old dee

Sorry but I Cannot agree with you I have never enjoy the "game" so little.

You have my vote, Funny that the game seem to more and more popular under decades of the old rules but has as a spectacle has fallen in a heap since the multi interchanges was introduced.

Could not have said it better. My God listening to the commentators is perhaps the worst thing about the telecast. Why do they have to talk non stop don't they think we have eyes. I don't mind them calling the game so much but the incessant prattle drives me nuts. I watched a couple of hours of the Bathurst race today I doubt there was one minute of silence. It is almost like we are a bunch of cretins who need every second of the race explained.

I didn't have any!

I know I did. I am commenting on his job overall.

I think part of that is going to come from trades.

We were talking about wether he had done a good job or not . Am I mistaken.

IMO he has failed miserably with the way the game looks. I watch the Tigers game and last night. The game looks terrible just a squabble between half forward line with low scoring. And these are the best four teams in the comp.

That's how I see it too DJ.

Not so sure about swift Nasher. With no idea of list size and dollar limit it might take while.

Neither do I Rif. If there is a perfect recruiting department I have yet to see it. I think some are getting little tough on our ability in this area over the last few years.

They were saying that about us 5 years ago. In a competition of 18 teams in sport native to only Australia the talent pool IMO is stretched too far. There is always going to be 1 or 2 teams that are close to not being competitive. It is North and Adelaide at present. The AFL created a competition with 18 teams IMO they over estimated the size of the talent pool.

Time for Gil to move aside. He has had his time in sun on a big salary.

Exactly what I suggesting. Clearly IMO under performed this year. Way back my original comment was the he won't be the coach for 9 years if we don't I think I said dont win a flag. But he has to at least make a GF. The MFC is a small club we will not survive on promises for the next five years.

So what is the time frame for you? 5 years, 6, 7, 8, 9, or 10?

Dr that proves nothing it assume from the start they have the same ability.

Not sure what you are drinking but I would love some Rif.

Well it ain't working.

In my view he is poor match day coach. If the other team is winning he hardly ever makes a change. Just keeps doing the same and expecting a different result. When the other side gets a run on he again very seldom changes anything.

Zero chance of that happening. Making the GF is beyond his ability.

Sorry dr. I could not help myself. Point is there is no chance he will be the coach for 8 years without a flag.

What's that got to do with Goodloss and the MFC? He won't get 8 years without a flag at the MFC.

Sadly I don’t share your enthusiasm od.

Shows what we all know that the only forward to get a look in is Frisch with 2.

Just sprayed my coffee all over the table!