Jump to content


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Not Telling

Recent Profile Visitors

6,407 profile views

goodoil's Achievements

Mighty Demon

Mighty Demon (3/10)



  1. 6. Clayton Oliver 5. Max Gawn 4. Jake Lever 3. Christian Petracca 2. Jack Viney 1. Jayden Hunt
  2. 6. Clayton Oliver 5. Christian Petracca 4. Jake Lever 3. Jayden Hunt 2. Charlie Spargo 1. Bayley Fritsch
  3. He's the second worst judge in the industry
  4. A brutal task - many deserving 6. Christian Petracca 5. Clayton Oliver 4. Steven May 3. Max Gawn 2. Christian Salem 1. Tom McDonald Its an absolute travesty that I don't give votes to Hibberd who was enormous on Rozee, to Petty who played his best game and Pickett who played his role as well as you can pretty much. The substance of our A graders was too much for them to overcome, as it was for the Power!
  5. Perhaps you could just say we should take him as a 1st round pick candidate and that will be enough to see him slide, a la Winder, Ford and Maher!
  6. He has done more to destroy the spirit and essence of the game of Aussie Rules football than anyone in its history, sidestepping what should be checks and balances against such behaviour. He is widely despised!
  7. Quite comfortably the worst and most disliked official in AFL history I would imagine.
  8. 6. Christian Salem 5. Tom McDonald 4. Steven May 3. Christian Petracca 2. Bayley Fritsch 1. Jake Lever
  9. 6. Steven May 5. Luke Jackson 4. James Jordon 3. Jayden Hunt 2. James Harmes 1. Max Gawn
  10. 6. Max Gawn 5. Christian Petracca 4. Tom McDonald 3. Clayton Oliver 2. James Harmes 1. Charlie Spargo
  11. 6. Clayton Oliver 5. James Harmes 4. Jake Lever 3. Christian Petracca 2. Max Gawn 1. Trent Rivers
  12. This is a new one for me, have always run with Vita Brits in the past :)
  13. 6. Clayton Oliver 5. Christian Petracca 4. Max Gwn 3. Jake Lever 2. Ed Langdon 1. James Harmes
  14. That's not necessarily the case, just its a systemic weakness of the fixed 6-5-4-3-2-1 system that you can play well and not receive votes in good team performances and conversely receive votes for mediocre - or worse - games in lesser team performances. Obviously also when multiple players play equally well, you have the issue that there is a massive difference between five votes and one vote when in reality there isn't such a difference in output. Obviousy the best solution is we all score every player each week out of 10, but that obviously presents its own issues and likely isn't manageable. But in terms of Rivers, he plays well but is probably our 12th, on average, best player each week. In this system, thats of no value unfortunately.
  15. 6. Clayton Oliver 5. Christian Salem 4. Tom McDonald 3. James Jordon 2. Jake Lever 1. Christian Petracca
  • Create New...