spirit of norm smith
Annual Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: The Clayton Oliver Thread
Everything posted by spirit of norm smith
-
The Steven May Thread
Just have to remember So far Premiership player 2021 2× All-Australian team: 2021, 2022 Ron Barassi Snr Memorial Trophy (Melbourne B&F Third Place): 2022 Sid Anderson Memorial Trophy (Melbourne B&F Runner-Up): 2020
-
The Steven May Thread
Yes that ship had sailed. It was an obvious move that never seemed to garner any consideration surprisingly!! “May competed for the Northern Territory at the 2010 AFL Under 18 Championships, he was named at full forward in the under 18 All-Australian team. He also kicked 40 goals in 7 games for Melbourne Grammar in the APS as a full forward”.
-
The Judd McVee Thread
He might only want short term if he’s not convinced our MFC future, living in Melbourne or indeed his role in the team. Again offer four years. If he only wants to sign up for two years, that’s okay.
-
Welcome to Demonland: Steven King
Steven King must take as much Geelong IQ as he can. They just seem to know how to extract the best from their players & create a system to beat teams.
-
The Judd McVee Thread
My vote. I want him McVee to stay. He has shown the ability to lockdown small forwards as well as rebound and have skill and composure. I think we should offer him a 4 year deal. Also see him play more of a half back role to get into the game more. If the West Coast Weasals or Fockers offer him to cone back to WA and more $ $ and/or 5 years plus, then so be it.
-
NON-MFC: Finals Week 03
THE AFL AND THE MEDIA ALL LOVE GEELONG 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 COLLINGWOOD 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 HAWTHORN🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 BRISBANE 🤮🤮🤮🤮 I HATE THEM ALL… TOTALLY HATE I DONT WANT TO SEE ANY OF THEM WIN IT THEY ARE ALL SO SO ARROGANT !! (I guess that’s from continued success!) Probably only give the Lions a 4-spew rating as Chris Fagan is a genuinely good guy.
-
Welcome to Demonland: Shane McAdam
The proof that he was injury prone was apparent across multiple years. Unfortunately some players are the one who get injured. He never looked fit at the Crows to the truthful. I think the Dees list manager and Goody must have thought we could get a gem if he could stay injury free. My issue was that (1) we have him a 3 year deal (2 years with a trigger for a third was the sensible thing to do ) and (2) it cost us a future 2nd round which given 2024 would have been valuable. I think the Crows might have potentially delisted him after 2023 so they were happy to get such a good trade deal. We gambled. So far a bust but if we can get him fit, he showed signs of his talent. Though his inability to kick over 35 metres was an early issue in the games he did play in 2024.
-
The Judd McVee Thread
Dear Tom Morris Please let us know if Judd McVee is going to sign his contract offer. Of course you will find out before any MFC communication to the members !! Best wishes, SONS
-
Welcome to Demonland: Brody Mihocek
Tim Lamb.
-
2025 AFL National Draft prospects: The next batch
@Turner Dovaston ⭐️and Robey⭐️. Young guns who are very impressive. Would be truly sad to see Trac leave but if we landed these two guys, it sets us up for the next 10 years with Langford, Lindsay, Kolt & Windsor.
-
2025 AFL National Draft prospects: The next batch
@Turner My priority? Young players with ability to run and who can kick. Players who you can see have AFL quality. First rounders Josh Lindsay, Sam Cumming, Sam Grlj, Jacob Farrow, Sullivan Robey , Rory Wright 2nd rounders Blake Oudshoorn-Bennier, Jett Dahlitz, Felix Kneipp, Harrison Bridge, Noah Roberts-Thomson 3rd rounders Oskar Taylor, Hunter Wright, Finn Davis And of course Toby Sinnema If the Dees are planning to execute under the new Steven King run and create and move the ball quickly, then they have to be able to get better ball users through the middle and kicks that hit targets or at least to kick to advantage.
-
Welcome to Demonland: Brody Mihocek
Brody Mihocek is dealing with significant pain and was a no-show for Collingwood’s captain’s run on Friday. Ummmm …
-
The Steven May Thread
Not yet. Still not ready. He’s like Jeffo. 50/50 at this stage, just my view.
-
Tassie Devils Possible Extinction
Buckley to coach the …
-
2025 AFL National Draft prospects: The next batch
Ahead of the Coates League GF, the National Combine and State Combines 1st round (likely up to 30 selections) Willem Duursma VIC Midfielder Cooper Duff-Tytler Vic Ruck Zeke Uwland(** academy GCS) Def Suns Dyson Sharp. SA Midfielder 5.Daniel Annable(** academy Bris) Midfield 6.Dylan Patterson(** academy GCS) midfielder 7.Josh Lindsay VIC halfback/quarterback Beau Addinsall(** academy GCS) midfield Sam Cumming SA midfield/Hff Sam Grlj VIC halfback/midfield Oliver Greeves VIC midfield Jacob Farrow WA def/halfback/quarterback Harry Dean (**Carlton f/son) def Noah Hibbins-Hargreaves VIC midfield/HF Mitch Marsh SA med/tall fwd Max King (**academy Swans) Fwd 17. Louis Emmett VIC ruck/fwd Lachlan Dovaston. VIC sml fwd Archie Ludowyke VIC ruck/fwd Aiden Schubert SA. Fwd/ruck Zac McCarthy (**Collingwood NGA)key fwd Riley Onley tall mid Lachlan Carmichael(**acdemy Sydney) halfback/quarterback Rory Wright. VIC Gun HBF/mid👍🏻 Fred Rodriguez WA midfield Adam Sweid (*Ess NGA) small mid Noah Chamberlain(**academy Sydney) Xavier Taylor Key defender Sullivan Robey 🚀VIC. Mid/fwd Harley Barker. SA. Mid/wing 2nd round 31-52 Jevan Phillipou SA. Mid/hff Cody Curtin Key fwd/ruck Koby Coulson (* Suns academy)👍🏻 Matthew LeRay. SA. Mid/wing Sam Swadling WA Mid Ryder Corrigan (**academy Giants) 👍🏻 inside tough mid Harry Kyle. (*Swans academy ) halfback/quarterback Jack Dalton. Sml mid. Accumulation Thomas McGuane(**Coll FS) ruck rover type mid Blake Oudshoorn-Bennier👍🏻 mid. Think Luke Parker. Jett Dahlitz SA 👍🏻def/halfback/quarterback Felix Kneipp 👍🏻skilled half back Tairon Ah-Mu Big key fwd 👍🏻 Jesse Mellor (*GEELONG NGA) hf/goalkicker Harrison Bridge (*Lions academy)elite Hbf 👍🏻 Louis Kellaway(**Rich FS) Jai Murray (**academy GCS) mid Noah Roberts-Thompson SA 👍🏻mid/hff Liam Hetherton (*academy Giants) Latrelle Pickett🚀SA Glenelg Hff Kye Fincher (*Saints NGA) Kalani White(** Melb FS/ )💙❤️ 3rd round + and rookie hopefuls Hussein El Achkar Avery Thomas Jack Ison (*Carlton NGA) Taj Murray. Sam Niklaus Xavier Bamert Toby Whan (*Freo NGA) Sam Ainsworth Tyan Prindable (* Lions academy) Thomas Burton Blake Kelly Zane Peucker Brodie Atkins Zac Harding Kobe Evans (*WCE NGA) Wes Walley(*WCE NGA) Tyah Williams WA Hunter Wright👍🏻 Jobe Scapin Toby Simmema (*Dees NGA)💙❤️ Callum Smith Blake Thredgold Cameron Nairn Hugo Mikunda Aaron Sharkie Finnegan Davis Sam Allen Oskar Taylor Ben Rongdit (**Cats NGA) Andrew Barker Talor Byrne Hunter Holmes Smokies Connor Ryan Tom Ryan Sam Lewis Jasper Russell Oliver McKenzie. Mitch Moate Harry Tatterson. VFL Tom Blamires Jackson Voss Taj Hayes Fergus McFadyen That’s 95 players so like many years, a lot of good youngsters will miss out. I would argue it’s not a weak draft year. It’s okay. Some quality young players are even going to be available through the later group. Some will be drafted, some will go on to play VFL/SANFL/WAFL, some will go on to local leagues and others pursue different paths in their lives and sporting careers. It’s an exciting but anxious time for all. Will they get drafted? Where will they go ? Will it be a move interstate?
-
The Steven May Thread
The rebuild is on !!!
-
The Steven May Thread
I get the feeling it is GM of football Alan Richardson who is running the show. Not sure him and Tim Lamb can stand by their list decisions over the past few years. Steven May 🏆❤️💙 May’s stats show he was elite for kicks & disposal efficiency and above average for interceptions. Sure he’s slowing down but he was still very good in enough games to warrant a 2026 listing and retire with a nice send off. A tough call in my view. It’s a cruel game and I understand we might want to rebuild with Adams and get Derksen in Footnote- how does McAdam survive on our list? Surely he also goes. Whoever gave him 3 years as an injury prone erratic player must be seriously questioned.
-
The Steven May Thread
Steven May 💙❤️🏆 Thanks but time for a fresh start
-
The Steven May Thread
I think we go and get Wade Derksen from GWS. He steps straight in !!!
-
2025 AFL National Draft prospects: The next batch
http://bit.ly/4gtck7U Sullivan Robey - watch this kid for Ranges this week His eye-catching performances as a half forward who racked up huge possession tallies when pushed into the midfield was capped by a 40-possession, three-goal clash against the Western Jets only a few weeks ago. It was only after Melbourne recruiter Jason Taylor interviewed him but was keen to keep their conversation under wraps that he realised he could be in draft contention. Soon enough every club realised a player who they thought might be a draft smokey was on centre stage. I wanted to get as far as I could with my footy and I was hoping to get onto a list or onto the VFL but it wasn’t until my first interview I thought, ‘I have got to be a chance here’,” he told this masthead. “I hadn’t played any Coates League before so I didn’t know the standard but after the first two or three games I understood I could be comfortable and could excel on that stage. “Melbourne was pretty intrigued and they didn’t want me telling anyone but that’s gone out the window now because people know. “Them wanting me to keep it a bit under the covers made me feel they saw something in me that could work out. It gave me a bit of confidence. “You think about the draft and what will happen but I am just trying to think about the week ahead. It’s a big weekend against Sandy and then it will be the combine and then the draft.”
-
The Max Heath Thread
It will be a great win to sign him Big strong ruck Can emerge as Max Gawns successor in a few years
-
Tassie Devils Possible Extinction
It’s an absolute clusterf&)k - AFL is a laughing stock. And add in the biased MRO under “magpie “ Christian
-
Tassie Devils Possible Extinction
Nathan Buckley “The Tassie job is much more appealing than Melbourne “.
-
Media Madness
Cal Twomey “Like every rom com, the Dees and Petracca must come to an end”. “It’s best it comes to an end”. Riley Beveridge “Where do you see Petracca in 2026?” Cal Twomey “Adelaide”
-
Media Madness
“If I was a Melbourne member, I don’t think I’d be happy with the way we’ve arrived at Steven King as our coach." - Sam McClure HE CAN FUCCCK OFF !! We would never accept McClure as a member. He’s a genuine piece of trash. Always negative about the Dees … always!!!