Freddy Fuschia

Is there any value in posting the names of players in NGA’s these days? If they’re any good they’re out of your club’s reach anyway.

I wonder if the injury to Howes is enough for him to be put him on the long term injury list? There’s talk of a few young talented players emerging in the ranks who could be worth looking at in the mid season draft. We would probably have the last pick but it might be worthwhile exploring whether there’s a player out there to fit our needs eg. a genuine young ruck prospect to nurture for the day when Max retires or if Luke Jackson gets homesick.

Do you think that’s going to work against us this year?

But you’ve missed my point completely. I said that waving hands in exasperation could be something other than dissent which means that players would be penalized for expressing disappointment in themselves - not for umpire abuse or dissent.

I get what you’re saying but we all know what abuse is because it can be clearly defined. Dissent is a different kettle of fish, especially if putting out your arms is automatically an expression of abuse when the same action could easily be interpreted as an expression of disappointment or frustration at the player’s actions rather than umpire abuse. By penalizing emotion and passion the AFL is emasculating the game.

The Melbourne website has an article here which states - “Majak Daw looked to be continuing his form following a best on ground display last week, kicking two first quarter goals, both from free kicks. “But his day was cut short after quarter time, meaning the Demons had to adapt to overcome the spirited Lions”. No explanation as to why his day was “cut short”.

Jake Lever reporting that he’s okay after rolling his ankle (twice) on Saturday night. As long as he looks after it, he should be right to go next week with the 8 day break. Some concerns however, at Casey level. Blake Howes not selected and the rumour is Blake Howes (“stress fracture”?). Majak Daw kicked 2 goals before coming off the ground and failing to re-appear. This is a concern because he’s really our only proper back up ruckman in the event of injury to our two ruck talls in the ones. Commentator on the afl site also mentioned that Dunstan was off getting his leg iced late in the game. Losing Daw early just two weeks after Mitch Brown was felled behind play is a concern, especially after the manhandling of Ben Brown last week.

Oops. My bad - I must have been having a Knightmare.😀

6. Clayton Oliver 5. Angus Brayshaw 4. Sam Weideman 3. Ed Langdon 2. James Harmes 1. Steven May

Toby Bedford not used means that he can play tomorrow.

One reason why there’s less discussion is that I believe Knightmare is no longer on ESPN’s books and is keeping a low profile this year.

Doggies streaking ahead tonight.

How much would you pay for an untried player like Mac Andrew who is presumably not going to play this year (and possibly next year)? What’s he worth?

There’s a Fraser Rosman sighting in there.

With Weideman so hot, you would think they take him off at half time and give him a half tonight.

Keep the pictures coming - especially of the newbies. Here’s their numbers 16. Bailey Laurie 19. Fraser Rosman 21. Jacob Van Rooyen 22. Blake Howes 27. Luke Dunstan 34. Deakyn Smith 40. Taj Woewodin 41. Judd McVee 42. Daniel Turner 45. Andy Moniz-Wakefield 50. Ben Brown

Doubt whether this is the Suns’ expectation. It’s just one pundit giving an opinion based on nothing other than that he was selected at 5 in the national draft. Like many others, it’s doubtful whether he’s ever seen him play.

Careful - we play them in round 2 this year.

How’s he doing up there?

I found it hard to read the numbers on tv. Must have been harder at the ground.

There was very little known of Turner when he was drafted late in last year’s mid-season draft. One unconfirmed report said that he started last year at 191cm but was closer to 194cm when selected in June. @dazzledavey36- could you please follow up his height and the all-important nickname “Disco”? Do they have discos in your neck of the woods?

That would have been about 15 years ago. Hard to believe that Stef’s still playing all of those years later.

The only thing is that in some cases, the talent within the new category of contingency players would be fairly thin. If you take the Casey Demons as an example where the MFC had a good year injury wise, there were some occasions last year when there were barely half a dozen VFL affiliates in their side and some of them might have spent less than 50% time on ground in games.

I think they do subsidize them to an extent but I’m not convinced it’s worth it when any player in your NGA can be taken without a right to bid against a nomination made in the top 40.

Just need to update the player pictures.