Everything posted by old55
-
WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - HARLEY BENNELL
"Harley Bennell's Demon debut bigger than Chicxulub"
-
Cap May Squeeze Out Fritsch
You must've missed JV in R1?
-
Revised 2020 Fixture
It was in 1964 at least - where you are stuck.
-
Revised 2020 Fixture
Thanks for the help! Do you know if this is still valid: https://help.kayosports.com.au/s/article/How-to-Apply-my-Club-Member-Offer#New If so maybe I need to request an email from the club Edit: Looks like a "No" This offer is valid for redemption up until April 9, 2020.
-
Revised 2020 Fixture
Yes I have to pay extra for those devices though. It's a Sony Smart TV about 3 years old but it's not an Android model.
-
Revised 2020 Fixture
It is a decent outcome but IMHO all the games should be FTA. I don't have Foxtel and my Sony Smart TV is only a couple of years old but is not Android so doesn't support Kayo. If this was a normal season I would definitely be going to this match - I'm willing to pay for that but not Foxtel. How am I supposed to see this match?
-
TEAM: Rd 02 vs Carlton
Anyone know what's happening with TV coverage? I don't have Foxtel or Kayo and in the original fixture I was either going to the game or could see in on FTA for all but one game. Is this game going to be FTA? Under normal circumstances I think it wouldn't be but I would go to the game. I'll be [censored] off if I have to pay a subscription to see it.
-
Dees vs Hawks: Who’s Closer to a Flag
Hawthorn have to win it in the next 2 years because after that their list is totally stuffed. I think it is possible that they could win in that timeframe if everything goes right for them - they're at least equally as likely as us. But we've got 5-8 good years ahead to pull it off.
-
TEAMS: Rd 01 vs West Coast
I've posted this before but I cannot understand why this tactic isn't used more often, or at least kick to space if there is any. The amount of times I've seen us go in the air to say Jeffy one out against a tall defender drives me crazy. Just kick the dribbler, most players can do it. Kozzy one out vs Hurn with the dribbler coming in ...
-
TEAMS: Rd 01 vs West Coast
afl.com.au still doesn't have the final teams!
-
Coronavirus: AFL & MFC
This post is AFL related.
-
Coronavirus: AFL & MFC
I believe I heard Dr.Norman Swann on ABC's excellent Coronocast podcast: https://www.abc.net.au/radio/programs/coronacast/ That data from China suggests that about 80% of infections were undiagnosed. If that's the case in Australia our current infection tally is 700 (diagnosed) x 5 = 3,500. 25 million / 3,500 = approximately 1 in 7000 Australians are currently infected. Approximately 400 AFL footballers participating in R1. Likelihood that one is infected is approximately 1 in 18. You can make up your own mind whether it is reasonable or not to go ahead with the football.
-
PREGAME: Rd 01 vs West Coast Eagles
When are they flying out - do we know?
-
PREGAME: Rd 01 vs West Coast Eagles
Let's say they played 10 minute quarters - would that make a difference to recovery? Let's say they played 40 minute quarters - how about that? There's clearly some point that the duration of the quarters makes a difference and that has to be balanced with the spectacle as a match. They've gone for 16 minutes which sounds like a good compromise to me.
-
Coronavirus: AFL & MFC
They've got more than one ball. Have you seen behind kick-ins recently?
-
16-a-Side to Fix Scoring
You won't sell me with a boxing analogy. Like I said earlier then - why don't we just get every player to run a half-marathon before the game and don't change any rules then.
-
16-a-Side to Fix Scoring
Fatigued players just cannot play as well. This is a very simple concept to grasp.
-
16-a-Side to Fix Scoring
You've missed the point I'm trying to make. Many here are advocating a solution based on limiting rotations thus causing fatigue and therefore reducing congestion. But that is a poor solution.
-
16-a-Side to Fix Scoring
Fatigued players does not provide a better game, it means more skill errors and a poorer spectacle where players are unable to perform at their optimum. How can this be better? Maybe we should make all the players run a half marathon before the bounce eh? Less congestion because there's less players per square metre is a far superior solution.
-
16-a-Side to Fix Scoring
It's a great idea as @Dr. Gonzo and @Fat Tony say. For those who doubt less players wouldn't affect congestion. Would it be more congested with 30 per side, less with 10 per side? The way the game is played has changed and the rules need to adapt to maintain the free flowing essence. Decreasing the number of players is the least invasive rule change - in fact it doesn't actually change any in-game rules. 6-6-6 and zones are horrible misdirected actions. The sweet spot is likely to be 14-15 per side, and I'd keep the four interchange.
-
What is missing to win a flag?
FWIW, AFL Computer models - aggregated here by Squiggle predict us finishing 15th (13th - 16th) with 9 wins (8-10 wins). https://squiggle.com.au/ladder/ The "colour bar" on the RHS - the size of the "block" represents the likelihood the team will finish in that position. Top 4 = 5%, Top 8 = 19%, Bottom 4 = 37% You can click on each team to see the detailed prediction of each model. I'm not buying what they're selling but is that because I have more detailed knowledge of the MFC situation or because I'm an overly optimistic supporter?
- AVB
- AVB
- AVB
-
Most hated teams
Gold!