rpfc

I think you care what Leigh Matthews says more than Jack Watts does... He's probably much more concerned with impressing O'Donnell, Gotch, Mahoney, and Bailey. Those last names don't reach out and grab you, unless they literally reach out and grab you...

Well said. Green is the perfect example of someone who - like Jack - prefers to avoid contact (prefers, not actively tries) and has developed that side of his game to the point where he has little regard for his own safety in contests and regularly crashes packs. But, saying - or infering - the kid has no faults, or he has nothing major to work on - is naive. One thing I will say though is his workrate has improved out of sight - he's a quick learner.

How precious can we be? I have a solution for those who feel belittled by others for getting names wrong... Spell the name right. We all go after Underwood when she mistakes Dunn for Watts. All MFC players should be spelt properly on this site. That's a deliverable we can all stand by.

Newcomers to Demonland! You have experienced one of the mysteries of Demonland... Freak is the anti-oracle. For everything he says, shall be. In reverse, completely wrong, like the most polar opposite thing to whatever he posts. We marvel at his wrong-ness and wonder why and how... Why he doesn't realize and how come he won't stop posting his nonsense.

Positive: the 7 and a half wins Negative: the 14 and a half losses Yes, i thought winning 7 or 8 games would be a good result. But losing 15 or 14 games is unacceptable. Just unacceptable. Positive: the stretching of coll twice, and the bullies in very honourable losses. Negative: the acceptance of defeat by determining the disappointing losses to those teams as 'honourable.' Defeat may be apart of life but that doesn't mean you shouldn't go on pathetic hand-wringing and whingeing expedition of blood and blame letting that would rival the emotional breakdown of 2010 known as the Foster-Cockerill Disaster.

Mono calling for Bailey's head?!? Oh my, must be that time of the year...

E25 and Jaded are right. Plan B is a nonsense concocted by fans who think a gameplan can be changed at a whim and/or that small tactical changes are a new 'gameplan.' Morton behind the ball isn't a gameplan. People saying we should abandon our rushing handball, play on through the corridor with risk are those that want to change the gameplan. And they are kidding themselves.

The gameplan - our Plan A - is pretty bloody effective and exciting when the players are doing it properly. Those who complain about not having a plan B - please tell me why players who can't perform the gameplan they practice all the time should be able to, without notice, play a different style. And what style would that be? The chip around the boundary line crap that Coll play? We got back into the game yesterday by playing Plan A. At about 2.30...

You're wrong. The very fact that you likened Dunn to the Ox in his early days says everything I need to know about your footy IQ. Dunn looks like a footy player but his execution and decision making leave; much to be required and him in the VFL. If he is as arrogant as you intimate with his 'tell the coach' quip, then I suggest he deal with his issues and show Bailey what he can do in an AFL game. Lord knows Bailey isn't the only person not to see what Lyndon sees.

Oooohh, menacing. Don't worry about diplomacy; name them and I will tell you whether you're on the mark or not. And this is GM at your worst. Equating Mortons presence to our decline in form is not just specious - it's scurrilous.

To say that Martin or Johnson do as much in the forward line as Miller is naive. Miller has been disappointing but his work ethic outstrips every other forward and easily covers a kid new to the game (Martin) and someone who wishes he was a foot smaller than he is (Johnson). Johnson as depth is laughable considering what a second ruck, especially to a dominant Jamar, does during a match. This is why we don't play a second ruck - because there isn't a ruck in the top 30 players at the club and considering that most Hives albums go for longer than the time spent on the field by Jamar's understudy.

Awesome is a mark of varying interpretations. I don't think we can win the flag in 2012 (which is the thirty games) but I do think we can push the top 4 for most of the year. The issue lies with our talent - they will still be inexperienced. Aside from Morton - our best players: Watts, Jurrah, Petterd, Jetta, Bennell, Wonaeamirri, Scully, Trengove, McKenzie, Gysberts, Blease, and Tapscott, will have played less than 50 games, and in most cases, far less than 50 games. When you expect too much too soon, you make rash decisions when you don't reach the unrealistic goals you have set. We all thought Thompson should have gone, they kept the faith. Faith! And the rest is history, and future history.

We really should employ someone, on a full time basis, to be a forwards coach. Bailey, Connolly and Schwab should get together with Bailey having the most say on this proposed, and radical, "Forwards Coach." Is everyone still with me? Stay with me now. This "Forwards coach" will be charged with attempting accomplishments like; turning Petterd into a dangerous medium forward capable of kicking multiple goals, designing a forward structure that tears apart more seasoned teams like Brisbane and Port Adelaide, exposing young talent (Watts, Jetta, Bennell, and Wonaeamirri) while still being competitive. Sounds like a tough job and those expectations are rather extreme. I reckon Josh Mahoney would be good in that role. He certainly has the experience and the runs on the board...

That Brisbane game was in the pouring rain... Plenty of run and carry and short kicks too. Too bloody easy.

My god, Melbourne supporters are a bunch of self-righteous, self-indulgent pikers. If you meet with him, tell him your concerns. Mahoney is a genius after the Brisbane game and a dud after the Carlton game. Honestly, if I wasn't one - I'd hate Melbourne supporters.

Not this again?! If we were winning noone would give a sh!t. Walls had a go at Carlton's white strip a couple years back but now they are winning he hasn't said a damn thing. This is people releasing their frustration through anger at side issues. Yeah, we are playing badly but expectations went too high too soon.

Well said. I cannot believe fans think that players not executing properly is a reason to abandon a gameplan. The time to abandon a gameplan is when players are executing but it doesn't result in wins. Plan B is like this mythical go-to criticism of those that don't know what they are criticising. What would be a Plan B for the MFC, something akin to what Collingwood play? Go around the boundary? They are executing that perfectly, and doesn't work a treat against Geelong and St Kilda?

He needs a kick up the arse that's for sure. Someone to yell at him that if he doesn't keep his feet or get in front - he'll be off. Keep him in. I don't think two games is enough rope. Hell, Miller has had over a hundred...

You must pleasure yourself everytime a young Demon miskicks a footy. Honestly...

North and WCE were hardly great games for our tall defenders with Goldstein, Hale, Kennedy, Lynch, and McKinley doing quite a bit. Rivers has 'zoning off' in his DNA - but it is only valuable if midfielders pressure the kick in to the forwardline by Judd, Gibbs, and Murphy. Rivers will get dropped if his form doesn't reverse, of course. I didn't mean this to be Rivers vs Warnock. My primary point is that fans live so much in the imediate week to week of AFL that they can't see that good players get dropped early in their career (McKenzie) and when they are performing below what the team requires (Warnock, Martin, MacDonald) but it does not mean it is the end of their career or that the coaching staff, or they themselves, have 'given up.'

God, you can't drop a bloke can you?! You all go nuts whenever any good player gets dropped. It's apart of footy. You play a few shockers and you get dropped. Warnock has played a few, and, to me, was inexplicably overawed by Podsiadly - didn't watch the ball, unsure in tackling, paid him too much respect. Rivers has been equally poor, but like Garland - has other strings. Garland has a decent attacking instinct, and Rivers is one of the best and selfless readers of the play in the game.

The game starts and ends in the middle.

The life of a Melbourne supporter - fear the worst, and revel in being the first to fear what eventually happens. It's a defence mechanism. Let's grow: Scully will play 250 games for the dees and win a flag or two. Anything else would be disappointing.

I feel like a Black Bear. Grrr.

Not going to bite on this one, Grimes is a very good kick. And one of the best 22 gamers going around. Maybe you should find another dead horse to [censored], Freak. Hmmm?