Demons make further changes

[DemonDan... 77]

Finally.

A strong statement from the club (almost insulting.)

MFC:

'Yeah, were still paying you, so we jiggled somethings around and found a spot for you out on the rookie list.

Someone else might decide to take a punt on you, if so - Good Luck and all the best - if not, you may as well hang around here and help out the Casey boys..'

Love it.

[Disco Demons 92]

i think melbourne have taken the approach of putting the best available players on the 'rookie list'...that being meeesen and newton...doesn't matter we need a key forward...Newton is best available to go on the rookie list. In my opinion..

[Jaded No More 68,974]

I don't see much in the way of deserving application from Newton.

He's still connected to the club, and that's, arguably, more than he deserves.

Agreed.

The mature-age rookie rule is fantastic and I'm glad we've taken full advantage of it.

I'd rather have picks 34 and 55/1 PSD available, than Newton and Meesen on the primary list.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Could this move (esp as far as Newton is concerned) have anything to do with Mitch Thorp training with us? The idea being that it makes it safer to take Thorp in the PSD, because we're not left high-&-dry if he gets injured (etc.) with Newton as a fallback option.

It frees up a spot on the list from a player MFC dont think will be a serious AFL consideration this year.

And could the Meesen move mean that we'll see Martin more in the ruck this year? Otherwise, our ruck stocks are really fragile with Jamar who was fit for only a handful of games in 2009, & PJ who's only for 'back-up' at best, then a 'true' rookie in Spencer and a 'pseudo-rookie' in Meesen who may now be on his way out. Especially because all 4 of their contracts will finsh at end 2010.

Either way Meesen was not the answer and was earmarked to go in 2010 regardless. He might not be the only one. Martin will get more time in the ruck regardless of the Meesen decision.

[DirtyDees DDC 187]

actually...how does it work if say Meesen gets picked up ? Would any subsequent contract simply make null and void ( by agreement ) the MFC one.. Do we have to pay the ( MFC ) contracted amount for the first year with pick up club topping up , if required ?

or are we simply off the hook with new club to sort it out ( highly unlikely but offer it up for discussion )

Has Anyone got an answer here?

Also, If they stay on the rookie list at the club for 2010, then we will have a very strong side at Casey Scorpions. Even without Valenti. Interesting to note that the 3 melboune listed players who played in the the 2009 final for the scorpions are now de-listed. Newton, Valenti, and Zomer.

[titan_uranus 25,045]

personally I don't like this... I think Newton hasn't been given the opportunities he's deserved... Daniel Bell should count himself extremely lucky to still be on the senior list...

Bolded bit I agree with. Bell should consider himself lucky to still be on this list. As should PJ.

But the unbolded bit I disagree with. Newton's had his chance. Evidently the FD's seen enough.

[Darren Cuthbertson 0]

Great result... I'm delighted we now have 7 picks in the main draft - although its disappointing that we have no scope to rookie a young tall

I will have to accept my two "list cloggers" ie Bartram on the main list and Hughes on the rookie list

You need to spend more time at the club then Hoopla -I'm sure you'll find the way to get Bartram and Hughes delisted. Maybe you can put your mongrel into Jack Watts!

[H_T 3,049]

You need to spend more time at the club then Hoopla -I'm sure you'll find the way to get Bartram and Hughes delisted. Maybe you can put your mongrel into Jack Watts!

Ugh.

I'm convinced DC, you're either: -

a) one who stalks hoopla and only answers to hoopla

or

B) perhaps you are indeed hoopla

[1858 285]

Maybe you can put your mongrel into Jack Watts!

WTF

[45HG 1,559]

I can't stop laughing, poor Jack.

[rpfc 28,779]

Here is a question you only ask once:

Can Darren Cuthbertson stop willing posters to violate our future CHF?

Thankyou.

[Rogue 585]

Maybe you can put your mongrel into Jack Watts!

Ahahaha.

[Old Gregg 1]

Were Bartram, Cheney and McNamara signed on one year contracts?

[Hobbits's 17]

You need to spend more time at the club then Hoopla -I'm sure you'll find the way to get Bartram and Hughes delisted. Maybe you can put your mongrel into Jack Watts!

OMG!