Not that I ever doubted it but I saw enough today to know we picked a winner with Jack Watts. Who gives a crap what BT and Lethal think. They are wrong pure and simple.

Anyone else get the impression that some radio commentators get paid to be idiots!

Like the ones who mistook Chip for Trengove.. then yes, they are idiots and they get paid well for it.

Rex Hunt called the eagles the magpies at half time LOL

Naitanui is breathtaking, and when he does something it's hard not to go "wow".

So incredibly overrated though, it's infuriating. He's certainly exciting to watch, but he does one or two things all day and doesn't touch the footy anywhere else around the ground. Taking him pick 2 was such a gamble. If I were West Coast I'd have taken Hill.

That [censored] Leigh Matthews got in to him a bit on the way home tonight reckons he doesn't show enough for someone in his second season and is just a player. No thought that it was his first game this year or that he only played 3 last year, Jesus I hate Matthews.

Arrogant [censored].

He had it in for him when Watts played his second game against Essendon last year.

"i've seem nothing to suggest to me why Watts was the number 1 draft pick" - June 2009

He played alright. But he did not seem to want the ball, Im not having a dig at him because I thought he was alright, but he just needs to want the ball more and demand it more and that is when he will start having better games. Took some nice marks out in front today which was nice to see.

He played alright. But he did not seem to want the ball, Im not having a dig at him because I thought he was alright, but he just needs to want the ball more and demand it more and that is when he will start having better games. Took some nice marks out in front today which was nice to see.

I mentioned that a few times today, he was waving his hands to suggest they kick it to him but he should be demanding the ball, he has good hands and there were several times when he was one out and a mark would have given us a big advantage but they ignored him.

Once he gets more confidence he will present himself more and they will kick it to him, he can't just stand there and wait for it he has to move around and make himself the best option.

Some very positive signs from Jack today. Interested on your opinions, I thought he looked a bit slow at times, remembering he was the fastest caucasian ever measured at the AFL Draft Camp.

...they ignored him.

I noticed that a few times today, waving his arms around and he was give the "cold shoulder" bad choice of words I know.

I agree in a few months he will show more and more.

Watts played well considering the team performance today.

And compare the amount & quality of delivery into the West Coast forward 50 to ours, and Nik Nat had twice the opportunity but only 2/3 the disposals.

And compare the amount & quality of delivery into the West Coast forward 50 to ours, and Nik Nat had twice the opportunity but only 2/3 the disposals.

Overrated IMO, Watts looks to be the better footballer.

All NN will need to do is take a couple of marks and then the media will be all over him like herpes on a 30cent street walker. After JW's 4th game, I could not imagine how much better he will be. NN after 18 games, to me is a hack footballer, Trengove (another #2 pick) has displayed more quality in his 8 games than NN's 18 games combined.

He played alright. But he did not seem to want the ball, Im not having a dig at him because I thought he was alright, but he just needs to want the ball more and demand it more and that is when he will start having better games. Took some nice marks out in front today which was nice to see.

yeah but that will come with time.

go on to www.footywire.com you can compare players at the same age and compare the stats of watts to riewoldt, fev, brown, pav etc and youll all be pretty happy. im excited about whats to come

go on to www.footywire.com you can compare players at the same age and compare the stats of watts to riewoldt, fev, brown, pav etc and youll all be pretty happy. im excited about whats to come

Good call. Im excited too! You should of said "Watts to come".

He played alright. But he did not seem to want the ball, Im not having a dig at him because I thought he was alright, but he just needs to want the ball more and demand it more and that is when he will start having better games. Took some nice marks out in front today which was nice to see.

So the times he was on his own screaming for the ball only to see it bombed aimlessly or turned over - that was because he "did not seem to want the ball"?

And when he led and the pass missed him by 10 metres - "did not seem to want the ball"???

Might be smarter to wait for a game when he's getting good delivery before pulling out a statement like that. And how can you be NOT having a dig at him? If this is the sort of carp he gets from so-called supporters ... sheesh!!

So the times he was on his own screaming for the ball only to see it bombed aimlessly or turned over - that was because he "did not seem to want the ball"?

And when he led and the pass missed him by 10 metres - "did not seem to want the ball"???

Might be smarter to wait for a game when he's getting good delivery before pulling out a statement like that. And how can you be NOT having a dig at him? If this is the sort of carp he gets from so-called supporters ... sheesh!!

There is a difference from calling for the ball and wanting it. I saw on many occasions he was in the middle of the ground just jogging along waving his hands like he wanted it, but anyone could tell that he really did not want it. He did not want the ball on that occasion and there where others like it. I am deffinateley not having a go at him, it is his 4th game, Im just saying what I thought about his game and what I believe he should do to improve it...sheesh!!

I can't be bothered reading all the posts, but I've never read such myopic discussion on a forum. All the rose coloured glasses that came out today after (our) Jack's 1st appearance was dogmatic to say the least.

Nit Nat - 100 touches in the AFL thus far, 70 clearances. 2 clearances today, 2 goals. Massive leaping, breathtaking athlete and helped by our players kicking him beautiful drop punts to make poor ole Russian feel like a stepladder. Maybe they had a vested interest in the car for mark of the year??

This guy is a generational draft pick - simply put, he is amazing, similar to the Scullgroves. Don't tell me, NOT ONCE! did some of you bemoan the fact the WE didn't pick him 1st.

I did.

I can't be bothered reading all the posts, but I've never read such myopic discussion on a forum. All the rose coloured glasses that came out today after (our) Jack's 1st appearance was dogmatic to say the least.

Nit Nat - 100 touches in the AFL thus far, 70 clearances. 2 clearances today, 2 goals. Massive leaping, breathtaking athlete and helped by our players kicking him beautiful drop punts to make poor ole Russian feel like a stepladder. Maybe they had a vested interest in the car for mark of the year??

This guy is a generational draft pick - simply put, he is amazing, similar to the Scullgroves. Don't tell me, NOT ONCE! did some of you bemoan the fact the WE didn't pick him 1st.

I did.

"simply put, he is amazing, similar to the Scullgroves." you are kidding right, you are saying NN is similar to Tom Scully & Jack Trengove???

"Don't tell me, NOT ONCE! did some of you bemoan the fact the WE didn't pick him 1st", A definite NO NO NO. JW all the way.

"simply put, he is amazing, similar to the Scullgroves." you are kidding right, you are saying NN is similar to Tom Scully & Jack Trengove???

"Don't tell me, NOT ONCE! did some of you bemoan the fact the WE didn't pick him 1st", A definite NO NO NO. JW all the way.

*Sigh*

*Sigh*

I can't be bothered reading all the posts, but I've never read such myopic discussion on a forum. All the rose coloured glasses that came out today after (our) Jack's 1st appearance was dogmatic to say the least.

Nit Nat - 100 touches in the AFL thus far, 70 clearances. 2 clearances today, 2 goals. Massive leaping, breathtaking athlete and helped by our players kicking him beautiful drop punts to make poor ole Russian feel like a stepladder. Maybe they had a vested interest in the car for mark of the year??

This guy is a generational draft pick - simply put, he is amazing, similar to the Scullgroves. Don't tell me, NOT ONCE! did some of you bemoan the fact the WE didn't pick him 1st.

I did.

If you don't want to read all the posts then don't generalise your comments about said posts. No-one can deny the talents, ability and potential of Nic Nat. And no-one here does. I think what pisses people off is how the media drools about him when, in reality, he does 2 to 3 terrific things a game and not much else. I can honestly say that not once have I ever wished we took Nic Nat - to say so after Watts has played just 4 games is foolish.

Good base for Jack to build on from today on this performance

he retains his spot and thats what it's all about at the moment.

The day he makes it and all the doomsayers have to eat their hats will be beautiful indeed.

Writing off a teenager so early makes as much sense as using a hornets nest as underwear.

If you don't want to read all the posts then don't generalise your comments about said posts. No-one can deny the talents, ability and potential of Nic Nat. And no-one here does. I think what pisses people off is how the media drools about him when, in reality, he does 2 to 3 terrific things a game and not much else. I can honestly say that not once have I ever wished we took Nic Nat - to say so after Watts has played just 4 games is foolish.

Therein lies the flaw that you've just analysed yourself - no-one doubts the ability of Nic Nat, yet so many are so afraid to speak their mind on this forum because they'll be pounced on by tunnel visioned posters that choose to attack the poster rather than the argument.

Many on this topic are kidding themselves.

Therein lies the flaw that you've just analysed yourself - no-one doubts the ability of Nic Nat, yet so many are so afraid to speak their mind on this forum because they'll be pounced on by tunnel visioned posters that choose to attack the poster rather than the argument.

Many on this topic are kidding themselves.

Fair point, but it's the same on every other site when it comes to the "rose colored glasses". Just a fact of internet fan site life. Nic Nat will be a gun but, with time, I have every faith that Watts will be as well and he gave a glimpse of that potential today. And I believe that 90% of the people who post here would feel the same way.

Fair point, but it's the same on every other site when it comes to the "rose colored glasses". Just a fact of internet fan site life. Nic Nat will be a gun but, with time, I have every faith that Watts will be as well and he gave a glimpse of that potential today. And I believe that 90% of the people who post here would feel the same way.

You're right - perhaps I'm still too close to the loss, watching this huge unit running around, fantasing on what could have been.