KozzyCan

I think it's pretty fair tbh.

They had to cap dump a few years back and gave the cats a pick for the privilege.

Except we're getting a first rounder back in my scenario.

As perspective, last year we traded this year's first and pretty much all our second and third rounders to get Lindsay. A lot of people said it was overs at the time. I reckon we don't regret that deal.

~10 and 11

Outside of Mitch Clark has there ever been a player nominate one club before back flipping and joining another?

Meh we're rebuilding and getting 21 year old who can play the same role as Petracca is more important than 'winning' a trade by holding onto a bunch of picks we won't use anyway.

Offer Trac, F1 and whatever second/third round picks we have from Spargo, Oliver, May, McVee for Humphrey and 7 F1 would be enticing to GC as they wouldn't expect us to make finals next year. Second and third rounders we won't use anyway for points for academy blokes. First rounder they don't need back to us. People will say this is overs but it's the kind of deal the club has shown to be more than comfortable doing if it gets us our man.

Great mates with the Giants boys it seems.

So Oliver had a planned trip to the states with an overnight layover in Sydney that conveniently gave him the opportunity to jump on a boat with the Giants team in between? What luck! Think there was a bit happening behind the scenes.

It's a big swing. Never guaranteed to come off. Consolation prize is a cultural reset and some first rounders.

No one really believes this. We are offering to pay more than 50% of his contract to see the back of him. We are salary dumping to make a big play at Flanders and Humphrey.

Reckon Petracca wasn't the reason we had small crowds lol.

Grow up.

Totally agree, and allows the admin to be located in the same building as the players.

This is the ballsiest trade period I can remember from Melbourne.

Btw is Smith now officially president?

Plan B if Caufield somehow falls over sounds like there has been a decent setback.

Or. Adelaide are saving face by saying they didn't want him anyway.

Bit of a sidebar but isn't this reportedly the situation with Jackson?

They were probably keen to get him on the cheap which we weren't willing to compromise on last year. This year he could be a bargain.

Geelong were definitely courting him.

Other clubs can get involved.

Curnow would be how Carlton unlocks it.

Sounds like Flanders has picked the Saints.