DeeZee

We just don’t have that killer instinct. Don’t want it bad enough . They are happy playing golf and surfing in the hub. Should have come out breathing fire against the swans, but what we got was lukewarm.

We were very lucky to win that albeit for a bounce. They smashed us in the clearances and inside 50s. They also sit above us on the ladder Clearly a better team.

St Kilda improved 200% when he left.

GWS did us a favor Hopefully they can stay in. Will spare us the embarrassment, and begin the process of a serious review and a clean out of the chaff.

Maxy seems to have lost the art of ruck work

Soft, Fragile, Flaky, untrustworthy. All if the above.

Out- Melksham, OMac, Wagner, Jones, ANB, Harmes, Smith. In - Baker, Hibberd, Bedford, Bennell, Jetta, Lockhart , Pickett.

6. The Waterboy

MFC - Soft , flaky pretenders

Typical Melbourne performance. Will always be Flaky pretenders Until they can prove otherwise. Not this year I’m afraid . Im hoping we don’t make it now so as not to be embarrassed.

We are not really a finals side anyway , it’s all false hope yet again. Just middle of the rd team at this stage.

Langons and Gawns kicking lol

The silky skills of Omac doing wonders up forward.

The ball lives in our forward line most of the game, but we can’t score. Weed been very poor today as well.

Put Tomlinson in the ruck and Gawn in the goal square

Harmes is a disgrace

Harmes has been pathetic all year. They don’t pick in form, that’s the problem. Guys like Bedford, Baker and Jetta have played well in the twos last few weeks.Who do they bring in? Harmes, ANB!!! They keep Wagner and OMac!! These guys wouldn’t get a game with North, let alone a finals aspirant.

I can guarantee you that we will not come back and win this game. Sydney have kept us to two goals in a half and they are up by 5. They would be loving this, as they love nothing more than a low scoring scrap. All over. Goodbye 2020

How many unmarked players inside 50???

That’s it!!! Retire Jones now!!!!

Melbourne can never really be trusted, and if we lose this, do not deserve to play finals

Too many ordinary players like Wagner and Omac worry me

Wagner hopeless, too slow.

We had problems with our forward connection which we tweaked and worked on until it’s now at an acceptable level. Our team defense was in question after the Bulldogs game, but to their credit the coaches worked on a plan for the saints which should hold us in good stead for any future games. The weird thing is we are losing the clearances over the past three weeks and if we can get our strength back in that area we should have most bases covered. I suspect the centre clearances are due to Maxy not being 100% because of injuries, but hopefully he can recover to be somewhere near his best.

Just needs another preseason .