old dee

You rate him 21st out of 25. Behind Fitzpatrick, Petterd, cook, Bennell and Bail. Not sure you will have many agreeing on that one Dee-luded certainly not me. From that list there is only one other I would say has Star ability. Why so low?

Just noticed an interesting one, Cook Wonder if he wants to stay?

Very good olisik sad but true

The master Not sure why you would have sellar in against anyone. Cannot play back cannot play forward cannot play ruck. Where do you suggest we hide him against Essndon?

My God we are desperate for something to talk about this year CHAMP.

That would put him in the top three forwards in 2012

No sure there is a third option available stuie

Could couch be worse than 10 that played last week? Interesting rhaz that we consider 60% of a game as a good result this year.

Funnily DemonWA I looked at the team, then Essendon I now wonder will it make any difference. Very negative I know but I struggle to see much that is positive in the Dees after three months of 2012

Yes thank you! I am tempted to say this looks like a good side But I have thought that the last two weeks and we have lost by10+ goals I think I have worked out the problem. I am forgetting to look at the other team. Oh no!

Thanks rpfc Makes for interesting reading Somebody has a lot of work to do over the next 3 months. I reckon there are a number of the ooc group that will have their manager looking for offers, my guess is 8. of which 3 probably won't get a choice. Only my view from the stand of course

It won't get you anywhere Fork em but you will feel better. Let me know when you plan it I would like be there

It has been a recuring thread for 3 years that I can remember. Not sure why we go on about it Rogue It is like having a discussion on "does the PM tell pork pies" We have all known the answer for 18 months. I was just trying to point out the fruitless nature of the discussion.

You think incorrectly? There are IMO a number that are not AFL standard. Performances will change my mind. Words are cheap

We do not get to have any say where Jamar goes. Under the free agency system he can choice any club and walk there we get no say. We get a draft pick as compensation. It is entirely up to Jamar if he goes or stays

Not sure the above will be what happens Martin has shown quite a bit IMO He will get at least another year Green maybe gone as he has no contract for 2013 and he could walk somewhere else if he liked the offer. Davey and Sylvia have large contracts for 2013 unless someone else is prepared to take over those contracts they will be at the MFC in 2013. We also have a problem with only a few senior players now. Do you want to fling all our senior players in one year? While I think Davey is over the hill and Sylvia plays 6 or 7 good games a year and the others are very ordinary he probably still has some value to us in 2013.

Dee-luded so was Davey, Green, Moloney, Morton, Dunn and bate. 2 years can be a long time in AFL.

yes you are correct. Free agency is the brave new world we are facing don't like it but that is the world now.

rpfc I am not sure that is true, I thought you got some sort of pick as compension. I know it would probably be third round but is that not true?

Dee-luded the comment was based on us offering Sylvia and Davey. The first plays 5 good games in his best years and the other is over the hill. To trade first you have to offer something of value If you were Adelaide would you take those two for Dangerfield?

This subject always intrigues me. What is it that everyone does not understand. The Pies and Bombers are both Rich, powerful and have lots of members. The MFC struggles financially and needs hands out from the AFL, has little power and does not have a lot of supporters. End of the story

Speechless

Me too They would say Viney or forget it

Plus Skill Something we are seriously lack

When he got this injury I thought that was the last we would see of Jetta However we can only drop about 8 at the end of 2012 and there are a number who are playing who have put their hand up for delisting over the last two months. Nev might get another year after all.