P-man

Please stop making threads.

You can't come back into the game if you CONSTANTLY fumble the [censored] thing.

[censored] infuriating. Stupid, stupid, stupid errors.

Wake the [censored] up. Not acceptable.

Ffs

I like him but I've also noticed him hesitating more than once. Needs time. Let's not throw him to the wolves just yet.

LOL..pick 3 for Atley and Mullet. Let's just flush it down the toilet instead Johnno.

Golden opportunity here to end two hoodoos.

Messiest goal of the year but I'll take it.

You forgot to mention their supporters. Being a precious [censored] is in their DNA.

T Mac and Jetta have been terrific.

How does Bail miss that handball?? Seriously.

Richmond have one foot in the door. Low scoring game and Swans don't look themselves. Making rookie errors.

Frawley has played 138 games for 112 losses. He has had 26 wins in his entire career to date. To pluck out just one of your examples, Robert Harvey passed that mark by his third season. By the time he had reached Frawley's stage in his career, he had been a part of 70 wins. I don't wish to be a Frawley apologist. No-one is more disappointed in the latter half of his season than me. But I'd love to see a record that compares with his. It is shocking, to say the least. Many players of his ability would've tried to leave long before now, but he chose to stick around and for the lions share of his MFC career has given his all. His motivation has finally been worn down after 8 years of crud and that's disappointing. But guess what? He's human. He's fallible. It's very easy to make Frawley the villain here. To lump him in with Scully and others. It takes a bit of pause for thought to think about the factors that have not been in his control.

I'd cheer for ISIS if they were playing Essendon.

On current form they could belt us with the physio and the water boy pulling on the boots. The best thing about this game is that it's the last one for the year.

This is just a really unfortunate way for things to end. Got drafted at precisely the wrong time and has gone through 8 years of crap but still fronted up every week and given his best, until this year. He's been a great servant, but it's an unfortunate ending.

It's crazy that this is still a debate. Unless you are confusing A grade with elite (i.e. the top handful of players in the league), Jones is CLEARLY A grade. Be happy we have him and don't downplay his ability just because he plays for us. He is a gun.

No allocated seating for country membership, just find a seat in GA on Level 1 or Level 3. It's a Melbourne game mate. Pretty much take your pick of where you want to sit.

I may cry tears of joy if this happens. You've all been warned.

You're missing the point. I don't think he's good yet. That isn't the argument. It's about whether as a first year player (FIRST year), he needs to do more, as you have stated. He plainly doesn't. He is learning the game at the level ffs. If you're going to judge players to that degree in their first year then you need to take your whack, the same as you've given Salem.

lol..oh yeah, we've totally moved on from Mitch. Pull the other one. We'd have him back in a heartbeat.

Even Tony Shaw creamed his dacks over that pass. He's shown glimpses of his absolute class. Once he builds up his tank we will have a player.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not in a mad rush to get Hurley. But right now I'd certainly have him ahead of Watts. Don't need stats to determine that.

Can someone please just ban this fool? All he ever posts is "you all have sh*t for brains". He's not even a poor man's Saty. That's an insult to Saty.