BW511

Straight out of the Dimma playbook Even with their premiership legacy, I reckon both Dimma and Dusty will be a little unpopular with the way this has all played out

My brother was playing footy in QLD at the time Jack Martin was playing late years of juniors. All everyone would talk about was how good he was. Hard to believe it’s amounted to so little

This suggests Parfitt is probably grossly undervalued and should be on our radar for the ANB role - if we stick to the current method

Lever 2017, May 2018 and Langdon 2019 were all quality. Following that we have landed Brown in 2020 and Grundy in 2022, who were both pushed out of their respective clubs. Hardly shooting the lights out but as I said, the trade pool is always very shallow

I can agree with that. He’s really neat and tidy but never the one to create the move. His kicking in particular is very safe

His contribution earlier in the year was certainly better, when we were playing the faster and more attacking gamestyle. He suffers from the same thing everyone else does, spend all their tickets defending space and have zero left when it counts. There’s certainly limitations in what Jack can do as a footballer but he’s being asked to be something he’s not, particularly when he was probably sold a very different story on recruitment. I should add, I’m not a Jack Billing’s superfan, far from it, but every player that had an ounce of attack in our squad has slowly been ground down to become a defensive robot

Wow. That’s a lot of money on a bloke that doesn’t have a set position

If there is an example of a bloke not suiting our game style, it is Jack Billings. If we transitioned to the faster, more skill based method, he could potentially add a lot more impact - not saying he will but it wouldn’t hurt to try

It’s not like 100 players are changing clubs every year, so we are starting a long way back when compared to the Hawks and Cats (Culture/Reputation etc) Then you have the deep pockets of Collingwood, Richmond and Carlton. At absolute best, we are 6th in line of the Melbourne clubs, more realistically, we are behind a few others too

Is Cerra known for running defensively? If he goes both ways, I’d take him as an upgrade on Sparrow for sure. Certainly finds the ball more than Tom

I think Trac and the review into FD will demand our system changes, makes it hard to know who will suit us in 2025. I think we need a Walsh or Andy Brayshaw type who is ultra consistent and dependable, not necessarily a game breaker but just does the hard/team orientated stuff each week.

For minimal currency, I would put some very serious consideration into it. He’s been a good player for a long time. He’s at 1.6 goals a game (293 total) versus Fritta at 1.8 goals a game (252 total), he’s also the same height and 10kg heavier. Some extra pressure on Melk/Turner/Fritta would be welcomed - I don’t see Melk as guaranteed games next year as he was patchy at best

I’d love to see Kolt permanently take ANB’s spot and transition the role into a more rounded/attacking version for 2025 and beyond. Can certainly appreciate what our Half forward rotation have done defensively in years gone by but have always felt we are spending too much energy defensively. Pick 5 needs to go to a mid with serious skill and some breakaway pace. We don’t need another Trac, we need someone who compliments Trac and Clarry

No way Houston gets them any further into September

A fit, confident and aggressive Oliver would be a welcome sight in 2025. If he can get there, we are in for a treat. It’s a big if, though.

Surely Watson and Dear convince everyone that the draft is the only way to go with pick 5. Couple of first year blokes with a very solid impact

While you are on a roll @goodwindees, any action for this thread?

Going all in on trying to keep Trac beyond 2025 then

Weren’t the media all liars, in your eyes, during the Petracca saga?

Houston has said he’s staying https://amp.abc.net.au/article/104290300

That’s not a fair comparison, even though Christian had very real issues with the club, his situation was almost entirely his own doing. Houston and Port are playing chess with each other but Houston is not burning Port to the ground in the process

He’s got good patience when he needs it too, doesn’t panic and dish off for no reason.

There has to be some smoke here, every club needs this type of player, you don’t let one walk with no proper reason.

That’s some guaranteed game time right there

I’m also a little on the fence about him, terrific stats and year, concerned how he fares at AFL level with a lot more congestion and bigger bodies. A lot of times he would be killing his teammates with handball at AFL level