Sydee

Agree but I’d definitely add LJ - imo a huge loss in so many ways

I would or call any of the following A graders based on 2024 form Fullarton McAdam Billings Hunter Our inability to attract players that can have an immediate impact to offset player departures has cost us imho Irrespective of where we finish this season I sincerely hope our list gets the shakeup it needs and we can attract some players that can contribute meaningfully in 2025 and beyond

Hasn’t exactly delivered a huge return for AMW or the club at senior level has it ?

Unlikely we are a bit too nice at the MFC to do that Haven’t seen a physically imposing MFC during a game for a couple of years tbh

Shame nobody in the FD listened to you

I struggle with the CFC comparison the reality is that with no Trac, Lever, Brayshaw, Smith , unfit or hopelessly out of form Petty, Oliver, Viney, BBB, etc our list is nowhere near theirs atm Our once celebrated midfield now looks one of the comps worst , our forwards are inconsistent or just not threatening and our backline is very suspect if/when the ball hits the ground Hard to see this team really threatening any time soon

Anyone not buying a membership probably doesn’t truly belong on hear tbh

I reckon we play better away from the mcg these days irrespective of the opposition

Get well Trac your health and full recovery is all that concerns me and all demon supporters Our fingers are crossed you make a full and speedy recovery

Langdon says more duck than dinner - next time he fronts up to the scum he is pulverised the first time he takes possession Jack Watts high profile debut - the scum rub his private school boy nose in the turf Seems like there is a clear difference in approach Not to sure ours is working for us atm

My bad apologies

I’ve heard the Daicos boys say they always had and have a footy in their hands and kicking constantly Pity some of our guys don’t have the same elite kicking skills would be very handy

Pity the report didn’t include a description of plenty of players receiving a big 🚀 But thanks v much nonetheless

Sounds like how our season is playing out 🥲

If you want fight I’m not sure Fullarton offers that much. I’ve watched him several times now at Casey and frankly he offers a similar level of intensity as a former demon chf now at the bummers He seems like a really nice bloke and I’m sure he is but right now I’d rather see a few more hard nuts run out in red and blue. We seem to have lost any sort of true grit particularly in the last month.

Throwing HBFs into the midfield doesn’t mean they will be successful in that role and then who replaces them at HB ? Howes doesn’t deserve a recall he butchered the ball time and time again this weekend at Coburg and it seems the coaching group don’t think AMW has what it takes Our list is overrated imo - we have quite a few who don’t look that hungry and seem happy to take their paycheck and just show up when it suits

Our midfield depth is a major concern If you watched Casey you’d agree we have nobody looking remotely likely to make it as an AFL midfielder coming through. Viney appears injured Trac is a gun but is needed in our F50 because we have a pretty weak forward line with the exception probably being Fritta and Pickett (sometimes) Sparrow looks like a player but produces little Oliver - disposal by hand is usually good - disposal by foot is comical ANB - not an AFL midfielder imo he is a good pressure small forward Pickett - see ANB Max - a one man ruck band - unsustainable in all respects. JVR is not terrible as a backup but he’s supposed to be our big KPF. Our rucking depth is frankly non existent

Very early days but he is another that just doesn’t seem that likely to me

We are currently slight favourites for the next game albeit against an undermaned Collingwood. Beggars belief after that insipid display

I’d say Trac has pride in his performance and the jumper - that sort of team performance would not sit well with him

If you watched Casey yesterday you’d know we are heading for a dark place - little to nothing back there to get even remotely excited about

What are the unsavoury comments ? If we can’t acknowledge that when we play as Narrm we generally lose then we need to harden up a bit I suspect Some people just don’t seem comfortable with facts and truth

Facts are facts BoBo

They seem to have that covered already - unless they are playing Narrm in which they may look like champs for a half

Win loss ratio would suggest they are not