Redleg

Thanks for that garbage I thought it was a real story. I hope the mods remove this quickly.

Why? You need ruckmen and Wood and Meesen could carry our load for some years to come. See my previous post.

I would do that deal ASAP. We could then trade Jamar off to a club chasing a ruckman like Pies, Saints, Tigers etc and pick up another pick. When Meesen is cleared we would have White, two youngsters who will improve and PJ as backup. We could then concentrate on best pick at 4 and then some Key Position players with later picks. Miller may go giving us another pick. Grabbing Wood for TJ would force other clubs without rucks to deal for Jamar.

I wasn't suggesting he is worth two first rounders but rather that he is more than a second rounder as posted.

Think I have to agree. I would be more inclined to go TJ and Miller for Pick 11 and a third rounder to use on Meesen.

Who do you replace Carroll with at Full Back? I note he was nearly AA last year.

Johnathon Hay was swapped for two first round picks and you would swap Travis for one second round pick. Not me.

Agreed.

Gone. They swapped their second pick for Mattner. Unless they trade back into the second round or find a suitable swap a Miller deal with Swans is off.

This may stop any Miller trade to the Swans.

Thompson, Thompson ,Thompson.

You jest.

His girlfriend's sister's boyfriend's uncle had told the guy next doors' wife who passed it on to her cousin's friend's daughter in law who had once been to a football match that.........................

I just heard from a reliable source............

Amen.

What?

It was the same guy who gave $2.7million to stop us merging with Hawthorn and going out of business. Anyone else offered to tip in lately?

No they are looking for a new takeaway outlet for after training. Apparently the boys love the prawn crackers.

CJ was touted as a very good junior and we were all rapt when we got him.

CJ has played 13 games for the Dees. This season he played 8 games for 104 disposals an average of 13 per game, fairly handy one could say. He can play back or forward or wing. Good disposal and took 33 marks an average of 4 a game. Can play tall or short. They are about the same age. I think he is worth more than McKinley at this stage. CAC has plenty of room to do a deal if all parties are willing.

I am glad that CAC is in charge of our trading and not many of the posters on here. There seems to be a fixation with giving far more in trades than is needed. You suggest we swap players and swap picks giving them a higher pick. Why? Chris is 193 cms a high pick with several games under his belt. Ben is 184cms with 1 game to his credit. Who do you think is more valuable? Why would they be swapped and we get the worse pick?

Can someone please explain to me why this " gun " forward can't even get into their team regularlyl It seems we are eager to "love" players at other clubs and trash our own. I would look at him but I would think he is a pick 21 at best.

Thanks.

How do you measure a beep test? What is it recording?

Wonder if this could lead to being stripped of right to be a Company Director. If so goodbye Carlton Presidency.