La Dee-vina Comedia
Life Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Forum: Melbourne Demons
Everything posted by La Dee-vina Comedia
-
Steven May Suspended for 1 Match
This post is so good I couldn't just click on a button to "Like" it. I need to add, "Excellent. Well stated."
-
New Major Sponsor - Jaguar CONFIRMED
It's obvious to me that they are a well-managed organisation. It's no coincidence that sales are increasing under a management regime which chooses to sponsor the MFC. The above can be read flippantly...or it can be appreciated that the sales increase might reflect the possibility that the Australian organisation has a well-developed strategic plan which includes sponsoring a team that (1) plays in the most popular competition in Australia, (2) has a support base which may have a higher proportion (than other clubs) of those who are well enough off to buy their cars and (3) is a club that has a standing which suits the Jaguar brand.
-
Steven May Suspended for 1 Match
I would rather the AFL and all clubs (and Demonland's posters) took a consistent line on concussion. Should May have been suspended under the current rules? I don't know. Should the rules be clear that a player should be suspended if he hits or bumps another player in an incident which is avoidable and might cause concussion (whether it did or not)? Absolutely.
-
Steven May Suspended for 1 Match
If breaking a team rule gets a player suspended, then there is something wrong with the team rule.
-
Steven May Suspended for 1 Match
I've just seen the footage for the first time. Under the current rules I have no idea whether he should be suspended or not. But if we're fair dinkum about concussion and stamping out unnecessary on-field violence, then the rules should make it clear that any avoidable late bumps on players without the ball, whether they make contact with the head or not, will result in a suspension. That will stop it from happening. And that will be good for the long-term health of the players and the game itself. That would mean the only question to be asked with respect to this incident would be whether it was avoidable.
-
WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JOEL SMITH
It's only taken about a decade (or perhaps more) for our defenders to learn not to go three or sometimes four up in a pack. Surely our forwards can learn from that...particularly as two (McDonald and Smith, or three if you include Hunt) used to be defenders.
-
Steven May Suspended for 1 Match
The AFL won't be happy if Christian's year starts with multiple successful challenges to the Tribunal. Would seem to suggest that the MRO might need to rethink his approach. Not returning to the ground in a practice match? That seems an odd parameter given clubs regularly rest players in practice matches (including JLT matches) whether it's because of plans to limit game minutes or to protect players from possible injury. In itself, this should be a ground for appeal.
-
WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JOEL SMITH
I haven't seen him play yet this year, but from what I've seen so far, he knows how to run, jump, tackle and mark. His kicking is not bad, but not great, either. His greatest weakness is his understanding of the game itself, that is, what to do with the ball once he's got it. I don't know if he'll make it, but I suspect that the bit in his game that's missing might be something that could be quite quickly learnt. And if that's correct, he could be come a valuable commodity - too tall for small defenders and too fast for tall defenders.
-
Salem Re-Signs Until 2021
I'm not sure he flies under the radar and more. Among my non-Melbourne supporting friends and work colleagues, he seems to be the third player (after Gawn and Oliver) who they comment on when discussing the best players in our team.
- Demon Legends
-
Demon Legends
What is it about these black and white photos which make people look so much older than they were? Is it the clothing? Or the hairstyle? Or is it just the way we think about older photos? Norm Smith was born on 21 November 1915, which means he could not have been any older than 49 when this photo was taken.
-
New Major Sponsor - Jaguar CONFIRMED
Should we be worried?
-
Twilight/Night Grand Final
The Herald Sun poll will be considered deficient by the AFL because it doesn't include the views of those billions who live overseas.
-
Target 70,000
Were you meaning Richmond supporters? If so, there's a typo in your post as I imagine you meant to write that they are "rank and vile" supporters.
-
Target 70,000
Two crimes against English here. "It's understood" is completely unnecessary and who describes people as "faces"? They don't have bodies? minds? souls? Ugh
-
Illicit Drug Use in AFL
Or "AFLXtasy"
-
Injury List - Season 2019
Because of the change in the rules allowing recruitment of relatively recent retirees, you'd have to assume clubs are striking deals with their higher-quality retirees which commit those ex-players to agree to come back to the club they've just retired from, should they decide to play again. The equivalent of a "non-compete" clause as used today in business.
-
Clarry's Mouthguard
- Twilight/Night Grand Final
I don't think there's been a "mindless plethora of rule changes", but I agree there's been a mindless plethora of discussion about the potential impact of rule changes. Not on Demonland, of course.- Illicit Drug Use in AFL
While we debate the illicit drugs in off-season (and in season) issue within the AFL, the NRL has had a nightmare off-season.This is in today's Sydney Morning Herald. I wonder whether the AFL will soon be embroiled in something similar? I hope not, but as much as I like to think NRL and its supporters are somehow inferior to the AFL, I suspect that our code will not be immune to something similar.- Shorter Preseason?
Having thought about this a bit more, I'm quite keen on replacing JLT1 with the first bye round and JLT2 with the second bye round. And I'd be quite happy to keep JLT as the sponsor. So, you'd have the JLT Bye Round 1 and the JLT Bye Round 2.- New MCC President
Couldn't agree more. Those seats have been paid for (many times over). That no-one happens to be sitting in them is irrelevant.- Sideline Symbols To Revolutionise Game Day Coaching
"You've hit the nail...right into the lid" (A Goon Show reference, if anyone was wondering. Also one of the greatest unscripted comic lines ever. From the "Moriarty Murder Mystery")- New MCC President
I should probably know this as I'm an MCC member, but the MCC announcement states that the new member of the Committee, Annabel Brebner, is "Chair of the MCC Football Club". What is the MCC Football Club? (Soccer? An amateur football team separate from the MFC?)- Clarry's Mouthguard
So, you never played without one, either. - Twilight/Night Grand Final