Out : Watts, Petterd, Bennell, Green

In: NFI

Edited April 7, 201213 yr by gOLLy

Perhaps we could give the support staff a game?

We need more VFL players

We could get a few from Wang Magpies and they'd be stars compared to...

Myles Sewell would be nice.

Bennell, Green our worst by far today. We never really got the change we expected last week, so i don't like the chances of getting them this week

Changers??

Realistically Watts and Howe wont be dropped.

Out: Green, Benell, Bail, MacDonald

In: Martin, Couch, Tapscott, Blease/Morton/best mid from Casey.

Changers??

I should say Clangers for next week

What can you say, has anyone ever heard of f.........manning up. Thats it for me a supporter for 50 years I have nothing left to give

OUT: Green, Macdonald, McKenzie, Sellar, Bennell

IN: Tapscott, Moloney, Morton, Couch, Tynan

Green is gawn; Macdonald is too slow, too short and his disposal is wretched; McKenzie can't dispose of the ball properly and is still not fit enough because of his injury; Sellar only came in to match it with the WCE talls; Bennell has no idea or willingness to get the ball

Tapscott is hard at it; Moloney is still our best midfielder, and as long as he hasn't cracked the sads, and is one of the few senior players who has a shot of taking us forward; Morton is just a hail-mary, hope-he-shows-something selection; and Couch has had some good form of late; and Tynan should never have been dropped.

Is Sylvia a chance of playing next round? If so, then he's straight in, perhaps for Colin Garland, who's been woeful all year.

Edited April 7, 201213 yr by Chook

Out Bennell,Mckenzie.Mcdonald. Bartram,Sellar,Green,Bail, Dunn.

In Couch, Nicholson,Blease,Moloney,Davis,Tynan,Tapscott,Morton.

also..Sack Royal , bring in Lovett or Viney.

Edited April 7, 201213 yr by DeeZee

Changers??

opps

Changers??

Can a mod fix the typo for me please!

OUT: Green, Macdonald, McKenzie, Sellar

IN: Tapscott, Moloney, Morton, Couch

Green is gawn; Macdonald is too slow, too short and his disposal is wretched; McKenzie can't dispose of the ball properly and is still not fit enough because of his injury; Sellar only came in to match it with the WCE talls.

Tapscott is hard at it; Moloney is still our best midfielder, and as long as he hasn't cracked the sads, and is one of the few senior players who has a shot of taking us forward; Morton is just a hail-mary, hope-he-shows-something selection; and Couch has had some good form of late.

Is Sylvia a chance of playing next round? If so, then he's straight in, perhaps for Colin Garland, who's been woeful all year.

I saw the first half after the first 15 minutes. Then the bar witch from the west got me dragged for me complaining about her 2 weeks a go. Barman apologised to me again re her, told me he couldn't serve me but let me stay until the boys in blue came an hour later. Barmen asked me if I wanted a beer 10 minutes before the boys turned up. I needed an ATM so He gave me a wink & said, "My shout".

I'm going to take it further next week.

The teams: Green was quiet again I think. McKenzie should be Sub, with his lack of fitness base, although that may put him back further. Maybe your right, he should get fit with Casey, but I can't think of anyone who'd be better.

I'd keep Sellar for height balance & it frees up Frawley to matchup on others tall or small. IMO the Rivers/ JMcDonald/ Garland thing isn't working. TMac looked OK, encouraging.

So, I'd bring in the likes of Morton for run, Davey for run & pace, Martin in, Moloney if fit? Couch for McKenzie, leave Green for one more, Maybe Bail goes out for Tynan, Bennell > Sub:

Edited April 7, 201213 yr by dee-luded

IN: My drinking habits

OUT: My 2012 hopes

We really need size .

Bail ,Bartram ,Jordy Mac etc are just not going to get us there .Jmac is a battler at best .

Can a mod fix the typo for me please!

You are able to do it yourself as you started the thread. Just click on advanced/full edit or whatever it is and the change the header.

Out: Green, Bennell

In: Morton, Moloney

Out: Green, Bennell

In: Morton, Moloney

Not Morton, please. I don't want to see him play again.

Not Morton, please. I don't want to see him play again.

Morton is better than half the blokes we have in there at the moment.

At least he has a bit of run and good disposal.

What can you say, has anyone ever heard of f.........manning up. Thats it for me a supporter for 50 years I have nothing left to give

Showing the white feather? I have been a longtime supporter too, but I'm not changing ships now or ever.

We need more VFL players

Well at least in Magners case he just plays footy unlike our overpaid players

I agree we should look further afield the sooner the better

Morton isnt the kind of player we need. We have too many of that kind already.

Edited April 7, 201213 yr by Norm Smith's Curse

Just a bit of push and shove from the Tiges. We're yet to see if it will pay off, but it's something the Melbourne players didn't show today when they were getting flogged.