How many can retire or be delisted?

[Mondê 525]

All this talk of a major cleanout at the end of the season with retirements and delisting dead wood; does anyone actually know if there is a limit to the changes that can be made to a list at the end of any given season?

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

There is a limit..... It is called sanity

A team, if they really are on a death wish, can delist every player if that is what they want! The only problem is contracts.... Not all clubs can make wholesale changes to their list every season....

Do we really want a league full of Carltanks???

[chapter 2 0]

i had an impression it was no more than 25% of your list, but this may be more an advised target that a binding rule

[sylvinator 96]

If i had it my way::::::

OUT:

retired (forced retired)---- White, Neitz, Holland, Yze

borderline retire- depending on their bodies and whether they want to go on- McDonald, Whelan

Delist- Weetra, Bode, Carrol

Trade for picks---- one of Bruce or Bell--- only because these are the only players on our list that have some worth, but are also very expendible.

keep Sylvia because though expendible, his trade value is below his real worth, so it would be a bad trade for us.

overall- 4 retired, 3 delisted minimum---- maximum 6 retire, 3 delisted and 1 traded.

IN:

6-7 draftees, 1 PSD, 2 rookie elevations.

[Deeview 0]

If i had it my way::::::

OUT:

retired (forced retired)---- White, Neitz, Holland, Yze

borderline retire- depending on their bodies and whether they want to go on- McDonald, Whelan

Delist- Weetra, Bode, Carrol

Trade for picks---- one of Bruce or Bell--- only because these are the only players on our list that have some worth, but are also very expendible.

keep Sylvia because though expendible, his trade value is below his real worth, so it would be a bad trade for us.

overall- 4 retired, 3 delisted minimum---- maximum 6 retire, 3 delisted and 1 traded.

IN:

6-7 draftees, 1 PSD, 2 rookie elevations.

While I agree with the suggestions involving most of the players mentioned, I have read somewhere that Carroll and Weetra have contracts covering 2009.

Can anyone confirm this?

[Mono 455]

While I agree with the suggestions involving most of the players mentioned, I have read somewhere that Carroll and Weetra have contracts covering 2009.

Can anyone confirm this?

Bailey has said that Carroll is contracted for 09. Don't know about Weetra.

[tess 19]

If i had it my way::::::

OUT:

retired (forced retired)---- White, Neitz, Holland, Yze

borderline retire- depending on their bodies and whether they want to go on- McDonald, Whelan

Delist- Weetra, Bode, Carrol

Trade for picks---- one of Bruce or Bell--- only because these are the only players on our list that have some worth, but are also very expendible.

keep Sylvia because though expendible, his trade value is below his real worth, so it would be a bad trade for us.

Id love to trade Bell and Sylvia for a second round pick.

[Eastie Boyz 0]

Pretty sure you can get rid of as many as you want but you gotta replace them somehow.

So if there's 3 or 4 retirees don't expect too many to be chopped just yet

[Rogue 585]

Fwiw, CC's mentioned that there'd be around seven changes.

[Mondê 525]

Fwiw, CC's mentioned that there'd be around seven changes.

Cheers. So what do we already know? Neitz is gone, White, Yze, Holland, Macca are probably all gone. That's 5. Surely there will more then 2 delistings. Correct me if I've left out anyone that is above a 90% chance of retiring.

[Mono 455]

All this talk of a major cleanout at the end of the season with retirements and delisting dead wood; does anyone actually know if there is a limit to the changes that can be made to a list at the end of any given season?

As many as there are out of contract, and not wanted. Or who agree/wish to retire.

Simple.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,777]

I have read somewhere that Carroll and Weetra have contracts covering 2009.

Oh lord

[45HG 1,539]

And Mcdonald was "probably" going to go at the end of the year. Another reason why this stuff is unnecessary untill at least after round 22

[Nasher 33,607]

I'm pretty sure Weetra's out of contract this year. Carroll is definitely contracted for 09 unfortunately.

In the gun and out of contract:

Yze

Neitz (obviously)

White

Holland

Bode

Weetra

I'm not sure of the contract status of Newton, but surely he's on the brink of extinction now. For now I'll assume he'll be on the list next year.

With Valenti and Aussie now surely certain to be promoted, that would leave 4 spots available for the draft. I'm not convinced that's enough, so I'd be looking to trade one player out for an enhanced draft position, but the problem is I don't think we've got anyone who would really fetch a price that would be worth it. We might dredge a second rounder for someone like CJ or Bell, but I doubt it. The likes of Bruce and Sylvia would get nibbles but IMO they're worth more in the side than on the draft table.

I had Warnock's name on my "delist" list written in pen at the beginning of the year. I've since had to apply the white-out.

Of the remaining rookies, I'd retain Spencer for a second year and turf Zomer.

A lot seem to hate the list management time of the year, but personally I love it. I'd love to be a fly on the wall in the list management meetings.

[45HG 1,539]

Nasher, do you see Syliva as more important in the side now, or more important in the side in the future?

[Nasher 33,607]

Nasher, do you see Syliva as more important in the side now, or more important in the side in the future?

I think Sylvia's a player that would look very good in a good side. In my eyes he doesn't look as bad now as he seems to to everyone else, but maybe that's just rose coloured glasses. I like the way he's built and the way he attacks the ball. He can take a grab and he's a good kick.

If he can iron out the brain fades that currently litter his matches then I think he'll be a genuinely good player. It's all ifs and buts at the moment, but I'm still hopeful.

[deanox 9,898]

I think Sylvia's a player that would look very good in a good side. In my eyes he doesn't look as bad now as he seems to to everyone else, but maybe that's just rose coloured glasses. I like the way he's built and the way he attacks the ball. He can take a grab and he's a good kick.

If he can iron out the brain fades that currently litter his matches then I think he'll be a genuinely good player. It's all ifs and buts at the moment, but I'm still hopeful.

yet you dont have any time for newton who has played 14 games and kicked 20.12? why should sylvia get yet another role of the dice?

he is averaging 10 disposals, 4 marks and 1.5 tackles in his 14 games.

just for comparrison. one club legend, D Neitz, averaged 11 disposals, 5 marks and .9 tackles over his 306 game career. In no season did he average more than 1.1 tackles per game. Im not sure what people expect from a full forward? i expect him to kick a couple of goals.

[H_T 3,043]

Cheers. So what do we already know? Neitz is gone, White, Yze, Holland, Macca are probably all gone. That's 5. Surely there will more then 2 delistings. Correct me if I've left out anyone that is above a 90% chance of retiring.

Macca has signed on again.

[Gouga 566]

I wouldn't be suprised if Whelan retired.

[John Dee 445]

Newton will be around next year. With our current forward stocks, he has to be retained. This makes him very lucky as in just about any other club he would be gone in a heartbeat. The only upside for us in this is the chance that something finally clicks and he realises the position he is in, and pulls his finger out.

[Roost It 1,434]

Newton will be around next year. With our current forward stocks, he has to be retained. This makes him very lucky as in just about any other club he would be gone in a heartbeat. The only upside for us in this is the chance that something finally clicks and he realises the position he is in, and pulls his finger out.

Patience Grasshopper.

Miller is just coming good

He's still too tall and lanky. He'll grow into his body over the next 2-3 years and may turn out a decent player. We can afford to be patient with him. We have good coaches who are every chance to turn Newts into a solid contributor. No certainty but worth a shot wouldn't you think?

For mine

OUTS: Neitz, Yze, White, Whelan, Weetra, Holland, Bode

TRADES: Wheatley, Bell, Green

[Brocky 4]

TRADES: Wheatley, Bell, Green

Yeah, lets trade Wheatley and Green.....two of our best players this year. Green will be Captain next year. Players who can kick like Wheatley are an asset, look how our point kick in's suffered without him on Sunday.

[H_T 3,043]

Patience Grasshopper.

TRADES: Wheatley, Bell, Green

Green trade? Your the Grasshopper.

[Boxy 0]

Yeah, lets trade Wheatley and Green.....two of our best players this year. Green will be Captain next year. Players who can kick like Wheatley are an asset, look how our point kick in's suffered without him on Sunday.

If Green is captain next year I think I would tear up my membership. You can't be serious?

[Roost It 1,434]

Yeah, lets trade Wheatley and Green.....two of our best players this year. Green will be Captain next year. Players who can kick like Wheatley are an asset, look how our point kick in's suffered without him on Sunday.

You are right Wheatley's kicking is an asset, to the opposition, as he turns it over so often it's like he's playing for them