old dee

You are correct he was listed, have no idea how he went. But they got done!

Rubbish

A voice of reason, thank you Cudi agree 100%

Swooper this just an of hand comment but perhaps we should have the line coaches playing on sunday! Was Couch, Martin or bate with the blue team?

H_T I think that line ruins your whole comment. It is hardly short sighted to be expecting more than Last with no wins and an average loosing margin of 10+ goals After 4.5 years of rebuilding. Sorry, but you are saying that after 4.5 years we are behind where we were at the end of 2007. By any measure that is abject failure. I do not believe it is short sighted to be expecting more

Oh yes there is but I am fairly confident it will not be a contest

And then we all fell out of bed and woke up!

Sounds like a good plan Oracle: "Anyway, now is not the time to be baying for anyone's blood." However can you please let me know when it is "time"?

Me too PaulRB but it is of own making. I have read the Sheahan article and I can find little to complain about. We have had one positive story in the last couple of years and that is the debt reduction. The rest is poor performance by the team and or administration. The vast majority of what is being reported is IMO close to the truth. There is a simple way to stop it. Starting winning a few games. Until then we just have to ignore it.

I do not think he is injured, did not get selected for the Sydney game and as there was no Casey game last week he was like a lot of others resting, also no Casey game this week so if he is not selected again he will be like quite a few others having a 2 week rest.

not sure why RR but I never cease to be amazed by MFC supporters who want to constantly shoot the messenger. I agree with you the media did create our current position we did it all on our own.

bang

Oucher why did you start this tread ? as i have said four other times in the last minute There are 4 other threads that this subject should be part of What gives in the last couple of weeks ever person on Demonland wants to start their own thread.

Why is this tread not part of the other Lyon thread?

Demon3165 Why did you start a new thread there is an Ox thread that is barely 24 hours old

Guys can we please stop creating threads that are slight variations on existing threads. It has got the ridiculous stage. Nasher can close some of them please

I seriously doubt we have to wait till sunday

No more than this week. If however it occurs on 24th June that is another question

No it is not Have pity on him to ensure we have a future member think of a reason not to go. Another 100 point loss and he will be considering the Melbourne Storm

Hardtack I doubt this will ever happen. IMO he is an outside player. The good games that he has played (IMO) are when he gets the balls delivered to him in the open or passed to him from a contest. But as I said I look forward to admitting I was wrong I am just not holding my breath

I think he was over it back in October Just look at the recruits since he came on board With the exception of a couple of early draft picks they are all older seasoned bodies. And may there be more of it.

I look forward to admitting that Bennell is a genius.

I do not disagree with you rpfc But there are a couple of big "if's" there.

I agree Big Jim Funny that not so long ago a lot on here were saying he will never be in our best 22. I have always liked him because of exactly the reasons you list. Right now he is in our our best three let alone the best 22. I guess it pays not to bag players too early ( which I have done )

Guys it was a different era, ND probably had a FD of 4 people. So some players do not get on with the coach now there is a surprise. Players not getting on with the coach is as old as the game. Whatever is said about ND there is one fact that cannot be denied He got the dees into a GF when we had terrible training facilities, poor back up , little money and a disfunctional board. Only the second time in 48 years. We should be doing as badly on the field now.