Who are MFC's top 10 Brownlow votegetters of all time?

Have a go. They are from the late 40's and upwards so you don't have to include the really ancient Demons.

I reckon Gary Hardeman would have to be there. The Umps loved him.

Who are MFC's top 10 Brownlow votegetters of all time?

Have a go. They are from the late 40's and upwards so you don't have to include the really ancient Demons.

Ivor Warne-Smith won his 2 Brownlows when only 1 vote was given to the B.O.G . He received 8 and 9 votes in those two years . Equivalent to 24 and 27 ? . Fairly sure he polled well in other years .

Al Nicholson, Matty Warnock, Isaac Weetra, Michael Newton, Shannon Motlop, Ryan Ferguson, Nick Smith, Luke Molan, Simon Godfrey and the obligatory answer of Jack Watts would have to be the top ten from my time.

Edited December 5, 201113 yr by Chook

From the thread title I thought that dear Mr Dumbitriou was about to make an announcement:

" the rules committee has decided that this year's medal votes will be determined on a new exciting advanced scientific analysis, made by myself and Mr Anderson, on what would have been the most likely voting on any given day had all potential players been available. Now we must emphasize, before there is any speculation, that this decision was made before the unfortunate injury to this year's favorite, namely 3votes, C Judd, Carltank. "

I reckon Gary Hardeman would have to be there. The Umps loved him.

Yes, he was right up there! OK, Robbie Flower was 1st with 150 votes. Who do people think came next? It wasn't Ron Barassi.

Al Nicholson, Matty Warnock, Isaac Weetra, Michael Newton, Shannon Motlop, Ryan Ferguson, Nick Smith, Luke Molan, Simon Godfrey and the obligatory answer of Jack Watts would have to be the top ten from my time.

Good try! A little more research required. Love your wit.

Al Nicholson, Matty Warnock, Isaac Weetra, Michael Newton, Shannon Motlop, Ryan Ferguson, Nick Smith, Luke Molan, Simon Godfrey and the obligatory answer of Jack Watts would have to be the top ten from my time.

What? No Scott Chisholm?

Greg Wells had a lot of votes over time

What? No Scott Chisholm?

I guess we have all forgotten what at least I see as the most bizzare draft selections of all time; I can't remember if it was late Balme or early um, et, umm Daniher ...... that is of course the Cockatoo-Colin's twins, a pair of galahs if you ever saw them ( which was pretty rarely). Does anyone remember who was the recruiting manager at the time?

D Neitz?

Greg Wells had a lot of votes over time

Well done 'Bimbo', Wells was second with 130 votes. Anyone want to guess who was next?

How about Jim Stynes?

How about Jim Stynes?

Close. Jim was 4th with 105 votes. 3rd placegetter did not start as a Demon.(Big hint!!)

D Neitz?

In the top 10.

Peter Moore?

Close. Jim was 4th with 105 votes. 3rd placegetter did not start as a Demon.(Big hint!!)

John Meesen? Jim Tilbrook? Paul Johnson?

More seriously, Brian Wilson?

Brian Wilson ?

Peter Moore?

Peter Moore is correct! Next player on the list has already been named, Gary Hardeman. 6th was a speedy winger.

Bluey Adams.

Bluey Adams or Stan Alves

Martin Pike?

I guess we have all forgotten what at least I see as the most bizzare draft selections of all time; I can't remember if it was late Balme or early um, et, umm Daniher ...... that is of course the Cockatoo-Colin's twins, a pair of galahs if you ever saw them ( which was pretty rarely). Does anyone remember who was the recruiting manager at the time?

I think it was griffith or similar

Bluey Adams or Stan Alves

Stan Alves was the one. Bluey Adams came 23rd. 7th was a Cordner, but which one?

Where did Yze come ?