ElDiablo14

Beg to differ. JVR is very competitive and he is one of our most accurate kicks. He may not be perfect but at the very least he should be a B+ or A grade player in a functioning system.

How come he couldn't bring a KPF after the flag? We knew it was the last piece of the puzzle, McKay was gettable. Yet not much fuzz or noise about it throughout the 2022 season.

Sad but true, I suppose we'll have to use the same strategy as we did in 2015-2016, bring some veterans on good deals and with premiership pedigree (Jordan Lewis type).

On Petracca, as opposed to butchering kicks inside 50? At least he's a good contested mark and maybe he can score 1.1 on average and may be good enough as a HF, he can still support the midfield. Maybe 60 - 40 split between HF and Midfield.

This. Once we can actually connect well with our forwards, it will make things easier for our young guns like JVR and Jeffo. Then you can start dreaming about luring a KPF.

Not much we can do but the 2021 core should be looked at. Salem Oliver Petracca Lever? May - nothing to do here, just one more year Max - heart and soul Viney - same as above Fritsch ? - finding some good form TMac - Playing very good footy, not sure if he would like to go again next year Spargo - not much market value Melksham - keep him for one more year and then make him our new kicking coach! Petty - he should go back to be May's replacement, if he is committed to the club Kozzy - our shining light Rivers - should become full time mid field Bowey - our most improved player Sparrow - not sure what to do with him

I think our young brigade is waiting for an outcome on Goodwin. If he's kept as the SC for next year look at many of our young guns to re-think their future with the MFC unfortunately.

In Hindsight it looks like that was a big mistake. Letting him go and extending Simon until 2026.

I think Max Gawn mentioned this in the morning. Apparently they got a warning during the second quarter. Success has many fathers, failure is an orphan.

What do you think is more embarrassing? Losing down at Mordor with a nothing list? Or is it a 46 point capitulation with a team full of premiership players? Simple question, simple answer. Probably both equally embarrassing but at least the 186 has the caveat that the club was a basket case and full young inexperienced players. Yesterday? No excuses!

The one thing missing was the perennial kiss of death to the coach "Simon Goodwin has the boards full support to steer the ship".

On top of my head Collingwood 2017 Sydney 2018 Geelong 2018 Freo 2020 SYDNEY 2020 That's even before the flag.

I think Max Gawn mentioned this in the morning. Apparently they got a warning during the second quarter.

Even Bevo survived longer. I don't think Goodwin will have a job any time soon once he departs the MFC. Unless he is willing to go back to being an assistant.

Let's be realistic. Are you planning to move on Petracca, Oliver, Salem, etc in one off season? Is that even feasible?

You can sack him, doesn't matter who comes as interim. They have plenty of time to look for the right replacement. This season is cooked.

Significant? At least 3 I think.

You aim for the moon even if only to fly

How can this guy keep his job for even one more game? The decline is out there for all to see.

Don't know. But I'd definitely like Jetta and Brayshaw back to the club in some form of leadership role.

Please don't be too condescending e, my question was genuine. I am not advocating for violence, I was surprised to learn that the picture was his actual car.

Is Christian 2025 the same as Christian 2021?

Can you imagine a world where Yze takes over Simon at the end of 2024. Gus and Neville Jetta would be great additions at the club from a culture and leadership perspective.

Dogga for Petracca and Oliver?