old55

I don't know ... but Bassett has gone and Rivers has arrived so I'm guessing Rivers is backline coach. Chaplin is retained so I'm guessing he's forward line coach again, what else? Jones has been reffered to as midfield coach and Atkins has just arrived and I doubt it's as forward line coach. Scarlett to assist Rivers and Hawkins to assist Chaplin.

I never even knew about the goal square rule in 6-6-6 😀

NWM, Ash, D.Rioli, N.Martin, Amon, Blakey, Noble, Impey ...

I watched 5 minutes of highlights and I shouldn't because I'm a hopeless judge of junior talent, but I didn’t see him run with ball at all and that concerns me for the role he plays. Yes nice, quick distribution over varying distances which is very good and "first option" is a great mindset. But I also want to see some line breaking 80-90m run and kick plays mixed in there too for the role.

IMO we should continue to focus on Bailey Humphrey despite having to trade for him. Let other clubs battle it out for these guys.

So in other words you'd get rid of Chandler, Fritsch and Sparrow? Seriously, there is no way any of them are staying on 2 year contracts.

The points discount is 10% but then it's locked in at 195pts after round 1. Pick 43 is worth 184pts, so from there the discount outweighs the cost so no picks are required to match. 37 to 43 is a tight window so we'd have to be very unlucky, mind you 37 should come in a fair way as picks get eaten up matching bids, so the window will be wider.

Robey presented well on Gettable, very confident but not arrogant. I like his Eastern jumper number too. Hopefully if we get him he retains it.

But do two Whites make it wrong?

Chris Connolly

Jeff White

Two at present and they're both from WA. We've got Lingers.

Yes I feel very similar. Except I've liked Freo, at least partly because they're not WC. Why aren't you keen?

A bit much Bowey...

I was expanding on the idea if we really want to trade up for Robey in my head, which might be partly activated by not loving the talent at 7 and 8 ... From above: Our F1 + 7 to WC for 2 + 13 That leaves us with 2, 8, 13 and GC F1 Then if we did 8 to Port for their F1 that would leave us with 2, 13, Port F1, GC F1 which is a better spread. All along we'd have to love Robey and Port would have to love an SA prospect. I agree with others that the neatest outcome would be to use 7 and 8, and retain the two F1s for next year for another hit at Humphrey or to take to a better draft. But I was just speculating alternatives.

There are quite a few SA prospects in Twomey's top 30. Five in the first 20 and nine in the first 30. I think that's a lot more than usual and SA won the championship, unbeaten. It's a curious position for Port to take.

Nothing. I'm assuming Port finish in a similar ladder position and the next draft is stronger. Port's F1 for 7 or 8.

The alternatives are far less desirable. I'm grateful Oliver and Petracca didn't go to any of them. That would have been a hard watch.

I wonder if Port would do F1 for 7 or 8 to get access to Schubert or Marsh?

And not just to Coaches

I like GWS, if we couldn't win the flag, I've hoped they do. That stays the same with Clarry at the club. I hope they win the flag and Clarry takes the Norm Smith. I'm less enthusiastic about Gold Coast.

I like GC, but I think I'll like them a bit less next year.

I think it's 8 and our F1 for 2 and 13 and we promise not to take WC's WA prospect at 7. Our F1 has a lot of value, clubs will think we finish 14th or worse next year. But we'd really want the player at 2 to do this.

2 is a lot more valuable than 3 because it's before any Richmond picks. And 3 is a lot more valuable than 4 because Richmond aren't going to trade their first pick but they would trade their second one. Despite points value, 7 and 8 isn't getting 2 and it isn't even getting 3 but it's too much for 4. Clubs will be thinking we finish bottom 6 next year, possibly bottom 4 or worse, so our F1 has a lot of value. They will also be thinking GC finishes top 6, possibly top 4 or better so that F1 has a lot less value. I think our F1 is probably about equal value with 7 and 8. Ask yourself whether you'd trade it for 7 and 8? Our F1 and 8 probably gets 2 and 13 provided we promise WC not to pick the WA guy at 7. We'd have to love Robey.

Other options urgently for what role? Berry is described as a 194cm mobile defender. We're very well stocked there.