strict mandated injury reporting rules like other sports.

[stuie 7,374]

Fairly sure they don't have an X-ray machine in the changerooms at the G.

Most injuries need to be tested out and aren't just black or white on Monday morning.

They don't have to tell us anything anyway.

[Benson 254]

....

Neelds press conference this morning said that Malthouse does not like surprises and he wanted to keep the Watts (2 weeks) injury under wraps until game day. Throw a spanner in the works maybe, any advantage is an advantage.

The screw in Clarks foot was removed as it was causing discomfort and would have affected his on field performance for the remainder of the year.

Viney... Come on, who is being immature now?

[Satyriconhome 10,015]

You are right. It is just you.

Seconded it is just you Demon_Chef

[Demon_Chef 20]

haha fair enough! thats why i was putting it out there!

but in ALL HONESTY.. Neeld saying he wants to keep Malthouse on his toes by giving him surprises.. thats a laugh. do you guys (and Neeld for that matter) HONESTLY believe Malthouse is worried about any players on our list having the ability to be a gamebreaker this week?

we could recruit J Selwood N Naitinui and T Hawkins this week and still get done by 12 goals.. simply because alart from Howe who can tear a game apart for 20mins we have no firepower.

its nice to be positive and i wish circumstances were different.. but dont hide behind a 12 goal qtr against GWS that saved embarassment.. cos 14/20 qtrs this year have been atrocious..

Malthouse probably wont even look at our teamsheet until hameday..