Updated Injury List

[Guest Thomo]

When did PJ become such a bad player?

PJ's 2008 form was very good, looked to be coming on as a player. showed in more than couple of matchs, that he was capible of dominating play.

From what i remeber, at the end of 2008 season, he went in for surgury.

What went wroung? he has never returned to the PJ of 2008, why? was it the injury sustained in 2008? will he ever be back to 2008 form?

To me, it seems that PJ thinks he is a wingman. He moves great for a big bloke, with good balance, and awesome below his knees, but he just doesn't seem to know how to use his size. I think he struggles with the body on body stuff. If he could work out that he is bigger than 95% of players on the field he would be a fantastic player, but at the moment, in my opinion, he is not up to it.

[Inner Demon 1]

Why do Wonna's hamstrings take twice as long as everyone else's

Whose hamstrings don't take 3-4??

That's standard.

[Felix 92]

Injury list as at 30 March 2010

- Colin Sylvia – Jaw – Test

- Austin Wonaeamirri – Hamstring – 2

- Neville Jetta – Groin – 3-4 weeks

- Daniel Bell - Shoulder – 4 weeks

- Cale Morton – Knee – 6 weeks

- Liam Jurrah - Shoulder – 13 weeks

- John Meesen – Ankle – Indefinite

- Max Gawn – Knee – Indefinite

- Luke Tapscott – Hip – Indefinite

does anyone know if Watts will be playing AFL this round?? & any news on Garland?

[sylvinator 96]

Whose hamstrings don't take 3-4??

That's standard.

At AFL level, any hamstring, even a grade 1 strain (only 25-50% of fibres damaged) take 4 weeks to recover minimum.

B/c hammies can reoccur very easily, every team takes a cautiuos approach. It's sensible

[sylvinator 96]

Also,

The fact that Wona has done his hammy 3-4 times in the past 12 months is VERY bad for his playing future. Hammy's that reoccur can threaten his career.

It is especially bad that Wona is doing his hammy from an action that is not particularly straining (i.e. tackling). I would prefer he did his hammy doing a 110% sprint, which puts real strain at the hammy. The fact he is doing is while tackling suggests his hammy's are bloody weak

[Craig Drinker 179]

To me, it seems that PJ thinks he is a wingman. He moves great for a big bloke, with good balance, and awesome below his knees, but he just doesn't seem to know how to use his size. I think he struggles with the body on body stuff. If he could work out that he is bigger than 95% of players on the field he would be a fantastic player, but at the moment, in my opinion, he is not up to it.

I thought you were describing Travis Cloke for a minute there.Anyway, any Melbourne players looking to man up Travis Cloke need look no further than the wing or very wide out on one of the flanks.Doesn't like any heavy traffic areas.

[satyricon 267]

At AFL level, any hamstring, even a grade 1 strain (only 25-50% of fibres damaged) take 4 weeks to recover minimum.

B/c hammies can reoccur very easily, every team takes a cautiuos approach. It's sensible

I'll add a bit more about Aussie, had a good chat to him and watched him, he was doing a series of runs 20M, 50M etc etc at different speeds, no limp, restriction etc, when he came to get a drink and a rest, I asked him how it was going as he looked to be running easily, he explained that was the frustrating part for him because he can run, change direction, jump etc, that is why they are sending him to a specialist, it is when he tackles, obviously he uses his torso and it could be linked to his back taking the strain and then overstretching the hamstring and pinging it, a lot of hammy problems are back related, they want him to see a specialist to confirm this, he is still doing the running so when they know what it is and how to fix it he has not lost any fitness.

[satyricon 267]

Also,

The fact that Wona has done his hammy 3-4 times in the past 12 months is VERY bad for his playing future. Hammy's that reoccur can threaten his career.

It is especially bad that Wona is doing his hammy from an action that is not particularly straining (i.e. tackling). I would prefer he did his hammy doing a 110% sprint, which puts real strain at the hammy. The fact he is doing is while tackling suggests his hammy's are bloody weak

I am of small stature, and when I was playing I found trying to stick a tackle on a guy that weighed 85 to 90K when I weighed 70 was a bit of strain.......Aussie is no giant so he has to throw eveything into the tackle....see my other post