Jordie_tackles

So over rated Only thing i would consider from carlton would be Murphy and even then i would have to think long and hard.

From a Collingwood supporter on BF, From what i saw of Dawes last year he tries hard when it hits the ground, he just couldnt mark it last year, is always a target and will take some pressure off Clark, teams cant couble team him all day when he have other targets. If he comes good pick 20 will be like 12 for Clark day light robbery.

Like this post, i like Watts in defence but think he has potential to go forward especially as the 3rd tall and when he gets a bit bigger. Will be very Goddard like imo can go forward or back, be the 3rd tall or the sweeping back player, good disposal ect

Tom Mcdonald is a btter option and Frawley, reckon that Sheehan or Williams sounds like he had a promising year in defense at casey. martin is not coordinated enough imo. Has some flair going forward but you can afford that in the fornt half, not the back.

He has just nominated us, no deal confirmed yet, speculation at pick 20, and i would hope we get a second or third round pick back

He is worth pursuing imo, pick 20 for Dawes and Collingwood's 2nd or 3rd rounder?

Further quote from my mate that watches rebels, when i compared him to Bennel,

[censored] posting, Cook may not cut it, but i doubt you have any proof and i challenge you to prove to me that he did not "put the effort in" before a couple of weeks ago? guy has had half the chances Watts got and weighs atleast the same or more being 2 years younger. Poor form digging into a bloke while they are down imo

Will be traded or delisted, i dont know what Cook has done wrong, says he is up to 91kgs so would be able to give something a crack imo Dreadful waste of a pick 12 if they de list him after 2 years imo

Ok got this from a guy i know down at the rebels, watches most games, he brings up my main worry hadrness, but otherwise sounds very promising.

Not a Rumour but could we offer Giles a spot as back up ruck/forward? is a big lad, can take a grab, great ruck? will cost maybe 250K and we need someone to take the heat off Mitch

Tim Membrey looks like he could make an immediate impact imo, think he is a bit older 19 and could play well under Clark?

Wellingham had an offer form the pies when he left

i hope so OD, i love Gysberts and think he was just unfit and injured. people were very hard on him this year, the team struggled but he came back with everyone else up and about after half a season, imo has ALOT still to offer

Not attempting to derail a thread but Emma is attractive and likes football pretty handy combination imo. just saying

All this says to me is that they are not going for Gysberts anymore as they wont have anything of worth, Considering people suggest they still need to gain a pick to finish the deal with GC? edit they may still have their first rounder

Is Rich worth more than Tippet ect? i think we would want something nice in return for Pick 4 personally Because people are saying Tippet could go for anything around 10 nothing close to pick 4 or 5 even

Info?

Will come down too who is safer imo Rich or pick 4..... interesting and i like the draft but Rich is atleast a known quantity in terms of what we gain

would you accept pick 20 for Trengove i assume they have a similar answer?

Surely if Pederson wants an opportunity Collingwood is not it?

i cannot see it? might be a mix up, afl controls parts of the stories on all clubs sites

I would want change, he was not pick 4 and has not improved past that edit is not of the quality of Gaff/Shuey ect

Mate all he said was that he didnt think he was a game breaker and i tend to agree, chill Judd breaks games Jones proabaly doesnt thats the difference

I would think it would be a gaff, Cotchin, Shuey, Beams type if anyone wants pick 4