Hells Gates

Sorry mate I should of explained better. The title was Cloke or Boak to which I mentioned the above players as to my preference instead of paying big bucks for Cloke or Boak. I think we'll be right.

?? Did I miss something?

@RalphyHeraldSun: Four year deal for Cloke would be fair enough as reports say deal is imminent. David Cloke knows Collingwood where his son maximizes talent

Lucas Cook & a fit Gysberts, Taggert, Viney, #4, #12.

Excellent effort although I'd drop Maric, have Naitanui on the bench and Cox starting ruck. Murphy would of been a shoe in early too but unfortunately got injured. Unfortunately because I had $100 on him at $26 for the brownlow! Damnit!

Gee that's a slow backline sir!!

Rabbits in headlights... Everywhere!!!

We call him Cart or Rock Cod

Brent?

God I hope that's not true, for the sake of footy.

Think Jack Reiwoldt/Kozitsche.....

Exactly....hes more corrupt that anyone in the AFL and thats saying something!!

I see a lot of similar traits in Cook as I do in Jack Reiwoldt, just needs a few more kg's, maturity and he'll be worth the wait.

I think Clark is worth every penny and may even be more valuable if we inject some midfield class. Cloke is good when hes on but Id only pay him $50k more than Clark because thats all I think hes worth, which would put him around the $640,000 mark. I think thats a fair price, not $900,000. Im getting excited to see Cook next year.

And thats why I said anytime soon. Players dont just make their mind up at seasons end, they will be following our form and culture from a long way back. I of all people hope we do attract some quality, but Cloke is not worth that amount.

Im sure you are not that silly to beleive a word that Sheedy says.

What about Lucas "sticky hands" Cook?? He will be our Cloke. Its not as if we are finals bound anytime soon. Id rather persist with Cook as our FF as IMO he will be a gun. Why would Cloke want to come to the Dee's anyway?? In all seriousness we have won one game for the year, we arent going to attract superstars anytime soon.

Well it wouldnt be Carlton. They are already in enough debt that we never hear about. He will go to GWS I think.

You made that up. I think what you are talking about is Desire Indicators (DI). It is just a standard that is set to maximise our competitiveness.

Well said. People look for excuses for our kids.....but why??!! Those GWS kids have no fear. Enough said.

A whopping 220!!!

Jai sheahan has been very impressive this year, anyone seen him live??

Yeah bloody sad about Menzel WJ. Good young kid. Do you know if Max will be ready to go start of pre season? Yeah they need to trial Spencer for a few games and see how he goes.

Yes whilst you may be right in these cases, Cook has put on 10kg in 2 years whilst Morton hasnt put on any!!! I rate Cook very highly. As for Jamar, personally I wouldnt of held on to him that long, nor would any club for that matter. Had one good season and doesnt do any damage around the ground. However he is leading the AFL in hitouts and is being let down by a non-existent midfield. Wouldnt be suprised to see the Dees get a mature ruckman in FA or Rookie draft this year, shame Gawn doesnt look like he will make it due to injury.

Huge fan of Davis & have never gave up on Cook like most - the kid has all the goods, needs to add on weight, will be our next FF, Clark plays better up and around the CHF position and thats where we get let down. Time to start playing these kids like Davis, Cook, Tynan, Taggert & Co.