BW511

I’d argue that trying to take hangers and iron out blokes is more around his desire to have an impact. I think this comes when things aren’t going right for him. As I said, it’s confidence in letting the game come to him, rather than trying to force it.

I think Kossie’s biggest weakness is he’s a confidence player. We seem to have a lot of them. The best thing he could do is stop worrying about being tough and start focusing on the footy more. Spargo has limitations but he’s well aware of them and very rarely do his mistakes hurt us like Kossie’s do

This is my pet peeve with our side. Half of our forwards are defenders first and it’s left to too few generating scores. The balance is not quite right

After last week and now, last night, I think Brisbane actually win it this year. I want GWS to do it but think Brisbane have the best mix. Walsh played like a man that really, really wanted to win. Big games demand it and he was brilliant

I’m all for a refresh on the coaching staff, we need to rejuvenate the club after a pretty somber end to the last two seasons. I’d be looking at players 3-5 years out of the game or even recently retired. Cotchin would be a great get, helped change the culture of Richmond with Dimma and played a very selfless role on field. Seems to have great character. Maybe a Jack Gunston type if he moves back to Melbourne, he’s been involved in very high end forward groups

Petty is one of the best aerial players in the game, I’d be surprised if lots of clubs don’t ask the question. If he goes, we are in strife

I’d also be asking the club to have a think about the role Jake Lever plays. He is an excellent interceptor but in the same manner as our forwards being defenders first, he’s not flash at actually defending. I don’t think there’s any reason for a captaincy change, I certainly wouldn’t be giving it to Trac.

I think the coaching staff also owe a few blokes an apology over the preseason/exit period. They may all be gone but Tommo, Laurie, Woey, Dunstan, Melk, Hibbo, Ben Brown, JJ and Spargs could all feel hard done by. They may not be the absolute best option at times but selection integrity has been a disaster. We’ve stuck with a system and group of players that have fallen short for two years straight. Ultimately, the stubbornness and system have failed that group and the club in general. I think there will be considerable movement over this off-season and we’ll find the club isn’t quite as harmonious as it should be

The strategy in our forward half is to be defensive first, it’s what I mean by stifling our players. The only player who is allowed to play as a genuine attacking forward is Fritsch and unsurprisingly, he kicks goals. The gameplan and strategy needs to loosen up to allow pure offence because the defence first version is being shown up year after year.

We need a re-think on the type of player we are drafting/recruiting. McAdam seems to be a shift in that mindset. Being combative is important and has kept us around the mark but the limitations on our playing group are overwhelming. We are exposed for height between HBF & HFF, we lack elite ball users nor do we value them, our gameplan stifles opposition but hurts us even more. Development of players seems to have come to a screeching halt beyond Judd McVee who has been absolutely phenomenal - yes, he made a couple of errors but no more than our leaders/best players do weekly. Our 3 best players, Clarry, Trac and Max have become almost ineffective. They get great stats but what the team gets from them is of far less value. Its’s just so disappointing to be here again and I hope we can address the mental side of our game and double down on ball use

Gut feel, our list is not as strong as people think. Our best 3 players let us down horribly with their skills at key moments

May 6. Rest, better luck in 2024

Being defensive keeps you in games but it doesn’t win you games

Be nice if the 2021 version of Langdon poked his head in

Not sure Petty played any more than 7?

If what you are saying is true, this is the unicorn I have been dreaming of

JVR > Grundy, every day of the week. Despite not hitting the scoreboard, he’s contesting and his ruck work has been really good for such a young kid

Interesting that JVR was excluded, surely if we win he comes straight back in.

Grundy suits the SCG and will make Sydney instantly better.

Langdon and Hunter would want to have huge pre-seasons. Would love to draft a highly skilled mid to enter the rotation and lessen the reliance on Clarry/Gus/Viney.

I hope one of them snaps him up, for his sake and ours

Watching GWS highlights our need for better ball users between HBF & HFF.If I can be real greedy, I’d like them to be 185cm+ and with some pace. Sounds like McAdam might be a start, and then at least one more from there.

I am really struggling to see how people think Maynard’s thought process was anything other than ‘if I don’t get the smother, I’ll take a body’. His intent may not have been to absolutely hurt Brayshaw, but he definitely made the decision to jump knowing body contact would happen. This is where it begins and ends, he went ahead with his chosen action knowing contact would happen. NBA players can run full steam at players to try and block passes/shots in the exact same fashion and this outcome doesn’t occur.

Such a great way of putting it. Stupidly, I read your post at 3am after my 3yo had just woken me up. Spent the next 90 minutes thinking about the Brayshaw and Frawley families and what they are going through. I’ve also had a similar train of thought but related to the smother attempt. If the smother actually worked and the ball was live in the area, I guarantee he lands with his hands ready to push off Brayshaw and win the ball back. The whole thing stinks, if Maynard cared for Brayshaw in the manner he said, it would have been the first thing he mentioned when they interviewed him. Instead he was already pleading his case. I liken it to someone being upset for being caught, rather than for the act itself.

The giants play bloody good football, good to watch and their top end is absolutely elite