jnrmac

What the hell are the coaching staff doing? This almost a carbon copy of the rd 6 game and we have done nothing about it. Roos should start coaching rather than pontificating on irrelevant matters

How pathetic is our backline. My god we are useless back there.

There weas 30 secs to go. He is brainless

IS the skipper playing today? Where the Farrk is our leadership. Disgraceful

For all those TMac defenders out there he is a moron with the ball in his hand. 30 secs to go and he takes a mark and does that. FMD

That would have been a final 4??

Not sure about that. I seem to recall a couple of games where selection had quite a bearing. Perhaps not cost us the game but we had a 6 day break when the team went in unchanged and got run off the park for example..

Play him fwd? He is better than Dawes and has kicked 5 goals in a game before....

Is that same criteria being applied to TMac?

The critcism as I have seen it has always been about whether he should be learning at Casey or the senior team where he has been outmuscled and outplayed numerous times or simply fumbled etc......

No problem as you correctly state your criteria for your opinion rather that try to claim incontrovertible fact after listening to someone else's opinion on a radio broadcast. Well done on evolving. Good to see you are not beyond learning and adapting.

agree

Was more like Chinese checker style....Ithink they had 14 or 18 uncontested marks inside 50. An utter disgrace of a game.

You won't cop flak but it is an impossible question to answer. I will have a go and say we were always going to trade for Melksham because Goodwin has a relationship and you can't have enough tough distributors with good foot skills off the back line. You never have your best 22 on the park so you always need multiple options.

That's an interesting point. I have seen him in interviews say that he is basically a left footer and that he prefers kicking left foot even though he grew up as a right footer. I have seen him kick set shots in from in front of goal with his left foot. But you are right. He is a freak.

That's pretty common. Very few of them grow up having to kick right sided..Sam Mitchell is a bit of a freak like that..

Tyson is a good kick. Has been known to dob them from outside 50m

Couldn't care less what you think but carry on

We are getting a lot of left footers.....just sayin..... A bit like the Hawks of a few years ago....

$300k a year? You would have to be kidding. He'll walk in anywhere at $500k a year.

Really? Wow. You need to get out more Ron. It's taken 8 years but you proved 'em wrong. Good job.

He was sidelined for much of the pre-season as well. Something was clearly amiss with the coaches and their instructions not being followed,,,,

I heard plenty of supporters questioning Watt's efforts over the years, many of which were half-hearted but can't say I heard supporters who took pleasure in him making mistakes. I thnk that's a generalisation.

You're a bolshie defender of EFC ....Hmmmmmm

Nah, it will happen.