Redleg

WJ good to see your cold has not robbed you of your common sense. We will not get Judd and we won't even be in the ballpark when the price is revealed. Not his salary or the trade cost. Your last line says it all. I hope he gets 1.5 million for 8 years from the Blues and that he costs plenty in a trade and in a few years we see the Blues supporters starting another election to get rid of this group that has destroyed them.

I knew you wouldn't let me down. Maybe they would throw in Kerr.

Sam Power ??????????

Where are you Rhino?

They had the opposite of us, few injuries.

Must disagree here Rhino a number of players trimmed down. I do agree that the reason for this needs to be ascertained before we go sacking people. I do believe however that BB was asked to trim the players down and he did that on the request of the Coach ND who wanted a running side. Someone can correct me if they actually know otherwise.

Another fisherman.

Still think Bizz and Byron should play out the year with Sandy and help them go for their fourth flag in a row. Could finish their careers playing in a premiership.

You sound like a Judge.

Do you wish to change your advice?

Agreed.

They were guessing. I have seen the incident now several times and the contact by Newton's shin to the back was nowhere "near high contact" and far softer than most marking duels. It looked bad front on but was nothing from the rear view as shown on Foxtel. The rear vision actually shows Newton trying to turn his body away from the player and he succeeded with evrything bar his shin. When I compare it to Buchanan's it is laughable. It was late but was minimal contact and he should at the very worst get it reduced to a reprimand if he doesn't beat the charge altogether.

And for several weeks previously.

Even though I was a supporter of Sheedy being appointed, for all of the reasons I have stated elsewhere, I am starting to warm to Bailey. The endorsements of him that are now being made public, such as Nathan Burke's " I wish I had played under him" and Mark Williams " he will be a very successful Coach" give rise to much optimism. The fact that he is prepared to fast track development of the younger players excites me and is something I have craved during Neale's tenure and was largely disappointed with. The fact that he sees players playing in different positions is also refreshing and demonstrates a flexibilty that is needed in todays football. His declaration that he wants to work with the players not have them work for him and that he wishes to hear their opinions is also refreshing. Lastly his comfort with the media and sense of humour is also an advantage in increasing the PR of the Club. I wish him the best of luck.

I am off to recheck the vision. I agree with reckless and low impact but it was not high contact as his shin contacted the players back. If the vision confirms this they should challenge it to bring it down to 1 point and then it becomes a reprimand. If however he can play for Sandy and it is seen as risky he can miss the first game next year, Neita should be fit for that one.

Just heard that Kreuzer has asked the AFL to stand out of this year's draft because he feels sick at the thought of playing with Carlton and would rather play soccer or try again next year.

Another fisherman.

Couldn't agree more. However I would also have added Weetra, for short bursts on the wing. He would have been in no danger as there wasn't a tackle laid. It would also have meant a few players dropping back to Sandy who would have won. That though is the lesser consideration. This was a game we would have won with Mrs. Redleg at full forward and her mother at CHF. It was a joke. For that reason why would you not have in the words of Rattan " tried every young player ".

He has improved week by week and is now kicking a goal. Has pace and a nice kick. Has got over his injuries and is a former All Australian. Needs more improvement but is a chance to become a regular.

Worst season I can recall and with less interest than I have ever experienced. Even 1981 I enjoyed more.

As Rhino has said on here many times players can only be traded if they are wanted by other clubs and most of the players we are trying to offload are not wanted. I disagree on Miller though, I think he has currency, as he can play both ends and for the right deal would be tradeable. However given the desire of many to delist Dutchy and Ferg ( who I would keep) Miller could become necessary as Rivers is alone in the key defence position.

Didn't look good at first live. When replayed several times on television he can be seen turning in mid air and only light contact with his shin to the back. If Buchanan's hit to the face front on was 1 week this can't be the same as contact is to the back and minor. If he is outed it could mean all the Sandy finals which is ridiculous.

To be fair, if we were playing for picks 1 and 3 we would do exactly the same.

We should have played Neville, Weetra, Garland and Buckley to in the words of Ratten try our young boys out. Four more senior players like Ward and Jamar could have gone back down to help Sandy and that way every player available is getting game somewhere. I find the selection pathetic considering the situation.

Ha Ha ! Jack will be in the passenger seat. Bring a spare chair for me. Scoop Jnr. may tag along as well.